I've been eagerly awaiting The Daily Show's take on the platinum coin, but when it finally came Thursday night, the result was a crushing disappointment. No movie-caper scenarios, no catchphrase punch lines, just a you-so-crazy reaction. What's more, the whole premise of Jon Stewart's reaction was completely uninformed. He seems to think the plan is designed not to prevent massive market dislocations caused by Republicans refusing to lift the debt ceiling, but to cover the budget deficit. Here's his setup:
America’s got a bit of a cash-flow problem these days. We have a $16 trillion debt. Our credit rating actually got downgraded for the first time last year. So I think you can all agree it’s time to get serious and figure out a way to restore the world’s respect for the soundness of our currency ...
No, that's not it. None of those points is relevant. It's not about the deficit at all. The credit downgrade was a pure political statement by S&P, one that had no impact at all on the markets. Respect for our currency remains extremely high, as evidenced by massive demand for it even at rock-bottom interest rates. We have no cash-flow problem at all.
It's hard to say exactly what Jon Stewart and his writers think about economic policy, but there is some odd vein of Hooverism that pops up from time to time. Take his 2009 interview with White House budget director Peter Orszag:
This happened in April of 2009 as the world economy was in a free fall. The whole comedic premise of the entire interview was "Oh my God, the deficit is so big; why don't you solve that?" Stewart compared the U.S. government to a family and asked what would happen if it called up its credit card company and said it was projecting a deficit of uncertain size. (Orszag correctly replied that families run deficits with credit card companies all the time.) He prodded with questions like, "When you say 'we’re cutting that down' — when?"
Orszag tried to gently explain that it wasn't important to cut the deficit right away, but Stewart did not seem to take that premise at all. (He did push back a bit on Über-deficit-hawk Alan Simpson in a more recent interview.)
Now, obviously it's not an economics show, but the premise of a joke is supposed to be reality, and the punch line is the departure from reality. The joke here proceeds as if we all know that Herbert Hoover's views on fiscal policy are obviously correct.
Most Viewed Stories
Exclusive: MH370 Pilot Flew a Suicide Route on His Home Simulator Closely Matching Final Flight
How Fox News Fired and Silenced a Female Reporter Who Alleged Sexual Harassment
Ivanka’s RNC Dress Was From Her Own Line — But It Wasn’t Made in the U.S.
Behind the Batman: The Killing Joke Movie’s Approach to Batgirl, Sex, and Sexual Violence
The Case for Tim Kaine
Why Italians, Maori, and Children of Divorce Have the Least Childhood Amnesia
When Did the Media Turn Against Taylor Swift?
Can Turmeric Cure Our National Inflammation?
3 Ballerinas Tell the Truth About Dance Wellness
The Psychology of Why Americans Are Afraid of Historically Low Crime Levels
Latest News from Daily IntelligencerSearching for the Secret Boehner Warehouse Party
The most coveted ticket in Cleveland.Hillary Clinton and Tim Kaine Had a Great Time at the Official Veep Announcement
A rally in Miami was joyful, optimistic, and showcased exactly why Clinton picked Kaine.How Fox News Fired and Silenced a Female Reporter Who Alleged Sexual Harassment
Ailes is finished at Fox, but sexual-harassment claims are following him out the door.At Least 9 Dead in Shooting ‘Rampage’ in Munich, Germany
Police gave the "all clear" early Saturday morning.The Case for Tim Kaine
The myopia of liberal disappointment.The Clinton-Kaine Ticket Is Safe and Boring — in a Good Way
Kaine is getting grief from left, but objectively some of it is undeserved. All of it, if you look at the alternative.Hillary Clinton Picks Virginia Senator Tim Kaine As Her Running Mate
Yes we Kaine.Hillary Clinton Withholds Veep Pick, Notes Trump Talks a Lot Like Dictator
Contrary to expectations, Clinton did not reveal her running mate in Florida on Friday, opting to rebut Donald Trump's RNC speech instead.The ‘Big’ Ratings Trump Bragged About for His RNC Speech Were Actually Not That Big
Not much higher than what Mitt Romney drew.First Baby Born in NYC With Zika Birth Defects
Department of Health officials confirm.
The FBI recovered the data from a hard drive, but Malaysian authorities have not made the finding public.After Resigning From Fox News, Ailes Is Reportedly Barred From the Building, But He Gets a $40 Million Consolation Prize
Rupert Murdoch will be running the shop for a while.5 Things for Frightened Liberals to Tell Themselves About Trump’s RNC Speech
We won't know for several days whether Trump's dystopian hate speech resonated with swing voters. Until then, here are some comforting things for liberals to tell themselves.The Only Defense America Has Against Donald Trump Is His Opponent
Hillary Clinton needs to vanquish him. But it's going to be close.Trump’s Grand Finale: Scenes From the Final Day of the Republican National Convention
Cleveland's finale.Trump’s Strongman Politics
The only solution he offers to the exaggerated problem of crime and disorder is himself.Donald Trump Jr. and the Future of Conservative Populism
The son will be the standard-bearer for his father, with some tweaks.Trump Brought Little Chaos to Cleveland – Outside the Convention Hall, Anyway
Authorities were anticipating mass violence and unrest. They got the most peaceful convention in recent memory.Fresh Intelligence: Today Is the Best Day Ever for Trump, But an Especially Terrible Day for Clinton
Our roundup of the stories, ideas, and memes you’ll be talking about today.Vicente Fox: Withdrawing From NAFTA Will Hurt the U.S., Not Mexico
Nonetheless, the former Mexican president pleaded with American voters to reject “false prophet” Donald Trump.