I've been eagerly awaiting The Daily Show's take on the platinum coin, but when it finally came Thursday night, the result was a crushing disappointment. No movie-caper scenarios, no catchphrase punch lines, just a you-so-crazy reaction. What's more, the whole premise of Jon Stewart's reaction was completely uninformed. He seems to think the plan is designed not to prevent massive market dislocations caused by Republicans refusing to lift the debt ceiling, but to cover the budget deficit. Here's his setup:
America’s got a bit of a cash-flow problem these days. We have a $16 trillion debt. Our credit rating actually got downgraded for the first time last year. So I think you can all agree it’s time to get serious and figure out a way to restore the world’s respect for the soundness of our currency ...
No, that's not it. None of those points is relevant. It's not about the deficit at all. The credit downgrade was a pure political statement by S&P, one that had no impact at all on the markets. Respect for our currency remains extremely high, as evidenced by massive demand for it even at rock-bottom interest rates. We have no cash-flow problem at all.
It's hard to say exactly what Jon Stewart and his writers think about economic policy, but there is some odd vein of Hooverism that pops up from time to time. Take his 2009 interview with White House budget director Peter Orszag:
This happened in April of 2009 as the world economy was in a free fall. The whole comedic premise of the entire interview was "Oh my God, the deficit is so big; why don't you solve that?" Stewart compared the U.S. government to a family and asked what would happen if it called up its credit card company and said it was projecting a deficit of uncertain size. (Orszag correctly replied that families run deficits with credit card companies all the time.) He prodded with questions like, "When you say 'we’re cutting that down' — when?"
Orszag tried to gently explain that it wasn't important to cut the deficit right away, but Stewart did not seem to take that premise at all. (He did push back a bit on Über-deficit-hawk Alan Simpson in a more recent interview.)
Now, obviously it's not an economics show, but the premise of a joke is supposed to be reality, and the punch line is the departure from reality. The joke here proceeds as if we all know that Herbert Hoover's views on fiscal policy are obviously correct.
Most Viewed Stories
Why Is Hillary Clinton Suddenly Tied in the Polls With a Widely Reviled Demagogue?
Anne Hathaway Calls James Corden the ‘Worst British Export Since Smallpox,’ Drops the Mic on The Late Late Show
The Sad State of Game of Thrones’ Direwolves
We Probably Won’t Have True Detective to Kick Around Anymore (But We’ll Still Have Nic Pizzolatto)
Game of Thrones’ Kristian Nairn Explains His Theory on Hodor
Why Did Bernie Sanders Put an Obama-Hater on the Democratic Platform Committee?
America Has Never Been So Ripe for Tyranny
The Voice Finale Recap: And the Winner Is …
New York Times Writer Has Finally Figured Out Why People Hate Hillary Clinton
Jay Z Jumps on the New ‘All the Way Up’ Remix With a Full Verse, Mentions His Marriage, Lemonade, and Prince
Latest News from Daily IntelligencerSeveral Arrests Made After Protesters Clash with Police at Anaheim Trump Rally
At least eight people were taken into custody.Fresh Intelligence: South Carolina Signs Restrictive Abortion Bill Into Law, While 11 Other States Sue the White House
Our roundup of the stories, ideas, and memes you’ll be talking about today.11 States Sue Obama Administration Over Guidelines Protecting Transgender Students
The suit calls Obama's policy a "massive social experiment" and objects to his interpretation of Title IX.Bernie’s Independent Voters Are Very Likely to Cast Ballots for HRC in the End
Sanders's appeal in the primaries has not been for swing-voting "true independents," but for leaners who are functionally Democrats.Audit: Hillary Clinton’s Use of a Private Email Server Violated Federal Rules
A new State Department audit challenges several claims the Democratic front-runner has made about her use of a private email server while serving as secretary of State.Rep. Scott DesJarlais Is One of Trump’s Biggest Boosters in Congress. He’s Also a Total Piece of Work.
As Establishment pols like Paul Ryan consider climbing onto the Trump bandwagon, they'll be joining some dubious early-birds.Picking Elizabeth Warren As Veep Probably Wouldn’t Cost Democrats a Senate Seat
Contra Harry Reid.Donald Trump Is Underwater With the All-Important ‘Writers of Literary Fiction’ Demographic
More than 400 writers have signed a petition protesting the Donald’s candidacy. Will the millions of Trump voters with McSweeney's subscriptions be swayed?A Libertarian Candidate Is Blowing Up in the Polls and Could Figure Big in November
Former New Mexico governor Gary Johnson could become the #NeverTrump choice, muddling the electoral map.Donald Trump Suggests America’s First Latina Governor Is Too Lazy to ‘Do the Job’
New Mexico governor Susana Martinez was supposed to be the future of the Republican Party. Then Donald Trump happened.
One month ago, the general election was looking like a Clinton landslide. What changed? And will it last?Fresh Intelligence: Charleston Shooter to Face Death Penalty, While Ferguson City Attorney to Face the Music
Our roundup of the stories, ideas, and memes you’ll be talking about today.How Running for ‘Obama’s 3rd Term’ Became a Political Asset for Hillary Clinton
Her campaign used to worry about insulating her from Barack Obama's political problems. Not anymore.U.S. Seeks Death Penalty for Dylann Roof in Charleston Church Shootings
Based on "the nature of the alleged crime and the resulting harm."Protesters at New Mexico Trump Rally Throw Rocks, Bottles at Police
At least one arrest was made.In Georgia, Two Republicans Face Primary Challenges for Not Being Extremist Enough
One — Paul Broun — called evolution "lies from the pit of hell."Trump Campaign’s New Office Plan Will Keep Paul Manafort and Corey Lewandowski Away From Each Other
Paul Manafort gets a cushy floor in Trump Tower, while Corey Lewandowski gets raw space.Why Did Bernie Sanders Put an Obama-Hater on the Democratic Platform Committee?
Tapping Cornel West raises this and other questions.For Bernie Sanders in California, Time Is Slipping Away
He needs a landslide to get close to Hillary Clinton in pledged delegates, but the signs are not pointing to that.Survey Says: Majority of L Train Riders Would Rather Suffer Through Complete Shutdown Than Longer, Partial One
Seventy-seven percent said they wanted to have it completed in 18 months, instead of the three-year partial-shutdown plan.