Who Took the Democratic Debate? It’s a Matter for … Debate

Photo: Getty Images
• Andrew Sullivan gives an easy win to Obama, though he doesn’t think his rejection/denunciation of Louis Farrakhan went far enough. [Daily Dish/Atlantic]
• Joe Klein says Obama was calm and in control throughout the debate, though Klein agrees with Clinton on health care and thinks Obama should have rejected Farrakhan outright. [Swampland/Time]
• Noam Scheiber writes that Clinton never flummoxed Obama, and that Obama only looked bad once, on the question about Putin’s successor. [Stump/New Republic]
• Chris Cillizza calls it a draw even though Clinton “dominated” much of the debate. [Fix/WP]
• Stephen Spruiell thinks Obama’s ability to rise above tedious political traps, for example the “reject versus denounce” Farrakhan exchange, is what won him the debate and what makes him a formidable challenger in general. [Corner/National Review]
• Jim Geraghty goes out on a limb and gives a straight victory to Clinton, who demonstrated that she’s a “fighter.” [Campaign Spot/National Review]
• Kevin Drum believes the candidates are too skilled for either to land a “knockout blow” in the debates but gives the win to Obama. [Political Animal/Washington Monthly]
• Mark Ambinder gives substance points to Clinton and style points to Obama, though he concedes the debate probably won’t affect anything. [Atlantic]
• Mark Halperin gives Obama a B+ and Clinton a B-. [The Page/Time]
• Ari Berman writes that the tie tips to the front-runner Obama, while the biggest loser was Tim Russert for his “gotcha” questions. [Nation]
• Mary Katharine Ham credits Clinton for her substance but points out that Obama was more likable and had the audience laughing with him and at Clinton. [Town Hall]
• Mike Madden says Obama mistakes were hard to come by and thinks Clinton’s complaint about moderator bias made her look like a whiny grouch, even if she was later somewhat vindicated. [Salon]
• Andrew Romano calls it a tie, giving the voters of Ohio and Texas the win for profiting from such a good debate. [Stumper/Newsweek] —Dan Amira
Related: Texas Primary: Four Trends, All to Obama's Advantage
For a complete guide to presidential candidates Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, and John McCain — from First Love to Most Embarrassing Gaffe — read the 2008 Electopedia.

Tantrums Erupt Over Wall Street Pay
What's Bill Bratton's Next Career Move?
The Political Fictions Project
Smith on the Khalid Sheikh Mohammed Trial 