You are not logged in

New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Ad Hominem Attack on Mariah Carey in the ‘Daily News’

3/18/08 at 12:45 PM

Mariah Carey

Mariah Carey, hurting.Photo: Getty Images

Dude, News editorial board, what's with this 63-word diatribe today?
Cultural note: We see that the warbler Mariah Carey, who has already tied Elvis Presley as the second-place holder of the most No. 1 records, will soon, if her new hit ditty goes to the top of the charts, tie the Beatles as the first-place holder of the most No. 1 records ever.
Man.
That's — that's just wrong.
On so many levels.

Why, exactly, is it wrong, you guys? Because you're a bunch of mostly white old people who don't understand R&B? If you'll recall, your parents thought Elvis and the Beatles were trashy, too. We won't defend Mariah Carey's cultural relevance in comparison to those musical giants — though we do love her. But from now on, you're no longer allowed to wonder why young people think your newspaper is irrelevant.

Off the Charts [NYDN]

Advertising
Senior Editors
Chris Rovzar and Jessica Pressler
Managing Editor
Jessica Coen
Articles Editor
Nick Catucci
Recent News