A week ago, Taylor Swift was getting crappy reviews for her off-key Grammys performance — and now she's getting crappy reviews for her acting. Of the hundreds of thespians in this weekend's Valentine's Day, Variety says she's the worst: "Some teen viewers may be drawn by the lure of the two Taylors, but their time onscreen together arguably reps the film's low point; Swift, especially, seems entirely undirected, as she jumps around, makes faces and jabbers on inanely." Too bad her role didn't require her to feign surprise. [Variety]
The Precious backlash: still happening! In an op-ed in today's Times, Ishmael Reed asserts that "Among black men and women, there is widespread revulsion and anger" over the film, which "wasn't made for them." Also, Reed worries that Oprah and Barbara Bush's attempts to make Precious a "teaching tool" might suggest that "incest is widespread among black families." Then he totally spoils the movie's ending. [NYT]
Record Label Tries to Quell Taylor Swift Backlash
While winning four Grammys on Sunday night may indeed have been the biggest accomplishment of young Taylor Swift's life, it didn't come without a price. Thanks to her tone-deaf caterwauling during a duet with Stevie Nicks and the disingenuous manner in which she delivered her acceptance speeches, the Taylor Swift backlash has been raging for the better part of the last three days. Strangely (and somewhat tellingly), no one in her camp exactly rushed to her defense. Until now!
If you thought the Slumdog backlash ended when the film picked up an Oscar for Best Picture, well, you were wrong. You see, it turns out that little Rubina Ali just shot a commercial with Nicole Kidman and Ridley Scott for an unnamed soft-drink company, one for which she was paid a handsome appearance fee. And also one that Fleet Street is now spinning as making her more money than what she was paid for Slumdog. Correct us if we've got it twisted, but isn't this a good thing? [Daily Mail]
Advertising
"The Bagger was never a Dark Knight advocate, because of an unsatisfying third act and because Mr. Bale insisted on making his Batman a low-talking oddlet, with a voice that was more comic than menacing. The Bagger always wondered why no one stepped to Mr. Bale and told him it wasn’t working — now I guess we know why. He seems, well, sort of sensitive." David Carr (a.k.a. the Bagger) [Carpetbagger/NYT]
Slumdog Filmmakers Strike Back
With ten Oscars on the line, Slumdog Millionaire director Danny Boyle, along with producer Christian Colson and a Fox Searchlight spokesperson, have released a statement rebutting charges of exploitation that appeared in Tuesday's Telegraph. In it, they reiterate the previously reported lengths to which they went to compensate child actors Rubina Ali and Azharuddin Ismail — in addition to paying wages that were "three times the average local annual adult salary," the filmmakers are also funding their educations, health care, and basic living expenses, and have set up trust funds from which the actors will receive a "substantial lump sum" upon completion of school. Also, just to be safe, Dev Patel has agreed not to participate in WrestleMania.
Decoding the Slumdog Millionaire Backlash
As the first two thirds of Slumdog Millionaire make clear, the slum-dwelling beggars of overcrowded Mumbai lead no easy life. But if violence, hunger, and substandard living conditions weren't already enough to contend with, the movie's ten Oscar nominations have them dealing with an additional scourge: pushy journalists who won't stop asking them what they think of Slumdog Millionaire.
"Who wouldn't want to be a millionaire?" says real-life slumdog. ![]()
With Friends Like These, Ben Lyons Needs More Friends
When we wrote about the brewing Category 4 Ben Lyons Hate Storm last week, Vulture took a mildly ambivalent stance on the self-proclaimed "movie dude." While a nation of highbrow critics are calling for his head on a platter (their bloodlust is so strong that they're not even demanding said platter be cast from silver), we kind of took the stance that Lyons isn't worth demonizing because he's pretty genial and, ultimately, not that influential. However, we just stumbled across a shoddily composed essay over at the Huffington Post titled "In Defense of Ben Lyons" that has us reconsidering our stance. Penned by a blogger named Cenk Uygur, the piece's crucial thesis statement reads as follows:
Here is my simple message to all the haters — get off Ben Lyons' ass.And it gets worse from there.
Ben Lyons Earns Title As America’s Most Hated Film Critic
While we here at Vulture have poked some good-natured fun at Paul Dergarabedian over the years for being a bit, oh, say, quote-whorish, yesterday's Los Angeles Times ran a blistering feature on self-proclaimed "movie dude" Ben Lyons that was tantamount to a hit piece. Over the course of some 1,800 words (!), reporter Chris Lee chronicled the Ben Lyons Hate Storm that has been picking up steam ever since he and Ben Mankiewicz were named as Richard Roeper's successors on the once-beloved At the Movies syndicated show. Lee goes to great lengths to speak to sources that were willing to go on the record to bash Lyons, quotes that run the gamut from "he has no taste" (Erik Childress, V.P. of Chicago Film Critics Association) to "he crystallizes everything that's wrong with American pop culture right now" (Scott Johnson, editor of StopBenLyons.com). Perhaps fueled by the unbridled scorn that the highbrow film-critic establishment shows the decidedly populist Lyons, Lee also found himself unable to resist the temptation to editorialize his own thoughts:
With his meat-and-potatoes good looks, frat-boy bonhomie and straight-down-the-pike delivery — more reminiscent of a SportsCenter commentator than an erudite cultural arbiter — Lyons is certainly not your father's movie reviewer.
