A federal judge this afternoon dismissed Goldstein v. Pataki, the key eminent-domain case seeking to block Bruce Ratner's Atlantic Yards megadevelopment. It's a major setback for the Develop Don't Destroy crowd, right? Wrong, says Matthew Brinckerhoff, DDDB's lead lawyer. Indeed, he calls it good news. "There was an initial ruling by the federal magistrate saying we didn't belong in federal court, and now a district court has said we belong in federal court but dismissed the claim," Brinckerhoff told us. Now, he says, his clients can focus their appeal on the merits of the case — that public officials delivered the massive project to Forest City Ratner when it should have gone to multiple bidders in a public process — rather than on jurisdictional technicalities. "Given where we were, we are not worse off," Brinckerhoff said. Of course — and we're not lawyers — one would imagine it would be even better not to have to appeal at all. But Brinckerhoff is standing firm and tossing off sound bites. "This is far from over," he said. —Alec Appelbaum
Most Viewed Stories
America Has Never Been So Ripe for Tyranny
Trump Has Won and the Republican Party Is Broken
George Takei Calmly Dismantles All of Marvel’s Excuses for Its Doctor Strange Casting
All the Ways Game of Thrones’ Ramsay Bolton Is Way Worse in the Books
Elizabeth Warren Promises to Save Us All From Donald Trump
ESPN’s Eight-Hour O.J. Documentary Is a Masterpiece
Meet Celina Midelfart, the Glamorous Norwegian Businesswoman Donald Trump Allegedly Dumped for Melania
Is Chris Hemsworth’s Dad Hot? An Investigation
While His Peers Took Chances, Drake Doubled Down on Drake
Jay Z’s Reportedly Responding to Lemonade With an Album, Because He Has Feelings, Too
Latest News from Daily IntelligencerHillary Clinton Wasted No Time Before Using Republicans’ Word Against Trump
Clinton's new ad features prominent Republicans describing their presumptive nominee as a "know-nothing" "con artist" who loves making fun of disabled people.How Do Republicans Protect Themselves From the Trump Fallout?
Spoiler: They can't.A Record-breaking Wildfire in Canada Forces an Entire Town to Evacuate
A blaze in Fort McMurray, in Alberta, is believe to be the largest in the province's history.Donald Trump Has Put the GOP in an Impossible Position on Merrick Garland
When it comes to defending Donald Trump’s “right” to appoint a Supreme Court justice next fall, Senate Republicans are damned if they do, damned if they don’t.John Kasich Is Finally Done Pretending He Could Be President
The Ohio governor, who still trails Marco Rubio in the delegate count, will suspend his delusional campaign for the GOP nomination this afternoon.Sheldon Silver Hoping to Serve His Time in a Cushy Prison
He was sentenced to 12 years in prison Tuesday.With the L Train Shutdown Looming, a Real-Estate Executive Is Still Trying to Make an East River ‘Urban Gondola’ Happen
He first proposed the idea in 2014.A Pregnant Woman From Connecticut Has Tested Positive for Zika Virus
She was visiting Central America and reportedly started developing symptoms of the virus.The Donald Says #NeverTrump Republicans Can Come Back ‘in 16 Years’
On Wednesday morning, Trump said Hillary Clinton "should suffer," Muslims are "destroying Europe," and his haters can re-join the GOP when he's no longer president ... in 16 years.Will It Ever Be Sunny Again in New York?
A wash of a week.
The FDNY says the fire wasn't suspicious.Revisiting the Last Great Debate Over Skyscraper Shadows
Another tall building, another fight over a share of light.In the Battle at SeaWorld, the Whales Have Won
Score one for the cetaceans.In a Bid to Fight Street Harassment, Prospect Heights Construction Crews to Don Colorful Hats
Problem solved!Fresh Intelligence: Cruz Bows Out, Sanders Stays In, and Trump Cleans Up
Our roundup of the stories, ideas, and memes you’ll be talking about today.Elizabeth Warren Promises to Save Us All From Donald Trump
"Donald Trump has built his campaign on racism, sexism, and xenophobia."Obama to Name Stonewall Inn First-Ever National Monument for Gay Rights
Just in time for Pride Month.Sanders’s Indiana Win Supports His Argument that Late Delegates Are More Important
It's a good way to keep the dream alive, but it's not necessarily a good prescription for party unity.Ted Cruz Drops Out of GOP Race, Promptly Elbows Wife in the Head
Not once, but twice.Bernie Sanders Wins Indiana, Rages Against the Dying of the Electoral Light
Liberal indies still aren’t ready for Clinton.