In a major financial blow to the owners of Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village, the State Court of Appeals ruled that some 4,000 rent-stabilized apartments were illegally deregulated in the past decade. That means that the current ownership group, led by Tishman Speyer and BlackRock (which are already basically out of cash for the project) and prior owners Metropolitan Life will have to pay an estimated $200 million in damages and rent overcharges to tenants. According to the ruling, the complex was receiving J-51 tax breaks from the city for major renovations, which barred them from luxury deregulation, and they'll have to pay back the tenants for the higher rents — and adjust future rents accordingly (they continue to receive the tax breaks). Of course, figuring out just who is owed what could take years. But as it stands now, a whole bunch of current and former tenants look to get a lot of money back. Whether or not the "dire financial consequences" the owners predicted for "themselves and the New York City real estate industry generally" come to pass also remains to be seen.
Most Viewed Stories
Beyoncé's 'Formation': Young, Gifted, and Black
Rubio Implodes in New Hampshire Debate by Acting Like a Broken Robot
The Complete Guide to Beyoncé's 'Formation'
The 100 Jokes That Shaped Modern Comedy
Pro-Rape Meet-Up Canceled After Women’s Boxing Club Threatens to Show Up
The Rocky Horror Picture Show Cast Takes Their 40th-Anniversary Reunion Photo
Beyoncé Drops ‘Formation’
Super Bowl Shocker: The Good Wife Will End in May [Updated]
Marco Rubio Defends His Repetition of Talking Point by Repeating Talking Point
Watch Lady Gaga’s Powerful Rendition of the National Anthem at the Super Bowl and Start Pounding Your Own Chest in Pride
Latest News from Daily IntelligencerLife in Paris’s 10th and 11th Arrondissements, 3 Months After the Attacks
A return to pleasures, amid an unwillingness to ever forget.Sizing Up the Next Penn Station(s)
Which plans are likely to happen? And what do we need most?Donald Trump Wants to Reclassify Waterboarding So It’s No Longer a War Crime for Him to Order It
It’s still not clear what other forms of torture Trump would like to bring back.Clinton and Sanders to Debate in Flint, Michigan
The Democratic party hopes to draw attention to the city, which is still in the midst of a massive, man-made environmental disaster.Marco Rubio Defends His Repetition of Talking Point by Repeating Talking Point
“Actually, I would pay them to keep running that clip, because that’s what I believe passionately.”North Korea Launches Long-Range Rocket, Triggering Emergency Meeting of UN Security Council
The country says it was trying to send a satellite into orbit, but world powers aren't buying it.Some Fear the Death of Twitter As Company Considers Algorithmic Timeline
If a Twitter power-user complains, but the new timeline algorithm never shows anyone, did it happen?Rubio’s Establishment Rivals Bring Him Down to Earth in New Hampshire
It was by far Rubio’s worst debate performance, at the worst possible time, and against exactly the wrong competition.Rubio Implodes in New Hampshire Debate by Acting Like a Broken Robot
After being attacked by Chris Christie, a rattled, robotic Rubio was unable to veer away from canned sound bites.Earthquake in Taiwan Leaves at Least 14 Dead, More Than 150 Missing
A 17-story residential building collapsed while hundreds were still inside.
Per Twitter, 125,000 accounts have received the ultimate troll.NYU Bioethicist, Amid Zika Threat, Wants to Reschedule Rio Olympics: ‘What the Hell’s the Difference?’
"It just makes more sense."In Iowa, Democrats Were Divided by Class More Than by Ideology
Iowa's upper middle class voted for Clinton, while its lower middle class opted for revolution.Jeb’s Big Surprise for the Palmetto State: W. Back on the Stump!
Jeb's desire to embrace his older brother with both arms is getting serious.Swipe Right to Feel the Bern: Sanders Supporters Bounced From Tinder for Aggressive Campaigning
Replies included "Trump2016."The Great Underdiscussed Campaign Issue of 2016: The Future of the Supreme Court
It's huge, and almost unacknowledged.Empire State Building Gets in the Way of Man’s Drone
The robot crashed into the 40th floor.Citi: The Global Economy Is Trapped in a ‘Death Spiral’
The bank predicts a coming "Oilmageddon" if policymakers don't change course.An Obscure Law From the ’70s Is Being Used to Toss Innocent People Out of Their Homes
Evicted on a hunch?Shooting at Boxing Weigh-in in Dublin Leaves One Dead, Two Injured
The gunman opened fire at the Regency Hotel.