Early Negative Reaction to G.I. Joe Teaser Gives Paramount the Jitters
On a day when a fake Thundercats trailer is being warmly accepted by seemingly all of the Internet, the suits over at Paramount have a considerable problem on their hands with a very real trailer for a very expensive nostalgia trip. And just like most problems these days, it all began with a meddling blogger. You see, a few weeks back, a blogger over at Nuke the Fridge happened to see a "test screening" for the first teaser trailer for Paramount's big summer tent pole, G.I. Joe (yes, you read that right, studios most definitely conduct focus groups to see how their trailers are going to play). And like any other enterprising blogger, he posted the largely negative review of the teaser including specific details and shots on his site. As you might expect, that's when the legal eagles at Paramount issued Nuke the Fridge with a cease-and-desist.
"Is it safe to certify 'GI Joe' as the first flop of Summer 2009?" ![]()
Variety's Todd McCarthy is the first critic out of the gate with a review of Seven Pounds, and boy, oh boy, it's the biggest evisceration of a Will Smith vehicle since Wild Wild West. Not only will it "infuriate anyone predominantly guided by rationality and intellect," but McCarthy also blasts Smith for "embracing [his character's] saintlike status in a way so convincing that it proves disturbing as an indication of how highly this anointed superstar may regard himself." Yikes! At this point, we can only keep our fingers crossed that the Times had the good sense to assign their review to Manohla Dargis. [Variety via Hollywood Elsewhere]
Key Twilight 2 Constituents Attempt to Curb Fan Backlash
In an effort to fend off some of the bad vibes surrounding the Twilight franchise in the wake of director Catherine Hardwicke's abrupt dismissal from the film, both series creator Stephenie Meyer and New Moon director Chris Weitz launched a coordinated PR offensive over the weekend. Sensing the potential for a fan revolt when a man was hired to helm the sequel to the incredibly girlie Twilight, Meyer broke her silence on the subject on her official site. "I've had the chance to talk to Chris [Weitz]," she wrote, "and I can tell you that he is excited by the story and eager to keep the movie as close to the book as possible. He is also very aware of you, the fans, and wants to keep you all extremely happy. (Torches and pitchforks are not going to be necessary.)" Phew, glad she cleared that one up! But aside from the back-patting portions of her statement, Meyer also offered a sense of some of the turmoil behind the scenes over the last few weeks by writing, "I'm going to miss [Hardwicke], not just as a brilliant director, but also as a friend." Wait, does this mean that Meyer and Hardwicke aren't even friends anymore? Or are we just reading too much between the lines? Either way, we're going to keep pulling the sweater and eventually the whole thing will unravel.
Advertising
Don't get enough snark on the Internet? Then try it in handy book form at approximately infinity times the cost! In his new book, Snark, David Denby has fun snarking on the snarkers. From what we've read by Denby in the past, we just don't see this turning out well for anyone. [SimonSays.com]
A Best Picture Contender’s Guide to Running Against Slumdog Millionaire
Like Juno and Little Miss Sunshine before it, Slumdog Millionaire — based on its small budget ($15 million), distributor (Fox Searchlight), and uplifting story (a Mumbai street kid makes good on a TV game show) — was cast early on as 2008's Little Movie That Could. But with recent honors from the National Board of Review, the British Independent Film Awards, and the Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association, along with the failure of any starrier, larger-budget movie to generate consensus among Oscar watchers, Slumdog has coasted backlash-free to front-runner status in this year's Best Picture race. Can smaller art-house fare like Australia and The Curious Case of Benjamin Button possibly compete? Probably not! Even so, for publicists running rival Best Picture campaigns, Vulture has drafted a set of anti-Slumdog talking points (caution: Spoilers ahead!) that might prove helpful.
