The rating scale of 0 to 100 reflects our editors’ appraisals of all the tangible and intangible factors that make a restaurant or bar great — or terrible — regardless of price.

Read more about the new ratings
84 Very Good

From the team behind Dead Rabbit comes this Pier A drinkery, designed to invoke American bars that fled to Cuba during Prohibition.

22 Battery Place, second fl., New York, NY, 10004


Known For

The lowdown

BlackTail is positing a thesis: This is what a what an American bar would feel like if it moved down to Cuba during the Prohibition era. Serious study has gone into the creation of this spot from the same team behind downtown’s Dead Rabbit, an ode to Five Points–era New York. The dark wood-walled space houses a reproduction of John Vanderlyn’s “Landing of Columbus,” a bust of Cuban liberator José Martí, as well as barstools meticulously copied from Ernest Hemingway’s favorite Havana haunt, El Floridita. A live band, and servers outfitted in guayaberas and fedoras keep the place from feeling too stuffy as you pick out a drink from five categories: highballs, punches, sours, old fashioned, and cocktails. While the classics are on the menu, they have been tweaked with global modern ingredients, like tonka bean and goji berry. The signature rum and cola does indeed have rum and coke, but is augmented with amaro, bitters, and Champagne. There’s a food menu as well, with Cuban-influenced bar bites including sweet plantains.

What you need to know

DrinksFull Bar

Noise LevelCivilized