New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Alchemy

Alchemy Menu

  • Takeout Available

breakfast
Mon-fri: 9am-4pm, We Use Organic Eggs From Lancaster County
Croissant with jam       2.50
Pain Au Chocolat       2.50
Three Minute Egg with toast points       3.50
Toad in a Hole egg fried in rustic sourdough with tomato dill cream sauce       5
Egg & Cheddar Cheese on English Muffin       4
With Bacon or Ham Add       1
On Croissant Add       2
Eggs Any Style with toast and potato rosti       7
Tofu or Egg scramble, Omelet with toast, potato rosti and any two fillings cheese, spinach, mushrooms, onions, tomato, peppers, sausage       8.50
Extra Fillings Add       1
Swiss Breakfast potato rosti, smoked salmon, over easy egg, sour cream, capers & onion       8
Sweet Guinness Pancakes with fresh fruit       7.50
French Toast with fresh fruit       7.50
Granola with greek yogurt, honey and fresh fruit       8
breakfast sides
Bacon or Sausage       2
Fried Bangers with maple syrup       3
Mixed Green Salad       5
Fruit Plate       5
Potato Rosti       2
Toast       1

lunch

Soup of the Day     cup 4.50   bowl 7
Beet Salad with mixed greens, goat cheese and toasted almonds       8
Zucchini Carpaccio Salad with arugula, parmesan lemon and olive oil       9
Caesar Salad with garlic croutons       8
Add Chicken to Any Salad       3
Fried Calamari with curry batter and pomodoro sauce       9
Cup of Soup and Any Salad       10
Gorgonzola Walnut Ravioli with wilted arugula and browned butter sage sauce       15
Rigatoni With Sausage with spicy tomato cream sauce       16
Alchemy Shells & Cheese with peas, bacon and bread crumb topping       13
Spring Vegetable Barley Risotto with pea puree, asparagus, zucchini, parmesan and truffle oil       15
Grilled All Natural Chicken Sandwich with bacon, arugula, pickled onions and garlic mayo       12
Grilled Veggie Sandwich with goat cheese and cilantro pesto on 7 grain       10.50
House Made Veggie Burger on an onion brioche bun with lettuce, tomato and shallot confit       11
All Natural Turkey Burger on an onion brioche bun with lettuce, tomato and shallot confit       11.50
Grass Fed Angus Burger on an onion brioche bun with lettuce, tomato and shallot confit       14
Alchemy Blt smoked bacon, romaine lettuce, tomato, garlic mayo       10
Add bacon, swiss, cheddar, havarti, Blue or Goat Cheese       1
Alchemy Fish & Chips beer battered cod, french fries and house made tartar sauce       17
Salade Niçoise with grilled fresh tuna       17.50
Steak & Fries grilled grass fed hanger with herbed butter       19.50
Grass Fed Steak Salad with mixed greens, avocado, roasted red pepper, red onion and blue cheese       16
sides
Shells & Cheese       6.50
Sautéed Spinach       6.50
French Fries       5
Side Salad       7
kids
Grilled Cheese and Fries       7.50
Mini Burger and Fries       8
Pasta with oil or butter and salt       7.50
Grilled Chicken Breast and Fries       7.50

