Last night’s Emmy ceremony continued the show’s tradition of being tragically less boozy than the Golden Globes while not being nearly as revered as the Oscars. But just because no one fell off the stage or accidentally lit Ryan Seacrest on fire doesn’t mean that those generous souls who braved the red carpet solely for our entertainment — and their own good press — don’t deserve a little constructive feedback. Keep reading for the Emmys’ biggest hits and misses.

Related: See all the looks from the red carpet!