New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

public drinking

Judge Rules That Cops Cannot Reliably Detect Beer by Sniffing

Forty ounces of beer, or freedom?

Brooklyn judge Noach Dear reached an anti-establishment conclusion on Thursday, rejecting the authority of NYPD officers to issue public drinking summonses based only on a sniff of a container's contents. “While the arresting officer’s professional training and sense of smell may be sufficient to support his conclusion that defendant was drinking beer,” Dear wrote in a case involving a man who actually admitted carrying a cup with beer, “such does not support the conclusion that the beer contained more than one-half of one percent of alcohol by volume."

In Dear's court, cops who moonlight as pub dwellers need not drag a person into court based on a sniff. He would like to see the NYPD use a lab test, or basically stop issuing summonses for public drinking.

In other words, if you're a Brooklyn resident who might get hauled before Judge Noach Dear's bench on a public drinking violation, this is your opportunity to experiment with drinking on the street from pilsners, beer helmets, or any other preferred container.

0