As if it weren't bad enough that Vulture buddy Nikki Finke has begun to label the underperforming Australia as "Rupert's folly," Nicole Kidman now finds herself on the receiving end of scorn from social-networking miscreants. Australian native Brendan Shanahan (not to be confused with the former New York Ranger) has started a Facebook group called "Am I Taking Crazy Pills or is Nicole Kidman the Worst Actress in the World?," a group which boasts at press time a (less than impressive) total of 246 members. Although Vulture tips its cap to the founder for incorporating a Zoolander reference into the group's name, we will go to our beds tonight fearful that the rogue actions of this collective might just be enough to persuade Nicole Kidman to finally quit Hollywood once and for all. [Fox News]
Closing Ceremony Takes the Bloom Off Zhang Yimou, Jimmy Page
The closing Ceremony included little that we couldn't have thought up if someone gave <em>us </em>millions of dollars, thousands of people, and terrible taste.
Will the Opening Ceremony Fakery Never End? Adorable Moppet Was Lip-Syncing
'I am proud to have been chosen to sing at all,' says plucky little Yang Peiyi.
Did ‘Breaking Dawn’ Ruin the Twilight Series?
Angry superfans are already returning their books to bookstores, apparently.
Have the ‘American Idol’ Producers Turned Against David Archuleta?
We'll put it this way: yes.
‘Iron Man’: A Dissenting View on Robert Downey Jr.
Having an effeminate roué like Robert Downey Jr. play Tony Stark is actually the most subversive thing that's ever been done in a comic-book movie — and not in a good way.
Will Charges of Inaccuracy Bring Down ‘Bringing Down the House’?
Ben Mezrich's MIT card-counting thriller is now the latest nonfiction book to come under scrutiny by people who think "nonfiction" means "true."
Advertising
Most Commented
Daily Intel
Last 72 Hours
- 1. ‘A Lot of Latter-Day Saints Would Think That Beck Was Asking Them to Leave Their Own Church’253
- 2. Jessica Simpson Sometimes Cleans Her Teeth With Her Sweater225
- 3. Frank Delaney Would Live in an Igloo in Central Park If He Had To31
- 4. New Jersey Man Accused of Al Qaeda Ties in Yemen29
- 5. The Return of the Hero Granny!28
Vulture
Last 72 Hours
Grub Street
Last 72 Hours
The Cut
Last 72 Hours
- 1. The Ten Best Things About Lady Gaga and Beyoncé's 'Telephone' Video78
- 2. Model Rie Rasmussen Finds Terry Richardson’s Work ‘Degrading to Women’64
- 3. Prada Japan Employee Accuses Management of Trying to Fire ‘Old, Fat, and Ugly’ Workers31
- 4. Dakota Fanning Out-Sparkled Kristen Stewart24
- 5. Donna Karan Wants a Fashion Revolution20
Vulture's Oscar Race Coverage
Latest Headlines
- Hugh Jackman on His Oscar Party, His Role in Lee Daniels’s Selma, and Getting Naked in Acting Class
- ‘Babble On’: Nothing Gets Infotainment Hot and Bothered Like the Oscars
- Somebody From The Hurt Locker Probably Should Have Thanked Critics at the Oscars
See who's up, down, and on the red carpet »
Sponsored By [BRANDING TK]
- Sunday
- The Amazing Race, Big Love
- Monday
- 24, Gossip Girl, How I Met Your Mother, Kell on Earth
- Tuesday
- American Idol, Lost
- Wednesday
- Ugly Betty
- Thursday
- 30 Rock, Community, Fringe, The Office, Parks and Recreation, The Real Housewives of New York City, Survivor
- Friday
- Caprica
- Saturday
- Saturday Night Live
- On Hiatus:
- Bored to Death, Breaking Bad, Californication, The City, Curb Your Enthusiasm, Damages, Dexter, FlashForward, Friday Night Lights, Glee, The Hills, In Treatment, Jersey Shore, Mad Men, Nurse Jackie, NYC Prep, Project Runway, Rescue Me, The Rachel Zoe Project, Top Chef, Top Chef Masters, True Blood, United States of Tara, V, Weeds
Opening This Week
The ProjectionistMasthead
- Entertainment Editor
- Josh Wolk
- Editors
- Lane Brown, Mark Graham
- Managing Editor
- Jessica Coen
- Articles Editor
- Nick Catucci
- West Coast Editor
- Claude Brodesser-Akner
- Assistant Editors
- Amos Barshad, Edith Zimmerman
Filter By Tag
People
More Slideshows-
Watch the slideshow
This Weekend's Concerts, From Muse to Neon Indian
-
Watch the slideshow
The Jonas Brothers Go Looking for Treasure
-
Watch the slideshow
This Weekend’s Concerts, From John Mayer to Surfer Blood
-
Watch the slideshow
See Photos of Angelina Jolie On The Tourist Set
The Runaways: “In patches it’s agreeably lurid, but it’s otherwise ho-hum.”
Mortimer and Jackman at the City Island Premiere
Morrison and Breslin at The Miracle Worker
Hawke, Gere, and Snipes at Brooklyn's Finest
Butler Discusses Oscars at Cosmo Awards
Gyllenhaal at the Character Approved Celebration
