Home > Nightlife & Music > Milk & Honey

Milk & Honey

Critics' Pick

134 Eldridge St., New York, NY 10002
nr. Broome St. See Map | Subway Directions Hopstop Popup
Send to Phone

Reader Rating:
8.6 out of 10
|
10 Reviews | Write a Review
Scene: Hot Spot, Nightclub, Romantic, Swank

Map Rate & Review

Official Website

mlkhny.com

Hours

Daily, 9pm-3am

Nearby Subway Stops

F at Delancey St.; J, M, Z at Essex St.; B, D at Grand St.

Payment Methods

Cash Only

Profile

Milk & Honey is owner Sasha's personal retaliation against celebrity-obsessed nightlife. One of the bar's rules prohibits "name-dropping and starfucking"; only mellow, non-famous folk receive the unlisted address; and all must call ahead to be buzzed in through the surveillance system-equipped door. The space encompasses a candlelit lounge, a four-seat bar and a few reservation-only booths. Sasha himself meticulously prepares each expensive cocktail, with blood oranges for screwdrivers and fresh mint for mojitos. Drinks often arrive with complimentary warm nuts or honey-drizzled sliced fruit. The intended effect is achieved—even a nice nobody can feel like royalty. That is, if you can get on the guest list. — Shana Liebman

Extra

Despite the fact that everybody's in the same club, groups at Milk and Honey don't tend to mingle. And don't even think of scoring phone numbers: Sasha has ordained that, "Gentleman will not introduce themselves to ladies."

It was our first time at M & H. We showed up with a group of 8 at 1130 or so - the host told us they would try to accommodate us in an hour or so we returned at about 1 am ( now being only four people) and Michael the host went out of his way to find us a place to wait for a few minutes and got to know us and our drink desires. He seated us and we were off to the most adept mixology in NYC if not in the country. The "Penicillin" was the most interesting drink we have ever had - (three of us are in a mixology club and were thrilled by Sasha's skills and subtle performance) Great place - with good rules and standards - A total experience - THANKS MICHAEL !!

Nice and inconvenient

VaninaG from 10025 | Posted on 7/5/09

Overall Rating: 6 (Mixed Reviews)

Milk and Honey would be the perfect place to hang out and relax after a hard day's work; a haven where to rest from crowded, loud bars if you happened to be in the neighborhood. A great place to drop by. But wait. There is a reservation-only policy. So unless one can afford or be infatuated enough with the place to pay for a membership, which allows unlimited, impromptu access (even though calling is strongly recommended), I would say don't bother. Yes, it is quiet. Yes, there is old school jazz playing in the background. Yes, the bartender knows his stuff. But then, you find all the same things at Angel's Share, without the fuss. As Milk and Honey's pros are not that exceptional, its cons make it unworth the while: the tiny space allotted to non-members feels claustrophobic, and the freedom given to the bartender does not mean tremendous creativity on his side, but rather the conviction that his somewhat boring, unbalanced cocktails are the best in the world.

Read All 10 Reviews >>