Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.


Three critics with different musical tastes offer competing takes on recent noteworthy kid-friendly albums.


The smash Beatles-for-kids compilation All Together Now was only the beginning. Our panel reviews five albums that both you and your tot can stand to listen to. Again and again. And again.

1 = Skip it
5 = Try it
10 = Buy it

(Illustrations by James Taylor)  

Barbara the Musical Mom
On maternity leave from touring with kids’-rock star Dan Zanes on ukulele. Brought two sets of parents and children in for review session. Her 3-month-old, Magdalena, is into Kirsty MacColl’s Tropical Brainstorm for dancing around and Arlo Guthrie’s Hobo’s Lullaby for nap time.

Luke the Literary Dad
Working musician turned literary agent. Once listened to a lot of Sabbath, now mellows out with Sparklehorse and Air, and raises 3-year-old August, who loves Giant Drag and fronts rock outfit Heavyfoot alongside Davis Diamond, spawn of Beastie Boy Mike D.

Keshia the Nanny
Brooklyn–by–way–of–St. Lucia undergrad swears by the reggae of her Caribbean youth but has grudgingly grown tolerant of the kids’ music she’s subjected to on the job. Says impromptu dance parties are a common work hazard.

Lil' J Xavier  

Kids Rap Radio: Vol. 1 & 2
Various Artists
A two-volume collection on which a cadre of anonymous prepubescent rappers—a.k.a. the Giggle Club—record cleaned-up versions of top rap hits.

BARBARA [Rating: 8]: [Parents] Cass and Jim liked this one best. It’s pretty pared down, apart from the eighties-drum-machine sounds, and the household-friendly lyrics and high proportion of girl rappers are unusual. Sam [age 6] listened for a moment and said, “This sounds like a kid is talking,” which intrigued him—maybe because the lyrics are easy to understand—and Henry [age 4] said it was “fun.”
Best track: "Back Then"

LUKE [Rating: 9]: I thought this was going to be lame. I was picturing little kids throwing gang signs … ugh. It is, however, really, really good. Great hooks, really nice and empty production, and great emcees with cute little voices and surprisingly good flows. “At dinnertime I try to get my eat on / But I can’t have dessert till my peas gone”—does it get any better than that? My only complaint is that it’s a bit similar from track to track.
Best track: "Lil Bit"

KESHIA [Rating: 5]: It’s funny to listen to popular rap songs made non-explicit, but I’m not a fan. Some rap albums fail to address positive messages and are filled with songs about materialism, and this is no different, just in a kiddie version.
Best track: "Lil Bit"

‘Open Season’ Soundtrack
Paul Westerberg
The famously hard-living Replacements front man goes PG, recording a collection of rootsy originals for an animated kids’ picture starring a deer and a bear.

BARBARA [Rating: 9]: Well, this one immediately brought back memories of drinking beer in the dorm room. It still sounds like Paul Westerberg—just his lyrics have changed. This got the repeated-listening stamp of approval from four out of five parents, and I think Jim, the holdout, was just being contrary. Cass noted that the sound was “pitched towards parents,” but to me it was just good.
Best track: "Meet Me in the Meadow"

LUKE [Rating: 7]: The first song, “Meet Me in the Meadow,” almost sounds like Prince when he wrote pop songs. The thing is, if it weren’t the soundtrack to a major-studio animated feature, it’d just sound like a really nice pop album by a happy Replacements—not a kids’ album but an album some kids might like, in a passive kinda way.
Best track: "Meet Me in the Meadow"

KESHIA [Rating: 6]: I can’t decide yet whether I like it or not. The songs are long and slow, and don’t succeed in keeping my attention. But it does have catchy hooks and melodies. Maybe for long, long trips in the car.
Best track: "I Wanna Lose Control"

The Donnas  

Brats on the Beat: Ramones for Kids
Various Artists
An impressive collection of punk-rock veterans (Alkaline Trio, the Donnas, Pennywise) plus a kiddie chorus belt out Ramones classics. The album’s a benefit project for St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital.

BARBARA [Rating: 5]: All of these sound pretty identical—true to their inspiration—and I was bored by the time track two came up. The upbeat tempos inspired dancing from the boys, however, and enthusiastic banging on things from the 10-month-old. I would never play this to a baby, however; it’s too relentless. I’m also biased—if I want to hear Ramones songs, why not just put on a Ramones album?
Best track: "Sheena Is a Punk Rocker"

LUKE [Rating: 5]: The Ramones were the ultimate kids’ band right out of the 1974 box. Witty and childish, amazing attitude, awesome cartoon look—they were perfect. So this just feels like Ramones Lite to me. I feel bad saying that because they’re raising money for St. Jude’s. But what’s next? Velvet Underground for kids? Wait a minute … I would buy that one for sure.
Best track: "Suzy Is a Headbanger"

KESHIA [Rating: 8]: I was a little hesitant that a kiddified version of classic Ramones songs would be any good, but the production is full of energy and life. I love that they have kids singing all the choruses and background parts—it makes it a little more entertaining.
Best track: "Rockaway Beach"

Current Issue
Subscribe to New York

Give a Gift