A fun thing that banks do around earnings season is start nipping and tucking themselves, accentuating the good parts of their quarterly earnings and hiding the bad. This can be accomplished in many ways: by excluding so-called "onetime charges" that have no effect on core business trends, by futzing with things called CVA and DVA that are way too boring and complicated to explain so just read this if you're interested, and by steering analysts and reporters to the best parts of their businesses and away from the clunker divisions.
In a stunning feat, Citigroup, which reported its third-quarter earnings this morning, managed to pull off all three.
Just look at this marvelous do-si-do of bad news avoidance, via The Wall Street Journal:
Citigroup's profit tumbled 88% as the bank took a $4.7 billion writedown related to its stake in Morgan Stanley MS +0.92% Smith Barney and a large accounting hit tied to its own debt ... Excluding the writedown and DVA, Citgroup said its net income was $3.3 billion, 27% higher than the third quarter 2011 ... Excluding the DVA impact, net income in Citigroup’s Securities and Banking unit rose 67% to $1.6 billion from the year earlier period.
So, except for all the stuff we lost money on, we made money last quarter! High fives and Macanudos for everyone!
The background to today's dismal earnings is that Citigroup has been, for several years, the big-bank equivalent of Pig-Pen, that guy from the Peanuts who was followed by a cloud of dirt everywhere he went. The bank got hit hard by the financial crisis and hasn't gotten many breaks since. It has had executives sued (unsuccessfully) for mortgage fraud, had shareholders balk at its executive pay packages, been dragged into Libor-gate, and came out on the losing end of a tête-à-tête with Morgan Stanley over the valuation of their Smith Barney joint venture. Most alarming, its five-year stock chart looks like this:
(For comparison's sake, BlackBerry-maker Research in Motion — by many accounts a nearly failed company — has essentially the same five-year losses, and it didn't get a giant government bailout.)
In fairness to Citigroup, some parts of its business are going well. Revenue in the bank's investment banking and fixed-income divisions were up over last year, and the bank says it gained "wallet share" (a horrible phrase that should never be used) "in all major products and in most regions."
Still, with its stock price and its return on equity still in the Marianas Trench, having a marginally better quarter in certain areas (excluding DVA and the MSSB writedown and whatever else Vikram Pandit thinks shouldn't count this quarter) is only a partial victory. Most days, in most ways, it's hard to see any other conclusion: Four years after it took a giant bailout and nearly died anyway, Citigroup is still fairly Screwed.
Most Viewed Stories
Exclusive: MH370 Pilot Flew a Suicide Route on His Home Simulator Closely Matching Final Flight
Ivanka’s RNC Dress Was From Her Own Line — But It Wasn’t Made in the U.S.
When Did the Media Turn Against Taylor Swift?
Why Italians, Maori, and Children of Divorce Have the Least Childhood Amnesia
Behind the Batman: The Killing Joke Movie’s Approach to Batgirl, Sex, and Sexual Violence
3 Ballerinas Tell the Truth About Dance Wellness
Ivanka Is Right About Promoting Gender Equality — and Her Father Will Do the Exact Opposite
Sophie Turner Made the Game of Thrones Team Take Vodka Shots Before Their Comic-Con Panel, Because She Rules
The Clinton-Kaine Ticket Is Safe and Boring — in a Good Way
Can Turmeric Cure Our National Inflammation?
Latest News from Daily IntelligencerThe Clinton-Kaine Ticket Is Safe and Boring — in a Good Way
Kaine is getting grief from left, but objectively some of it is undeserved. All of it, if you look at the alternative.At Least 9 Dead in Shooting ‘Rampage’ in Munich, Germany
Police gave the "all clear" early Saturday morning.Hillary Clinton Picks Virginia Senator Tim Kaine As Her Running Mate
Yes we Kaine.Hillary Clinton Withholds Veep Pick, Notes Trump Talks a Lot Like Dictator
Contrary to expectations, Clinton did not reveal her running mate in Florida on Friday, opting to rebut Donald Trump's RNC speech instead.The ‘Big’ Ratings Trump Bragged About for His RNC Speech Were Actually Not That Big
Not much higher than what Mitt Romney drew.First Baby Born in NYC With Zika Birth Defects
Department of Health officials confirm.Exclusive: MH370 Pilot Flew a Suicide Route on His Home Simulator Closely Matching Final Flight
The FBI recovered the data from a hard drive, but Malaysian authorities have not made the finding public.After Resigning From Fox News, Ailes Is Reportedly Barred From the Building, But He Gets a $40 Million Consolation Prize
Rupert Murdoch will be running the shop for a while.5 Things for Frightened Liberals to Tell Themselves About Trump’s RNC Speech
We won't know for several days whether Trump's dystopian hate speech resonated with swing voters. Until then, here are some comforting things for liberals to tell themselves.The Only Defense America Has Against Donald Trump Is His Opponent
Hillary Clinton needs to vanquish him. But it's going to be close.
Cleveland's finale.Trump’s Strongman Politics
The only solution he offers to the exaggerated problem of crime and disorder is himself.Donald Trump Jr. and the Future of Conservative Populism
The son will be the standard-bearer for his father, with some tweaks.Trump Brought Little Chaos to Cleveland – Outside the Convention Hall, Anyway
Authorities were anticipating mass violence and unrest. They got the most peaceful convention in recent memory.Fresh Intelligence: Today Is the Best Day Ever for Trump, But an Especially Terrible Day for Clinton
Our roundup of the stories, ideas, and memes you’ll be talking about today.Vicente Fox: Withdrawing From NAFTA Will Hurt the U.S., Not Mexico
Nonetheless, the former Mexican president pleaded with American voters to reject “false prophet” Donald Trump.Peter Thiel Is Pro-Trump, Mainly Because He’s Pro-Trolling
His speech at the RNC didn’t make any sense, and that may be the point.The Christian Right Has Surrendered to Trump
So recently an electoral and ideological fountainhead for the GOP, Evangelicals have given themselves over to a Philistine.Donald Trump Is Bidding to Transform the GOP Into a White-Identity-Politics Party
The meaning of one of the most significant acceptance speeches in history.Turkey Suspends European Human-Rights Convention As Parliament Approves State of Emergency
The government claims fundamental freedoms will remain in place as it continues to purge state institutions of suspected dissidents.