Football Metaphors Not Enough to Save ‘Top Chef’
4/17/08 at 8:30 AM

Top Chef judges in a huddle.Photo courtesy Bravo
Fauxersky: I don't care what the judges thought. Anyone who gets to pick a beer to pair and goes with Michelob Ultra loses all food privileges.
Bratt: I have a feeling this is the first time Richard's tasted beer in a long time. Doesn't he seem more like the biodynamic-wine type? Or perhaps he likes a glass of Shiraz wrapped in Saran Wrap and slightly smoked?
Fauxersky: Does Glad make Saran Wrap? If so, yes.
Bratt: I'm waiting for the challenge where they have to incorporate Glad products into the dish.
Fauxersky: That's when Richard just serves a sous-vide bag.
Bratt: Spike displayed the least imagination this episode, which is nothing new. He didn't even cook in the Quickfire, and then he made chicken wings for the tailgate party.
Bratt: The only thing he's got going for him is his burgeoning man-love for Mark.
Fauxersky: Well, since the lesbians got separated, Top Chef needs a new subplot.
Fauxersky: But the bathtub thing, as well as the early Dale conversation with Lisa about feelings, convinced me that this show is fast becoming Real World, with food.
Bratt: The bathtub definitely took us into Real World Las Vegas territory. I even sensed some tension on Antonia's part when Nikki returned from her thrashing at the hands of the judges.
Bratt: And, of course, we have Jennifer, who is now doing everything "all for Zoi."
Fauxersky: What'd you think of the Elimination Challenge? I kind of loved it. There were so many ways for the chefs to go wrong!
Bratt: It proved that the producers have followed suit with other reality shows and decided to create as many disadvantageous scenarios for contestants as possible.
Fauxersky: Well, at least it fit Chicago in a way that wasn't totally contrived, like the gross block party.
Bratt: It hammered home the idea that Chicagoans like to eat outside. They were dealing with a strong tradition that more or less has a code of conduct regarding cuisine.
Fauxersky: It seemed there was a lot of food that required utensils. Skirt steak?
Bratt: Yeah, no one wants to use a fork and knife, especially on some flimsy Bears paper plate.
Fauxersky: The plates were the worst! Nothing looks good plated on a blue and orange Bears plate.
Bratt: But serving a poached pear dessert to Bears fans is like serving honey-glazed ham at a Passover seder.
Fauxersky: I'm sure nothing goes with Michelob Ultra like crème fraîche!
Bratt: Was Ryan a victim of his self-proclaimed metrosexuality?
Fauxersky: His California casual doomed him.
Bratt: The highlight of the episode was when everyone applauded after Ryan proclaimed that he had realized that, "Wow, I'm not the shit."
Bratt: But Nikki should have gone home. I'm tired of her excuses.
Fauxersky: Oh, I don't know. The Kiwi was a slob. He licked his serving spoon! Colicchio looked like he wanted to delouse Mark right at judges' table.
Bratt: Padma just shook her head disapprovingly, like Mark was some dirty one-night stand she couldn't stand to see the next day.
Fauxersky: And poor Dale. Yeah, he won. But instead of a hot trip to Italy with his lover, he gets a Bears jersey and a giant grill.
Fauxersky: He works at Buddakan. Where is he going to put his grill?
Fauxersky: Start checking eBay. It'll be there.
Bratt: I'll bid on the jersey if you take on the grill.

Email
Print
Why Oliver Stone Made His Bush Biopic, W.
Theater Review: A Man for All Seasons
David Edelstein on Happy-Go-Lucky
Hilary Berseth's Buzzworthy Sculptures