what other people think
How Hysterical Are Conservative Reactions to the Passage of Health-Care Reform?
If you ask liberals, last night marked a historic moment for America. The House of Representatives, after decades of similar attempts, narrowly passed sweeping reforms of the health-care system with legislation that seemed all but dead after the election of Scott Brown. But conservatives see its passage as historic as well, just in a very different way. While a Democratic congressman compared health-care reform to the Civil Rights Act, some conservative political pundits saw the beginning of America's downfall. Literally. We're not kidding. Here are all the conservative reactions we could get our hands on, in order of the least hysterical to the most hysterical.
• Ross Douthat says that he thinks liberals are wrong, but he hopes they're right. "Indeed, I hope that 20 years from now, in an America that’s healthier, richer and more solvent than today, a liberal can brandish this column and say “I told you so.” Because the alternative would mean that we’re all about to be very sorry, and for a very long time to come." [NYT]
• William Kristol wants Republicans to focus the campaigns of 2010 and 2012 on repealing health-care reform. Though Obama "won a short-term victory," it is "one that will turn out to mark an inflection point on the road to defeat, and the beginning of the end of the Democratic party’s dominance over American politics." [Weekly Standard]
• John Podhoretz says the legislation "draws the brightest ideological and political line between the two parties since the end of the Cold War — which featured a profound conflict of visions about the question of confronting the Soviet Union or accommodating it — and revivifies the Republican party’s role in opposition to the state’s growing encroachment on the particulars of American life." [Contentions/Commentary]
• Peter Suderman thinks that ultimately, "we're left with a highly expensive, fiscally dangerous expansion of health insurance that locks even more people into a broken system. That's an achievement, all right, but not a particularly good one." [Hit & Run/Reason]
• Jennifer Rubin suspects that health-care reform's passage will "set off a firestorm of protest that sweeps Democrats from office and will in due time result in the repeal or roll back of much of the mischief-making." [Contention/Commentary]
• The Wall Street Journal editorial board says that "by ramming the vote through Congress on a narrow partisan majority, and against so much popular opposition, Democrats have taken responsibility for what comes next—to insurance premiums, government spending, doctor shortages and the quality of care. They are now the rulers of American medicine." [WSJ]
• Peter Wehner thinks that while "Obama has certainly left his stamp on history ... the health-care debate has utterly shattered the impression of Obama as a post-partisan, fresh, unifying, and attractive political figure. All his talk about “turning the page” in American politics was cynical nonsense." [