New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Best of New York 2012 • Eating

Best Pizza

  • Don Antonio by Starita

    309 W. 50th St., nr. Eighth Ave.; 646-719-1043

    Funny the way these so-called Neapolitan-pizza purists are the ones touting all the wacky new pizzas these days. First it was anchovies and mozzarella together on one pie, then it was creamed corn and ham. Before you could ask “what’s next, a turkey-and-cranberry calzone?” along came the montanara. A montanara, in case you didn’t know, is a round of dough that’s flash-fried, molded into a pan, topped in the minimalist margherita fashion of the day, sprinkled with some sharp grated cheese, then given a quick tanning-booth session in the wood-burning oven. It’s the hardest-­working pie in the pizza business, and has been proliferating ever since ­Giulio Adriani unleashed the thing at Forcella in Williamsburg last summer. Every version we’ve tasted is delicious, in the way you’d imagine deep-fried, cheese-topped dough would be, but our current infatuation is with the montanara Starita at the new Don Antonio. Their take benefits from the secret Starita sauce (don’t ask; they won’t tell) and the application of smoked buffalo mozzarella, which contrasts ever so delectably with the faint sweetness of the dough.

From the 2012 Best of New York issue of New York Magazine

Order the Issue Today

Cover of New York Magazine's Best of New York issue

Order This Issue

Other Best Of Guides

So what exactly does “best” mean in a city with thousands of pizza joints, hundreds of celebrity masseuses, and museum-worthy concept shops on every corner? Well, in the case of this, our annual “Best of New York” roundup, there’s a heavy emphasis on what’s new or what has somehow remained virtually unheard of (until now, of course).