The Obamas’ Guide to NYC: Why the First Family Should Probably Move to Brooklyn

By
Photo: Shutterstock, AFP/Getty Images

When Barack Obama leaves office on January 20, 2017, he’ll need a new place to live. And like the race to succeed him as president, as absurd as it sounds this far out, there’s already a front-runner: According to Politico, Obama just can’t stop talking about moving back to New York City, where he lived as a young dreamer in the early ‘80s. “I just desperately want to take a walk through Central Park again, and just remember what that feels like,” the president reminisced at a fund-rasier in 2012.

But his life after the White House won’t be all philosophizing in grimy apartments like the first time around. As an ex-president with an active wife, high-school-age daughter, two dogs, and vague plans to start something like the Clinton Global Initiative, Obama will need to find a new niche in a much different city than the one he knew as a poor Columbia student. The options are plentiful, but we’ve got some ideas.

Let’s just go ahead and assume price — and co-op boards — won’t be an issue.

Obama’s old place was on East 94th in Yorkville, and as he remembered in Dreams From My Father, it wasn’t pretty:

It was an uninviting block, treeless and barren, lined with soot-colored walk-ups that cast heavy shadows for the rest of the day. The apartment was small, with slanting floors and irregular heat and a buzzer downstairs that didn’t work, so that visitors had to call ahead from a pay phone at the corner gas station, where a black Doberman the size of a wolf paced through the night in vigilant patrol, its jaws clamped around an empty beer bottle.

Sure, he could move back — there are luxury high-rises around now — but the Upper East Side is Michael Bloomberg’s kingdom. You’ve got to give him his space.

15 CPW. Photo: Jb Reed/Bloomberg via Getty Images

As a junior in college, Obama tried the west side, in a two-bedroom at 109th Street. A bit south of there could be an option: Massive buildings like 15 Central Park West, home of Lloyd Blankfein, Sting, and many more bold-face names, promise privacy, space for chauffeurs, and of course the park. But even for a president, the Upper West Side seems a bit stuffy. And it could get awkward with the bankers.

They have these in the suburbs, too. Photo: SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images

Sparking Obama’s rekindled affair with the idea of the city, aides say, was his trip earlier this year to the Gap in midtown, of all places. “What he cherishes and misses is the serendipity — you don’t know who you’re going to bump into or what they’re going to say,” said presidential confidante Valerie Jarrett.

He won’t really get that in midtown. But, duly noted: He likes stores and serendipity! (Also good food, having eaten at hip spots like Blue Hill and ABC Kitchen, Harlem’s Red Rooster and Sylvias, and the decidedly less cool Junior’s in Brooklyn.)

Bill shows around Barack. Photo: MANDEL NGAN/2013 AFP

Using this knowledge, we plugged some assumed facts about what the Obamas will need into New York’s Nate Silver–helmed Livability Calculator — safety, diversity, green space all ranked high; bars and transit low — and the results favor lower Manhattan:

But that data is from a few years ago, and the rise of the other borough has only continued. Tribeca and Soho have their perks and their share of famous people, but also tourists and traffic and retail. As Politico reported, the president “loves the city and the anonymity it can provide. It may be wishful thinking, but he and his wife crave a return to a life in which they can stroll into a CVS or down the street without fanfare.”

What they need is space. What they need is Brooklyn. (They have CVS there.)

Imagine: A tree-lined brownstone with high ceilings, a private study for the president to write in, a garden for Michelle, a nearby park for Bo and Sunny … It’d be urban bliss, if not anonymously. Park Slope and Brooklyn Heights topped the Brooklyn choices above.

Fort Greene is also an attractive option, at once a “culinary mecca,” “a bastion of African-American pride and culture,” and “the artistic center of the borough”:

What new and old residents have found is that Fort Greene plays all of these roles with grace and aplomb. It is a busy, blooming hybrid whose slate-sidewalk streets somehow retain their serenity. No one is in a hurry — even as newcomers rush in from all corners of the city to live here.

Bo and Sunny would love the green space. In the immortal words of Spike Lee, “Have you seen Fort Greene Park in the morning? It’s like the motherfuckin’ Westminster Dog Show.” A few blocks over, Clinton Hill and Bed Stuy are also still on the come-up.

“When I was living here, Brooklyn was cool, but not this cool,” said Obama in the borough last year. In addition to his places in the city, Obama spent the mid-’80s on Second Street in Park Slope, in a 109-year-old house. The area has only gotten nicer since — “the very definition of a well-rounded neighborhood.” The de Blasios, we’re sure, would be happy to show them around; reelection could keep New York’s own first family in Gracie Mansion through 2021. And Bill knows just the place for Barack to play basketball: He swears by the Prospect Park YMCA. The park isn’t so bad either.

A mother and daughter walk through a field of fallen leaves in Prospect Park, Brooklyn. Photo: Andrew Lichtenstein

It could all come down to a teenager. The Obamas’ younger daughter will be 15 at the end of the term, a sophomore in high school. “Sasha will have a big say in where we are,” the president told Barbara Walters last year.

There’s not quite an NYC Sidwell Friends, but the top-tier private schools are plentiful: Trinity, Brearley, and Horace Mann are among the top prep schools in the nation. (U.S. ambassador Caroline Kennedy, a Brearley alumna, could write a hell of a recommendation.) If Sasha feels like overachieving in public school, there’s always Stuyvesant and Bronx Science. (Admission is tough, but her father is Barack Obama, so ...)

If given the choice, what teen doesn’t want to live in New York City — especially Brooklyn? Just ask Dante

Sasha (L) and Malia Obama, daughters of US President Barack Obama, take a photo of themselves during the Presidential Inaugural Parade on January 21, 2013 in Washington, DC. Photo: JOE KLAMAR/AFP/Getty Images

The wild card is Westchester.  The Hudson Valley is trendy, but it’s also spacious and convenient, offering both small-town charms and proximity to city life. Since commuting won’t be an issue for a family with Secret Service protection, anonymity could be achieved more realistically a bit north of the city in a village like, say, Chappaqua, where the Clintons set up:

[Bill] orders a decaf venti at Starbucks (and always tips) and stops in at Lange’s Little Store and Delicatessen and chats with everyone there. When Mrs. Clinton is around, they go to movies at the Jacob Burns Film Center in neighboring Pleasantville and are reliable diners at local restaurants like Le Jardin du Roi, Crabtree’s Kittle House and the Chappaqua Restaurant and Cafe … Their chocolate Labrador retriever, Seamus, and toy poodle, Tally, are both groomed at Wags and Whiskers. The Clintons are both groomed at Santa’s Salon and Spa.

It does sound like a nice life. And if it seems like there’s not enough room in the area for two ex-presidents, the Clintons may be back in Washington by then anyway.