New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

 

Model Tracker

2/19/08

4:39 PM

Banks vs. Klum: Only One Is America's Top Ex-Supermodel

There's room for only one set of bangs in this town.Photo: Getty Images

The Daily News has a random ode to Heidi Klum and Tyra Banks today. The article praises them for "doing things they're actually good at" after their modeling careers began to fizzle:
In the '90s, supermodels like Cindy Crawford and Naomi Campbell tried to break away from the runway with roles on the big screen. (Anyone remember Crawford's flop, "Fair Game"? We thought not.) But Klum and Banks redefined the model slash actress cliché and instead created a platform that actually flies: model slash host.

Seriously, thank gawd they stopped trying to do things that required acting talent. (But Karolina Kurkova, we wish you all the best in your big-screen debut in GI Joe.) What's interesting, however, is that Klum gets top mention in this article. This is probably because it's inspired by models.com's list of the world's sexiest models, which ranks Klum number one, and Banks number four, after Gisele Bündchen and Adriana Lima. They may call Klum "Heidi Inc.," but America's Next Top Model is about to launch an unbelievable tenth cycle this week while Project Runway is only in its fourth season. Add to the mix that Banks draws over a million viewers each morning on her daily talk show and we had to wonder if the News was really right in insinuating that Klum is America's top ex-supermodel. Is Klum more successful than ubiquitous Miss Tyra?

To answer this serious question, we decided to take a quantified look at the non-modeling highlights of each woman's career, ranking each on the Fierceness Scale of 1 to 5, with 5 being "absolutely ferocious."

Tyra Banks:
• 1993: Appears on The Fresh Prince of Bel Air looking really hot, in an early-nineties-ish way. Score: 5

• 1997: Publishes first book, Tyra's Beauty Inside and Out. Score: 2

• 2003: ANTM premieres with Tyra performing the theme song. Score: 4

• 2004: Musical career fails when Banks is unable to release album T.Y.R.A. Score: 1

• 2008: Banks walks off of her talk show because she can't stand bickering among the cast of the Bad Girls Club. Score: 1

TOTAL FIERCENESS: 13

Heidi Klum:
• 2001: Appears as an ill-tempered hair model in the movie Blow Dry, which is about a British hairdressing championship. Bold move. Score: 5

• 2004: Klum is featured in James Bond video game Everything or Nothing as the villain. Score: 4

• 2006: Klum's Mouawad jewelry collection debuts on QVC, and most styles sell out in just 30 minutes. Score: 2

• 2006: Klum hosts Germany's Next Top Model, with Banks in the wing as executive producer. Score: 3

• 2007: Sings the sap-tastic song "Wedding Day" with hubby Seal on his new album. Score: 1

TOTAL FIERCENESS: 15

Well, what do you know — sometimes we surprise ourselves. Klum wins, and she is in fact America's Top Ex-Supermodel. We just can't believe how wildly we miscalled this one; we're going to go practice vamping in the bathroom until we regain a shred of our self-confidence…

Heidi Klum and Tyra Banks are models of success [NYDN]

Advertising

Edited by Amy Odell

  • Get the RSS feed
The Cut Features

21 Questions: The New York questionnaire.

Ask a Retailer: What they're buying from the runways.

Backstage Video: Behind the scenes at Fashion Week.

Beauty Marks: Read all Beauty Marks posts

Body Issues: Chronicling the unending quest for physical perfection.

Cult of Personality: Digging in with the people who matter.

Dress Code: Deciphering the language of fashion.

Fashion Album: Stars' favorite runway looks.

Fashion Calendar: Pencil in these sales and events.

Fashion Library: Read all Fashion Library posts

Fashion Yearbook: Read all Fashion Yearbook posts

First Looks: Read all First Looks posts

First Responders: Read all First Responders posts

Harriet and Amy: New York's fashion editors' picks.

In the Magazine: Stories from our print parent.

Loose Threads: Quicks news hits and assorted minutia.

Model Tracker: Who's dominating the runway today?

New York Fugging City: The Fug Girls on the Fashion Week scene.

Party Lines: What happened last night.

Passing Judgment: Read all Passing Judgment posts

Retail Therapy: Read all Retail Therapy posts

Reviews: Our critics weigh in.

Run Through: Fashion news daily.

Show & Tell: News from around the tents.

Tastemakers: Read all Tastemakers posts

The Fab Life: Read all The Fab Life posts

Three Is a Trend: Instant trend-spotting.

Video Look Book: Street style interviews.