I've been eagerly awaiting The Daily Show's take on the platinum coin, but when it finally came Thursday night, the result was a crushing disappointment. No movie-caper scenarios, no catchphrase punch lines, just a you-so-crazy reaction. What's more, the whole premise of Jon Stewart's reaction was completely uninformed. He seems to think the plan is designed not to prevent massive market dislocations caused by Republicans refusing to lift the debt ceiling, but to cover the budget deficit. Here's his setup:
America’s got a bit of a cash-flow problem these days. We have a $16 trillion debt. Our credit rating actually got downgraded for the first time last year. So I think you can all agree it’s time to get serious and figure out a way to restore the world’s respect for the soundness of our currency ...
No, that's not it. None of those points is relevant. It's not about the deficit at all. The credit downgrade was a pure political statement by S&P, one that had no impact at all on the markets. Respect for our currency remains extremely high, as evidenced by massive demand for it even at rock-bottom interest rates. We have no cash-flow problem at all.
It's hard to say exactly what Jon Stewart and his writers think about economic policy, but there is some odd vein of Hooverism that pops up from time to time. Take his 2009 interview with White House budget director Peter Orszag:
This happened in April of 2009 as the world economy was in a free fall. The whole comedic premise of the entire interview was "Oh my God, the deficit is so big; why don't you solve that?" Stewart compared the U.S. government to a family and asked what would happen if it called up its credit card company and said it was projecting a deficit of uncertain size. (Orszag correctly replied that families run deficits with credit card companies all the time.) He prodded with questions like, "When you say 'we’re cutting that down' — when?"
Orszag tried to gently explain that it wasn't important to cut the deficit right away, but Stewart did not seem to take that premise at all. (He did push back a bit on Über-deficit-hawk Alan Simpson in a more recent interview.)
Now, obviously it's not an economics show, but the premise of a joke is supposed to be reality, and the punch line is the departure from reality. The joke here proceeds as if we all know that Herbert Hoover's views on fiscal policy are obviously correct.
Most Viewed Stories
The 7 Best Lines From The Simpsons’ Food Network Send-up
Meryl Streep’s T-Shirt Promoting Suffragette Is Unfortunate
Julianna Margulies Insists There’s No Feud Between Her and Archie Panjabi; Archie Panjabi May Disagree
Jennifer Lawrence and Amy Schumer Hung Out With Their Male Equivalents, Chris Pratt and Aziz Ansari
The Big Secret of Every Dating App: Tech Doesn’t Matter
Times Square: The City’s Id, Now and Always
Stephen Colbert Gave a Searing Monologue on Guns, Trump, and ‘Honest Insanity’
Quantico Recap: Spot the Needle
What’s New on Netflix: October 2015
Adam Platt on the Best New Breakfasts in New York Right Now
Latest News from Daily IntelligencerAnn Romney Crushes Lingering ‘Mitt 2016’ Hopes
“We made the right decision,” to get out of the race, she says.Hillary Clinton Turns Kevin McCarthy’s Benghazi Gaffe into a TV Ad
To bolster her claim that Republicans are conspiring against her.No, Depressed American Towns Do Not Look Like Zimbabwe
Are trade deals turning the United States into Zimbabwe?California Becomes Fifth State to Adopt ‘Right-to-Die’ Law
Governor Jerry Brown signed the controversial legislation Monday.Commercial Flight Lands Safely After Death of Pilot
The American Airlines plane, which was on its way from Phoenix to Boston, made an emergency landing in Syracuse.House Will Choose Boehner’s Replacement One Day Before He Says ‘Bye!’
The other leadership positions will be filled at a to-be-determined date.Pizza Rat Just Got Slightly Sexier
Happy Halloween.South Carolina Floods Kill at Least 9
"This flood disaster has been like nothing South Carolina has ever seen."Edward Snowden to DOJ: Call Me Maybe?
The NSA whistle-blower is ready to go to jail, if necessary.On Eve of Playoffs, CC Sabathia Is Checking Himself Into Rehab
"I want to take control of my disease, and I want to be a better man, father and player."
Liberals are deluding themselves about Francis's openness and radicalism.Long Island Doctor, Mother of 3, Found Dead After Night Out in City
A Post source says the Manhasset dermatologist used cocaine that night with a Facebook pal.North Korea Frees NYU Student Detained Since April
The 21-year-old Joo Won-moon was captured after he crossed over from China.Amtrak Train Derails in Vermont
No fatalities have been reported so far.Biden Will Maybe Decide Whether to Run for President Soon
As soon as this weekend, according to reports.Missing Cargo Ship Sank in Hurricane, One Body Recovered
Twenty-eight Americans were aboard.Leaders Give Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Deal a Thumbs-up
But the arguing on the outside will continue evermore.Jack Dorsey Officially Becoming Twitter’s Permanent CEO
Switch-hitter Jack Dorsey returns to "prime time."John Oliver: Why Do We Only Talk About Mental Health After Mass Shootings?
"The aftermath of a mass shooting might actually be the worst time to talk about mental health."Clinton Tacks to Sanders’s Left With New Gun-Control Push
She’ll call for legislative and executive action to close loopholes.