substitution of vegetable for potato $1.50

dinner

Soup of the Day     cup 5   bowl 7.50
Beet Salad with mixed greens, goat cheese and toasted almonds       8.50
Zucchini Carpaccio Salad with arugula, parmesan lemon and olive oil       9.50
Caesar Salad with garlic croutons       8.50
Add Chicken to Any Salad       3.50
Spare Ribs with house barbeque sauce       8
Fried Calamari with curry batter and pomodoro sauce       9.50
Pei Mussels white-wine-scallion, tomato-cilantro or coconut-chili-basil       12
Gorgonzola Walnut Ravioli with wilted arugula and brown butter sage sauce       16
Rigatoni With Sausage with spicy tomato cream sauce       17
Alchemy Shells & Cheese with peas, bacon and bread crumb topping       13.50
Spring Vegetable Barley Risotto with pea puree, asparagus, zucchini, parmesan and truffle oil, all sandwiches served with french fries       16
Grilled All Natural Chicken Sandwich with bacon, arugula, pickled onions and garlic mayo       13
House Made Veggie Burger on an onion brioche bun with lettuce, tomato and shallot confit       12
All Natural Turkey Burger on an onion brioche bun with lettuce, tomato and shallot confit       12
Grass Fed Angus Burger on an onion brioche bun with lettuce, tomato and shallot confit       15
Add bacon, swiss, cheddar, havarti, Blue or Goat Cheese       1
Fish of the Day      
Alchemy Fish & Chips beer battered cod, french fries and house made tartar sauce       18
Salade Niçoise with fresh grilled tuna       19
Duck Confit Cassoulet with white beans, pulled pork, merguez sausage and dried cherry sauce       19.50
Grilled Grass Fed Hanger Steak with herbed butter, mashed potatoes and spicy kale       23
Roasted All Natural Chicken with peppercorn gravy, mashed potatoes and brussels sprouts       19.50
sides
Shells & Cheese with peas and bacon       6.50
Brussels sprouts, Spicy Kale & Spinach       6.50
French fries, Mashed Potatoes       5
kids
Grilled Cheese and Fries       7.50
Mini Burger and Fries       8
Pasta with oil or butter and salt       7.50
Grilled Chicken and Fries       7.50

substitution of vegetable for potato $1.50

brunch

Sat-sun: 11-4, We Use Organic Eggs From Lancaster County and Organic Fair Trade Coffee From Counter Culture Coffee

Eggs Benedict with canadian bacon, hollandaise, fries and salad       11.50
Eggs Norwegian with smoked salmon, hollandaise, fries and salad       12.50
Eggs Florentine with spinach, hollandaise, fries and salad       11.50
Corned Beef Hash & Eggs with hollandaise and salad       11.50
Chorizo Eggs sunny side up eggs, jalapeno grits, spanish chorizo and salad       11.50
Huevos Rancheros with cheese, black beans, tomato sauce, sour cream and guacamole       11.50
With Chorizo       12.50
Grass Fed Hanger Steak & Eggs with fries and salad       20
Eggs Any Style with salad and fries       8
Tofu or Egg scramble, Omelet with any two fillings, fries and salad       9.50
Cheese, spinach, mushrooms, onions, tomato, peppers, Sausage Extra Fillings       1
Sweet Guinness Pancakes with fresh fruit       10
Brioche French Toast with fresh fruit       10
Granola with greek yogurt, honey and fresh fruit       9
Soup of the Day     cup 4.50   bowl 7
Caesar Salad       8
With Grilled All Natural Chicken       11
Alchemy Shells & Cheese with peas, bacon and bread crumb topping       12
Alchemy Blt smoked bacon, romaine lettuce, tomato, garlic mayo, fries and salad       10
House Made Veggie Burger on an onion brioche with shallot confit, fries and salad       11
Grass Fed Angus Burger on an onion brioche with shallot confit, fries and salad       14
All Natural Turkey Burger on an onion brioche bun with shallot confit, fries and salad       12
drinks
Coffee, Tea       1
Cappuccino, Latte       3.50
Fresh Oj       3.50
Espresso       2
Bloody Mary       7
Mimosa       8
sides
Bacon or Sausage       3
Fried Bangers with maple syrup       4
Mixed Green Salad or Fruit Plate       5
Fries       5
Jalapeno Grits       4
Toast       1
happy hour
Wines $4, Local Beers and Well Drinks $5 Plates
One Dozen Mussels with tomato, coconut chili or white-wine-scallion-pine-nut sauce      
Bbq’d Spare Ribs with house bbq sauce      
With House Bbq Sauce with curry batter and pomodoro sauce      
Mini Alchemy Burger on english muffin cheddar, swiss, havarti, blue, bacon       1
Spicy Chicken Wings spicy chicken wings      
Mixed Green Salad with red wine vinaigrette      
French Fries       3
desserts
Our Home Made Desserts
Sticky Guinness Pudding with toffee sauce and candied hazel nuts       8
Apple Cheddar Crisp with vanilla gelato       8
Coconut Crème Brulée       7
Warm Chocolate Espresso Cake with vanilla gelato       7
Chocolate Croissant Bread Pudding with bushmill’s creme anglaise       8
Gelato, Sorbet dark chocolate, vanilla, sorbet of the week from il laboratorio del gelato       6
A la Mode       1.50

