Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

mickey mantle's

All the Memorabilia From Mickey Mantle’s Is Up for Auction, Which Doesn’t Please Everybody

You may have heard that Mickey Mantle's, the Central Park South sports bar bearing the name of the Yankees legend (who was once an investor and frequent visitor), is closing. After months of failing to pay rent and making desperate fund-raising attempts to avoid bankruptcy, the restaurant was finally shuttered with all of its valuable sports memorabilia padlocked inside. Some of those artifacts got claimed by their respective donors well before the bankruptcy, but the rest of them — including countless autographs, photos, and even seats from the old stadium — are up for auction next week.

This development is particularly troubling to Marty Appel, a renowned Yankee historian and public relations magnate. In an effort to help the restaurant out, Appel donated 22 framed items from his personal collection. This was just weeks ago — days before the windows got shuttered and the walls got stripped bare. Appel, who was promised that he'd recover his stuff if the place ever closed, is now dismayed to find his beloved items included in that auction, and he's apparently not alone in that dilemma:

Bankruptcy trustee Allan Mendelsohn said Appel wasn’t the only claimant trying to recover property culled from the restaurant where Mantle once held court.

Appel “sent me a letter — and believe you me, he was not the only guy,” said Mendelsohn. “There are a lot of people who claim to have stuff in there.”

If their assertions are true, “they may have a claim to the fund from the proceeds of the auction,” the trustee said.

So, Appel might get some of the money back for his belongings, but that doesn't seem to be the point. The point was that he spent time and effort assembling a collection of things he loved, generously offered those things to a struggling business, and now has to either watch his collection get unceremoniously dismantled (puns!) and sold or buy back his own property, which, from the sound of things, isn't something he's wont to do. It's not the end of the world. It's just another bummer on top of what was already a bummer of a story.