America Loves Rudy More Than Ever; New York, Not So Much

20070320rudy.jpg

The faithful greet Giuliani last week.Photo: Getty Images


The Gallup Poll people released new numbers on the Republican presidential contenders today, and they only buttress the emerging consensus that Rudy Giuliani, who used to be New York’s tyrannical mayor before he came America’s beloved one, is the nominal front-runner. Forty-eight percent of liberal and moderate Republicans — granted a group that might be about twelve people big these days — said they preferred Giuliani; 26 percent picked the second-place finisher, John McCain. But even among conservative GOPers, the thrice-married moderate came in first, with 38 percent of respondents picking him to McCain’s 20 percent. And here’s the knockout punch: A whopping 80 percent of all Republicans holds a favorable impression of Giuliani. That’s huge — and “until he's not defined by 9/11," the Politico’s Jonathan Martin writes, "those fav/unfav numbers probably don't come down.” But, then, those are national numbers. Contrast them with local poll results reported today by Crain's New York Business. There, 70 percent of respondents agreed that Rudy lacks the temperament to be president, presumably recalling his performance up through September 10, 2001. Of course, this Crain's poll, unlike Gallup’s, was online and unscientific. On the other hand, its respondents were people who have actually, you know, been governed by the guy. Ah, memories.

Gallup on Rudy's Lead [The Politico]
Giuliani Not Fit for the White House: Poll [Crain's]