I've been eagerly awaiting The Daily Show's take on the platinum coin, but when it finally came Thursday night, the result was a crushing disappointment. No movie-caper scenarios, no catchphrase punch lines, just a you-so-crazy reaction. What's more, the whole premise of Jon Stewart's reaction was completely uninformed. He seems to think the plan is designed not to prevent massive market dislocations caused by Republicans refusing to lift the debt ceiling, but to cover the budget deficit. Here's his setup:
America’s got a bit of a cash-flow problem these days. We have a $16 trillion debt. Our credit rating actually got downgraded for the first time last year. So I think you can all agree it’s time to get serious and figure out a way to restore the world’s respect for the soundness of our currency ...
No, that's not it. None of those points is relevant. It's not about the deficit at all. The credit downgrade was a pure political statement by S&P, one that had no impact at all on the markets. Respect for our currency remains extremely high, as evidenced by massive demand for it even at rock-bottom interest rates. We have no cash-flow problem at all.
It's hard to say exactly what Jon Stewart and his writers think about economic policy, but there is some odd vein of Hooverism that pops up from time to time. Take his 2009 interview with White House budget director Peter Orszag:
This happened in April of 2009 as the world economy was in a free fall. The whole comedic premise of the entire interview was "Oh my God, the deficit is so big; why don't you solve that?" Stewart compared the U.S. government to a family and asked what would happen if it called up its credit card company and said it was projecting a deficit of uncertain size. (Orszag correctly replied that families run deficits with credit card companies all the time.) He prodded with questions like, "When you say 'we’re cutting that down' — when?"
Orszag tried to gently explain that it wasn't important to cut the deficit right away, but Stewart did not seem to take that premise at all. (He did push back a bit on Über-deficit-hawk Alan Simpson in a more recent interview.)
Now, obviously it's not an economics show, but the premise of a joke is supposed to be reality, and the punch line is the departure from reality. The joke here proceeds as if we all know that Herbert Hoover's views on fiscal policy are obviously correct.
Most Viewed Stories
Aunt Sues Then-8-Year-Old Nephew for $127,000 Over ‘Unreasonable’ Hug
I Am Training for a Marathon. So Why Am I Getting Fat?
The First Legal Abortion Providers Tell Their Stories
Anne Hathaway Sends Breakfast Back Four Times, Like a Badass Who Knows What She Wants
Jessica Jones Has Hot Sex and Nuanced Sexuality (Especially for a Marvel Show)
I Was Diagnosed With Breast Cancer and Decided to Do Nothing
There Are Pictures of Justin Bieber’s Big Penis on the Internet
Wait, Prancercise Might Actually Work
The New Conservative Argument to Ignore Climate Change Is Even Dumber Than the Old One
How Does a White Supremacist See America Today?
Latest News from Daily Intelligencer2-Year-Old South Carolina Boy Shoots His Grandmother in the Back
He was in the backseat.Confirmed: A Russian-Made Warhead Downed Malaysia Airlines Flight MH17
But nobody's saying Russia itself pulled the trigger.New York Magazine Competition No. 58: New York Autumn Couplets
The latest installment of our game.Is It Boring to Wonder Just How Boring the Democratic Debate Will Be?
Will it be the least fun thing to ever happen in Las Vegas?Once-Great Freebie Alt-Weekly The Village Voice Sold to Non–New Yorker
Rich guys still like owning newspapers.Rand Paul Currently Trapped in His Own Truman Show in Iowa
It is not clear if the presidential candidate knows he has been stuck in the primary state for months and is being watched all the time.How Hillary Clinton Will Try to Fend Off Her Rivals (Including the One Who Isn’t There)
She wants to charm Sanders supporters while convincing potential Biden fans that she has the race in hand.Taxi TV May Finally Go Dark
You may soon be able to ride in a cab without being force-fed Jimmy Kimmel clips.The New Conservative Argument to Ignore Climate Change Is Even Dumber Than the Old One
Deconstructing the emergence of a painfully stupid talking point.Jack Dorsey’s First Big Move As Twitter CEO? Laying Off Hundreds of Employees
Which is sure to do wonders for company morale.
“I remember him shouting, ‘Auntie Jen, I love you,’ and there he was flying at me.”Russian Embassy in Syria Attacked During Pro-Government Rally
Russia says it was "obviously a terrorist act intended to, probably, frighten supporters of the war against terror."The Absolute Moron’s Guide to the First Democratic Debate
Clinton, Sanders, and the rest of the Democrats prepare for the election’s first Trump-free showdown.Citi Field Crowd Doesn’t Get to See Chase Utley Plunked, Does Get to See a Game 3 Mets Win
The Mets can advance to the NLCS Tuesday night.How Does a White Supremacist See America Today?
Don Black, founder of the white-supremacist group Stormfront, talks about Donald Trump, the Charleston shooting, and the future of his movement.Many Professors Anxious About Legally Armed Students in Their Classrooms
“The idea that our students would bring guns to our offices and classrooms was never part of the deal when we considered going into this field.”Strongman Chris Christie Fully Prepared to Start WWIII
"Don't try me."It Looks Like That Dentist Will Probably Get Away With Killing Cecil the Lion
Zimbabwe says it can't charge Walter Palmer for his outrage-inducing July hunt.Washington Post Reporter Convicted in Iran
The charges against Jason Rezaian are still unclear.The Meaning of Russia’s Intervention in Syria
As Putin embarks on what may be a new Soviet-style misadventure, a variety of experts debate the possible endgames, as well as a possible U.S. alliance.