New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

the greatest depression

The CNBC Emotional Index

Green is the new flattering.

CNBC spends its days tracking the Dow, the S&P, the NASDAQ and even the LIBOR. But in these panicky times, who's tracking CNBC?

Yesterday, October 2 — the day after the Senate approved the bailout bill and the day before the House took it up — we went from Wall Street's opening bell to closing bell charting the CNBCEI (that would be the CNBC Emotional Index). Isn't it time to put politics aside and engineer a bailout for Maria Bartiromo?

The CNBCEI scale runs from Great Depression (1) to Bubbly (10)

9:30 a.m. Russell Simmons rings the NYSE's opening bell while wearing a delightfully colorful sweater-vest. 8

10 a.m. Up pops the day's first graphic showing the progress of the Dow. It's down 185. 6

10:31 a.m. Befuddled by a chart on NASDAQ stats, anchor Mark Haines simply blurts out, "What is going on here?" 5

10:46 a.m. Interview with Russell Simmons. Still loving that delightfully colorful sweater-vest. 8

11:02 a.m. Reporter Bob Pisani enthusiastically makes the case that we may soon see a bull market. He has three screens with bullet points! 9

11:09 a.m. In argument over whether the government could actually make money from the bailout bill, reporter Rick Santelli looks like he's ready to throw a punch. 7

12:23 p.m. Viewing video of the long-mothballed Intrepid aircraft carrier heading back to New York, Michelle Caruso-Cabrera says, "A strong military is what ultimately defines a strong reserve currency." Others look at her baffled. 4

12:33 p.m. Now-jovial Rick Santelli and Dennis Kneale bet cheeseburgers on the direction of European interest rates. They're going double or nothing! 7

1:43 p.m. Breaking News headline: "Dow down 300+ points." In fact, by the time the graphic loads up, the Dow's down by 310. 4

2:35 p.m. Discussing the downturn in commercial paper, Mary Thompson says, "The chill is causing significant shrinkage." She doesn't even giggle. 3

2:50 p.m. Jim Cramer likens the value of the New York Stock Exchange stock to that of a bowling alley. Erin Burnett laughs and tells him to go take a nap. 6

3 p.m. Amid a day of heavy losses, Maria Bartiromo takes over coverage. When she's not talking, she looks like she's holding her breath. 4

3:26 p.m. Uninterrupted string of Breaking News headlines: "S&P Down almost 4%," "Dow falls over 3%," "Dow below 10,500," "NASDAQ down 4%," "NASDAQ below 2000." Ouch. 3

3:43 p.m. Breaking News headline: "Dow drops almost 400 points." In fact, it's down only 360. How pessimistic. 2

3:48 p.m. Analyzing graphs of data, Jordan Kotick somberly describes the current economic downturn as a "perfect chart storm." 1

4 p.m. NYSE closing bell rung by the CEO of Wendys Arbys Group. Earlier he had enthusiastically implied that a faltering economy would be good news for Wendys Arbys because it would increase the number of people who could only afford to eat fast food. 2

Photo: Getty Images/ MSNBC.com
Advertising