New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Catching Up to the Joneses

Phylicia Rashad and Sean Combs do what it takes to leave Chicago’s South Side.


Pauline Kael, always wicked and occasionally wrong, once told readers of Harper’s that the lesson to be learned from A Raisin in the Sun is “that a Negro family can be as dreary as a white family.” This isn’t criticism, of course. It’s more like anthropological slumming, as if Raisin, Death of a Salesman, and Long Day’s Journey Into Night were alternative bus stops in the same despondent boondocks. And yet Kael’s snooty disdain is not much different from the consensus enthusiasm for Lorraine Hansberry’s play. Hasn’t it been so celebrated for 50 years precisely because it suggests that all American families, regardless of color, are deep down alike, with the same wise mama, preferred uplift, and suburban, middle-classy aspirations?

ABC’s three-hour television-movie version of the recent Broadway revival of Raisin, with Phylicia Rashad as the widowed matriarch, Lena Younger; Sean Combs as her son, Walter Lee Jr.; Sanaa Lathan as her daughter, Beneatha; and Audra McDonald as Walter’s wife, Ruth, is a splendid chance to see the play for the complicated creature it’s always been—angry, funny, dreamy, ferocious amidst its ambiguities, at war with and forgiving of the stereotypes it embodies and transcends. As the Youngers wait on the South Side of Chicago for the $10,000 life-insurance check their husband and father died for, notice first that they aren’t middle-class; Lena and Ruth are domestics and Walter a chauffeur. Notice next that the house Lena longs for, out of the ghetto, isn’t in the tony suburbs; it’s among working-class whites in a blue-collar neighborhood. What the Nigerian intellectual Joseph Asagai (David Oyelowo), Beneatha’s surprise suitor, thinks about “integration” and “assimilation” is not exactly “Kumbaya.” And the excitable Beneatha, who has taken lessons in photography, horseback riding, and guitar, who wants to go to medical school and Africa, sounds the several selves of the playwright Hansberry. Young, gifted, and black herself, she admitted of no impediments until cancer took her at age 34.

Obviously, Raisin said prescient things about class and gender that most of us failed to hear in 1959, when it opened on Broadway, or in 1961, when the same cast, with Sidney Poitier and Claudia McNeil, appeared in the film. Some of this failure wasn’t our fault. We only discovered in 1989, when “American Playhouse” mounted a public-TV version with Danny Glover and Esther Rolle, that a number of passages on class, violence, feminism, and African nationalism (not to mention Beneatha’s Afro) had been abbreviated or omitted from the original stage production. They are mostly restored here, too, and more valuable than the attempts to open up the set to the rich interiors and pastoral climes of white employers. Actually, Raisin works well on television, like so many other fifties plays that tended toward the Freudian and claustrophobic, with their Munch-scream close-ups and slammed Ibsen doors.

Phylicia Rashad’s Lena flirts with complacency, perhaps insufficiently troubled by fraying kinships. Sean Combs knows what Walter Lee is supposed to feel, which isn’t the same as our feeling it, too; his crybaby is better than his cynic. Audra McDonald can do no wrong, even when she’s not allowed to sing; Ruth’s visit to the abortionist is a wordless wonder. Sanaa Lathan you may recall from Love and Basketball, where she evoked Yeats on Maud Gonne (“beauty like a tightened bow”); her rash Beneatha stops the heart. There are long sufferings in these little rooms, which may be why the plant is hiding on the fire escape. But there is also a deep choral meditation, as contradictory and creative as the contending views of W.E.B. DuBois and Zora Neale Hurston, of Richard Wright and Ralph Ellison, of Toni Morrison and August Wilson, of Kara Walker’s silhouettes and George C. Wolfe’s Colored Museum. “If I am not who you say I am,” James Baldwin once explained to white America, “then you are not who you think you are.”

Current Issue
Subscribe to New York

Give a Gift