What do the culture makers and shapers of New York think of this year’s crop of movies, political impersonations, museum shows, and YouTube clips? To find out, we polled 129 people from across the arts—from Harvey Weinstein to the director of the Hip-Hop Dance Conservatory. We were looking for what was best, but couldn’t help asking for opinions on other matters, too. (Paul Rudd’s stock is up; Judd Apatow’s, not so much.) Above, this year’s wisdom of the smart crowd.