While Astoria has long been the go-to place for Greek cuisine, Eliá, a laid-back but elegant taverna, makes Bay Ridge a destination to be reckoned with for top-notch Hellenic eats. The neighborhood, which adjoins the Verrazano Bridge, is a melting pot of Italians, Irish, Middle Easterners, and Greeks. In the late 1990s, Pete Lekkas decided people in the area were ready for more than gyro joints and opened Eliá, offering deftly grilled meats and fish, as well as oven-baked casseroles. For entrées, lamb yuvetsi entices with a heady aroma of cinnamon and nutmeg. The shank is slow-braised, and the meat is literally falling off the bone. It’s worth lingering over your meal: With bright white-washed brick walls and pinky-peach accents, the dining room feels sunny. Eliá makes its patrons, largely locals, feel that way, too. — Michael Anstendig
Recommended Dishes
Pikilia, $9; lamb yuvetsi, $18; shrimp Eliá, $21
9.0
"Highly Recommended" Average Reader Rating on a Scale of 10
Writing the 1st review, i decided I should introduce my bf to this place. We walked in w/o reservations and were given a seat at the bar while we waited for a table. Busy Sat night crowd of young and older couples, many candles lighting the resto. 15 min later, we were seated & told the specials. A small bowl of olives and warm bread were placed on the table,perfect to nibble on as we perused the menu. We ordered 2 appetizers, the pikilia, an assortment of dips served w/ warm pita, and the grilled octopus, both really good. For entrees, I tried a special, halibut with almond sauce over sunchoke puree with roasted cauliflower, and my bf got what our waiter assured him was the largest dish - a veal chop - and he was not kidding, it was enormous! We both enjoyed the dinner, tho my bf felt the place was a bit small. Our waiter was very helpful and informed about the food. We were too full for dessert, even my bf who can eat a ton! Next time we'll save room for dessert... and there will definitely be a next time!
My brother and I took our mother here for her birthday. We were a group of 8 people, made reservations & when we arrived, were seated quickly by a very warm & gracious host. We got a carafe of wine right away, and appetizers shortly afterwards - delicious! Several of us got the octopus salad special, and were all raving about it, the entrees that followed did not disappoint! My branzini was perfectly grilled, i ate every bite, & every dish was presented beautifully. Mousakka came in little layered rounds, also delicious. Desserts were yummy, tried a phyllo dessert layered with a thick custard, served w/ a semolina gelato - filling, very good and not too sweet. Service throughout dinner was excellent, attentive but not overbearing, and we weren't rushed at all. Atmosphere was quaint and rustic, we saw a few couples eating there at the smaller tables. My mother loved the place so much that she went back a week later with her fiance. I will definitely be going again!