Economy-Saving Program That Everybody Hates May Turn a Profit

By

Among certain American patriots, the word “TARP” is met with actual physical disgust. Parents tell their children that if they’re bad, the TARP monster who lives under their bed will come out at night and suffocate them (with debt). GOP presidential hopefuls have found creative ways to disavow their prior support for it — “the idea was correct but the implementation wrong,” or something like that — in order to avoid the wrath of the tea party.

And yet the truth is that TARP — the Troubled Asset Relief Program, otherwise known as the bank bailout — shouldn’t be a dirty word at all. On Sunday, the Treasury Department will no longer be able to use TARP money. That’s okay. It has already saved the economy.


This is the best federal program of any real size to be despised by the public like this,” said Douglas J. Elliott, a former investment banker now associated with the Brookings Institution, a Washington think tank.

Okay, so it prevented an even more catastrophic financial meltdown. Still, we have a huge national debt to consider here, right? We can’t just throw away hundreds of billions of dollars just because our economy is about to collapse.


[B]y mid-2009, the administration projected that TARP could lose $341 billion, a figure that reflected new commitments to A.I.G. and the auto industry.

The Congressional Budget Office, which had a slightly higher loss estimate initially, in August reduced that to $66 billion.

It turns out that the victims of TARP were not the taxpayers after all (while best-case scenarios admittedly rarely happen with regard to anything the government does, even a $50 billion loss, the worst-case scenario, is like couch change for the United States). They were the Republicans who were voted out of office because of their support for a program that earned the misplaced hatred of the tea party. Guys like Republican senator Bob Bennett of Utah, who didn’t even make it onto the primary ballot this year after serving since 1993.


For those who were screaming at me — and screaming was the operative word — ‘You’ve just saddled our children and grandchildren with $700 billion,’ I said, ‘No, I haven’t,” Mr. Bennett said in an interview.

Crazy old Bob.

TARP Bailout to Cost Less Than Once Anticipated [NYT]