New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Vulture

Edited by Dan Kois & Lane Brown

 

Backlash

4/ 8/08

1:45 PM
Like this article?
Buzz up on Yahoo!

Will Charges of Inaccuracy Bring Down ‘Bringing Down the House’?

Courtesy of Free Press

Much has already been made about the liberties Hollywood took when translating Ben Mezrich's nonfiction book Bringing Down the House into the surprise-hit MIT card-counting thriller 21 (for instance, in real life, the book's protagonist — played onscreen by Jim Sturgess— was actually Asian and never had hot, athletic sex with Kate Bosworth). Now, doubts are being raised about the accuracy of House itself, with the Boston Globe's Drake Bennett blasting Mezrich who he says, "appears to have worked more as a collage artist, drawing some facts from interviews, inventing certain others, and then recombining these into novel scenes that didn't happen and characters who never lived."

Among other, more minor alleged inventions, House — which carries a disclaimer explaining that names, locations, and other details have been changed, and that some characters are composites — includes scenes in which the film's heroes smuggle cash through airport security inside laptop computers, hollow crutches, and Velcro bags strapped to their bodies; the real people those characters were based on claim that never actually happened. Also, in the book, the students are trailed by a private detective with "narrow ice-blue eyes" who beats up one of them in a casino bathroom. According to the real-life inspiration for the beating victim, this never happened either.

For his part, Mezrich says "The idea that the story is true is more important than being able to prove that it’s true," but whatever — going forward, it's probably safest to assume everything you read anywhere is completely untrue. Unless you read it on Kanye West's blog, obviously.

House of Cards [Boston Globe]
Is “Bringing Down the House” a Fraud? [Paper Cuts/NYT]

Earlier: Breaking Down the Movie ‘21’ Should Have Been

Advertising
Vulture Features

Movies | TV | Music | Video | Books | Theater | Art

Art Candy: One new artwork, every day.

Beef: Cultural rivalries and confrontations.

Chat Room: Entertainment and culture Q&As.

The Comics Page: Excerpts from new graphic novels.

The Early-Evening News: So what the hell happened today?

The Industry: The morning trade news roundup.

Kudos: Awards news, buzz, and predictions.

Leak of the Week: Listening in on the file-sharing networks.

The List: Culture by the numbers.

Overnights: Recaps of TV shows.

Right-Click: The hottest new MP3s.

Trailer Mix: Movie trailers reviewed.

Tube Junkie: Nuggets from the online video archives.

Vulture Picture Palace: Exclusive short films.

All Vulture Features »