A Long History of Assuming That Chuck Schumer’s Day of Glory Would One Day Come

By
14 Jan 2014, Washington, DC, USA --- Senator Chuck Schumer (D-NY) speaks to the media about the failure of a procedural vote to end debate and advance an unemployment insurance extension bill forward for a final vote during a press conference on Capitol Hill. --- Image by ? Pete Marovich/Corbis
FINALLY.Photo: Pete Marovich/Corbis

When Senator Harry Reid announced he would retire next year, he also endorsed Senator Chuck Schumer as his replacement as Democratic leader of the Senate. Schumer’s chief rival, Senator Dick Durbin, also endorsed the New York senator. 

This is one of the least surprising developments in recent political history, as Schumer has been described as Reid’s replacement for more than half of his Senate career. He always denied that he was thinking about such things, but everyone assumed anyway. 

The probable coronation won’t happen for another year and a half, and there’s still plenty of ways the prophecy could be proven wrong, but for once, it looks like American politics is going to follow the script printed out for it in advance.

January 23, 2006, New York Magazine

Indeed, for Schumer, the Alito hearings marked yet another step in his improbable political ascent: from New York’s favorite schlepper senator to national Democratic macher … “Chuck thinks that he can be the Senate Democratic leader some day — that’s what he’s aiming for,” says a senior party operative.

May 1, 2007, The New York Daily News

A prediction: If Hillary Clinton isn’t the next President, she or Chuck Schumer will be the next majority leader, assuming Reid’s stewardship doesn’t hand the Senate back to the Republicans.

November 12, 2008, New York Observer

As Cook Political Report analyst Jennifer Duffy put it, “I don’t see him as somebody who aspires to 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue — I think he is the ultimate legislator and he aspires to majority leader. I think his ambitions do not have to be realized tomorrow, and he has invested a lot of time in them, so he lets things work themselves out.” Asked if he had any plans to serve as majority leader down the road, Mr. Schumer said, “I’m not even going to speculate.

November 4, 2009, New York Observer

There are, of course, ways to leave a profound Senate legacy without holding the office of majority leader. Mr. Schumer’s model Jacob Javits never did; neither did Ted Kennedy. Yet no one who knows him doubts that the hypothetical has crossed his mind.

April 2, 2010, The New Yorker

Harry Reid, the Democrats’ leader in the Senate, is facing a challenging race for a fifth term in Nevada, potentially opening the door for Schumer to replace him. But, in keeping with senatorial tradition, Schumer must not acknowledge the possibility that the job of leader will become vacant or that he has any interest in filling it.

August 29, 2010, The New York Post

So, what would a Schumer-led Senate look like? Cosmetically, at least, it would function much more smoothly than under Reid. “Reid is a master of the inside game, but he’s a disaster media-wise,” says a former Schumer aide. “Chuck’s a master of the outside game. He’s a skilled media guy. Who do I want on ‘Meet the Press’? Chuck.”

May 21, 2010, The Washington Post

Now, with confidant Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (Nev.) hanging on to his seat by a thread, the Brooklynite is nearing the goal line of his long game. … Schumer declined to be interviewed for this article and betrays an uncharacteristic loss for words whenever the term “majority leader” is uttered. 

October 28, 2010, The New York Times 

For Mr. Schumer, it would be bittersweet to seek Mr. Reid’s post. People close to both men say that Mr. Schumer considers Mr. Reid a close friend and attributes much of his success in the Senate to him.

March 28, 2013, National Journal  

Looming in the distance is a potential leadership showdown between Schumer and Senate Majority Whip Dick Durbin, D-Ill., whenever current Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., decides to retire.

April 19, 2013, The New York Post

Everyone presumes that Sen. Chuck Schumer, the media-hungry Democrat from New York, wants to be the next Senate majority leader.

June 24, 2013, The New Yorker

Durbin and Schumer are, respectively, the second- and third-ranking Democrats in the Senate, and each would like Reid’s job when he steps down. … Durbin conceals his ambition more artfully than Schumer does.

July 5, 2014, The Washington Examiner

Reid’s departure would leave a major power vacuum among Senate Democrats, one most likely filled by Schumer, the powerful Rules Committee chairman who has aggressively, if patiently, pursued the Democratic leadership post for years.

July 25, 2013, National Journal

Chuck Schumer has been many things: an aggressive partisan who led his party to a Senate majority; an unapologetic media hound who loves the camera; a denizen of the rat-infested Capitol Hill group house that inspired an upcoming Amazon streaming TV series; and a brash contender to one day become Senate majority leader.

October 2, 2014, The Washington Free Beacon

He went on to ask Pryor who would be the best option to succeed Reid as majority leader. Pryor suggested Sen. Chuck Schumer (D., N.Y.), saying he “does a pretty darn good job there in the Senate, and he’s actually, he’s not this crazy wild-eyed, left wing liberal either.”

November 25, 2014, The Atlantic

So it was a significant moment on Tuesday morning when Schumer, New York’s senior senator and a likely heir to Reid, called for Democrats to “embrace government” as they try to hold the White House and recapture control of Congress in 2016.