bacon, swiss, cheddar, havarti, blue, goat $1

drinks

draft beer & bottled beer
Seasonal Draft      
Blue Point Toasted Lager       5
Captain Lawrence Brown Ale       6
Shipyard Blue Fin Irish Stout       6
Doc’s Pear Cider       6
Kelso Pilsner       6
Six Point Bengali Tiger Ipa       7
Ommegang Witte check out these other local brewers we feature for our seasonal drafts       7
Greenport harbor, Southampton Sam Smith Oatmeal Stout       (5.50ml) 11
Southern tier, Riverhorse Chimay Red       12
Schaffer Can       3.50
Butternuts Pork Slap Ale Can       5
Pacifico       6
Czechvar       6
Brooklyn Lager       6
Avery Brown Ale       6
Amstel Light       6
Peak Organic Fall Summit Ale       6.50
Delerium Tremens       10
Hitachino White       11
martinis
The Emily Rose hendrick’s, lillet, lemon, honey       12
The Ruby campari, gin, ruby red grapefruit, lemon       10
Mocha Martini alchemia chocolate vodka, kahlua, créme de cacao, espresso       11
Sidecar cognac, lemon, patron citronage, sugar       11
Passionfruit Cosmo citrus vodka, patron citronage, cranberry, passionfruit purée, lime       10
Sazerac maker’s mark, pernod, bitters, sugar       12
Strawberry-jalapeno Margarita jalapeño infused tequila, patron citronage, fresh strawberries, lime juice, sugar       11
The East Side tanqueray, cucumber, mint, lime       10
classics
The Tipperary jameson’s, green chartreuse, dry vermouth, orange bitters       9.50
Brooklyn rittenhouse rye, sweet vermouth, maraschino liqueur       9
Gin Blind bombay, cognac, patron citronage, orange bitters       10
Champagne Cocktail prosecco, cognac, angostura bitters, sugar       9
Atomic Fireball pimm’s, stoli oranj, campari, grenadine, old fashioned bitters       8
Tincture of the Moon sambuca, absolut       9
Antrim Cocktail cognac, ruby port, sugar       8
Old Fashioned maker’s mark, orange, sugar, angostura bitters, soda       12
cocktails
Gin Smith tanqueray, rosemary, honey, pear purée, soda       10
Clamberskull wild turkey, fresh ginger, o.j., honey       10
Dark & Stormy gosling’s rum, ginger, honey, lime, soda       9.50
Pomegranate Margarita sauza gold, citronage, pomegranate juice, lemon, lime, sugar       9.50
Slippery Slope maker’s mark, lemon, lime, sugar, mint       9.50
The Stoop citrus vodka, cucumbers, strawberries, mint, lemonade       9.50
King’s County Iced Tea citrus vodka, iced tea, lemonade, mint       9
Passionfruit Mojito bacardi limon, limes, mint, passionfruit puree, sugar, soda       9
The Brazilian organic cachaca, sainte germaine, limes       10
The Consigliari averna amarro, ginger, pineapple, soda       10

wine by the glass

red
Primativo, Negro Amaro Grandpa Chacha’s Home Style wine, salento, Italy ’09       7
Cotes Du Rhone les cigales, France ’09       8
Sangiovese carpineto, dogajolo, Super tuscan, Italy ’09       9
Pinot Noir Cycles gladiator, Central coast, Ca ’10       9
Montepulciano D’abruzzo Barone cornaccia, Italy ’09       10
Merlot Wolffer estate, sagaponack, Ny ’07       11
white
Pinot Grigio cadonini, Delle venezie, Italy 09       7
Keuka Village White ravines, Finger lakes, Ny ‘08       8
Pinot Blanc Jean rosen, d’alsace, France ’09       8
Gruner Veltliner Kremser kogl, Austria ‘10       8
Chardonnay Hanging vine, lodi, Ca 08       9
Vidal Blanc Brooklyn oenology, Finger Lakes ’10       9
sparkling & rose
Prosecco del Veneto Astoria       9
Sparkling rosé lamberti, Vino Spumante       10
Rosé Brooklyn oenology, Ny ‘09       9
Advertising