Chris Smith: Ratner Showing Fear, At Last?
1/29/08 at 12:45 PM

Photo: Getty Images
To which the judges should respond: So what? In pitching Atlantic Yards plans to state and city authorities, Ratner's representatives always made a thorough case that he's an experienced, savvy developer, so of course he's factored delays, legal hurdles, and economic changes into the Atlantic Yards projections. Perhaps Ratner didn't forecast the credit markets tightening as quickly or severely as they have; few did (among the astute, however, is Ratner's underwriter, Goldman Sachs, which seems to be handling the economic slump quite nicely, thank you). But Ratner clearly understands the business cycle, and he anticipated an end to the city's boom, so he included an economic downturn into his Atlantic Yards scenarios. A project this massive, in the heart of a major city, was always going to take a long time to launch and complete. Ratner's lieutenants shrugged off any suggestion that lawsuits might imperil the project; Atlantic Yards was such a sound deal, they said, that even if the margins changed, the company had little worry about lining up financing. So Ratner can't have it both ways. He can't claim that Atlantic Yards is a solid deal for both him and the city, then turn around and say the project is fragile enough that the fallout from the subprime-mortgage mess could sink the whole thing.
Ratner has released a multitude of pretty architectural renderings and models for Atlantic Yards. The one thing he's always zealously guarded is the calculations of how much money he expects to make on the deal, especially the sixteen high-rise apartment and condo towers. One real-estate expert has calculated Ratner's take as nearly $1 billion; certainly the direct public subsidies of $305 million help his bottom line. Rising interest rates may shrink Ratner's return, but that's hardly a reason for the judges to rush their review.
Today Ratner is back in the Post threatening to take his ball and go home completely. It's another move in his ongoing attempt to turn up the pressure on the opposition to Atlantic Yards. The developer and his lawyers want people to believe that the pesky protesters are costing Brooklyn a civic boon. But Bruce Ratner decided a long time ago that fighting it out in court was cheaper than submitting Atlantic Yards to a transparent public-approval process. —Chris Smith
Email
Link
Print
Can Paterson Navigate the Troubled Economy?

Will Sulzberger's Heirs Sell the 'Times'?
How McCain Lost His Public Image
What Wall Street Will Look Like in Fall 2009