And boy is she glad she did. We wondered earlier what A-Dubs would do today, with the U.S. Open men's final scheduled for 5 p.m., precisely when her darlings Proenza Schouler were to show their collection. Now we know: Anna followed her heart — her real one, the one that roams free of the glossy page or masthead (yes, we believe such a thing is possible) — and ditched her designer boys in favor of the strapping Swiss champion. And oh, how we were all rewarded: When Federer won, she leaped up in her seat and clapped her hands over her head, smiling like we've never seen. Love does that to you.

Earlier: Anna's Choice