Profile

Built in 1904 as the Beaux-Arts Seville Hotel, the Carlton spent the last few decades as a decaying mid-range property before undergoing a total renovation at the turn of this century. Sixty million dollars later, the transformation is stunning: All 316 rooms and suites have been refurbished, 17,000 square feet have been added, and a relocated, three-story lobby now faces Madison Avenue. With flattering low-lighting and a rich palette of mahoganies, golds, and creams, the hotel glows from within, casting everyone inside in a romantic haze. Rooms range from small fulls and standard queens to well-sized kings and suites, and feature high-end touches not found in many higher-priced hotels. There’s complimentary in-room wi-fi, Apple iHome systems with iPod docks, Penhaligon’s toiletries, and comfortable beds dressed in Frette linens. Another perk: Room service hails from Country, Geoffrey Zakarian’s exceptional two-level lobby restaurant topped by an early-1900s Tiffany-style glass dome rediscovered during the restoration. Like the Carlton itself, the surrounding, mainly residential neighborhood has also cleaned up nicely of late and now offers a quiet, central location for both business and leisure travelers. With all the renovations, prices are no longer as much of a steal as before, but the hotel’s charms and perks make it worth the splurge. — Sandra Ramani

The rooms are attractive, and the location is convenient.

Cons
Not a lot of conveniences in the surrounding blocks; no spa or fitness center.