Emily Nussbaum Archive

Intra-Dharmite color, sparkly dialogue, psychedelic torture, only a dash of Kate, plus the most insane ending since they jumped off the Island.

Show, you are so strange and inconsistent, why do we love you? Clearly you are our wonderful, awful Kate.

This was basically our dream episode, full of spooning, miracle births, Alpert eyeliner jokes, and four-toed statues!

John Locke, best (and most original) character on the show, light of our life, fire of our loins, anti-hero of our favorite episodes!

We return to the Island with strategic narrative slices removed just to mess with our heads.

We don't rate episodes, but hey: B+?

The plot gods have enriched us beyond measure.

"I hate to bust up the 'I'm an Other, You're an Other' reunion," snarks Sawyer.

We're time-traveling — although with so many rules and restrictions, Michael J. Fox will never be able to invent rock and roll.

She still seemed like someone capable of handling anything. Then in last week's episode, Joan's power turned against her.

New York Magazine