New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Benny's Burritos (West)

Benny's Burritos (West) Menu

  • Takeout Available | Delivery Available
  • Delivery Hours:
    Daily, 11:30am-11pm
  • Delivery Area:
    Houston St. to 28th St., Broadway to West Side Hwy.

appetizers

Salsa Cruda chips       2.50
Salsa Bambino chips       2.50
Guacamole chips       4.50

salads

Served With Homemade Balsamic Vinaigrette

House Salad       4.50
Mexican Taco Salad mixed field greens, salsa cruda & guacamole in a crispy tomato tortilla shell, topped with jack cheese       7.75
Grilled Chicken Salad mexican taco salad topped with grilled marinated chicken in a crispy tomato tortilla shell       10.75

quesadillas & nachos

Quesadilla lightly grilled 12" flour tortilla folded over melted monterey jack cheese       4.25
Nachos monterey jack cheese melted over crisp golden corn chips       4.25
Create Your Own Quesadilla or Nachos      
choices
Salsa Cruda       1.25
Jalapenos       1.25
Black Beans       1.25
Spanish or Brown Rice       1.25
Tomato       1.25
Sour Cream       1.25
Tofu Sour Cream       1.25
Guacamole       2.25
Roasted Vegetables       2.25
Grilled Chicken       2.75
Pulled Chicken       2.75
Ground Beef Picadillo       2.75
Shredded Beef       2.75

tacos, tacos, tacos

Our Unique Double-shelled Tacos Feature a Hard Shell on the Outside and a Soft Shell on the Inside to Give You a Unique Crunch and Corn Taste experience; Stuffed With lettuce, Salsa cruda, Monterey Jack Cheese and Your Choice of Filling

Plate of Two served with rice & beans and sour cream on the side       8.25
choose two
Rice & Beans      
Beef Picadiillo      
Shredded Beef      
Bbq Chicken      
Jamaican Jerk Chicken      
Havana Chicken      
Grilled Chicken      
Pulled Chicken      

benny's burritos

Our Burritos Are Stuffed With Creamy Black beans, Spanish rice, and Monterey Jack Cheese and Served With Sour Cream and Salsa on the Side (add Guacamole to Any Burrito For 75 cents)

chicken
Chicken Burritos grilled or pulled in a flour tortilla       8.75
Mini Chicken With Salad a smaller version of the above with fresh salad and balsamic vinaigrette dressing       8.75
Super Chicken like the chicken burrito with guacamole, sour cream and salsa cruda inside       9.75
Jamaican Jerk Chicken tender chunks of chicken (grilled or pulled) cooked in a spicy jerk sauce with sweet plantains wrapped in a curry tortilla       10.25
Bbq Chicken chicken (grilled or pulled) simmered in a tangy bbq sauce wrapped in a tomato tortilla       9.50
Havana Chicken chicken (grilled or pulled) marinated in a cuban sofrito sauce (spicy tomato with sautéed peppers and onions) in a curry tortilla       10.25
Chicken Fajita Burrito tender strips of grilled marinated chicken breast wrapped in a flour tortilla, with lettuce, fresh salsa cruda and tangy green tomatillo sauce, served with rice, beans, and jalapenos       11.50
beef
Spicy Ground Beef Picadillo in a chili tortilla       8.75
Shredded Beef in a flour tortilla       8.95
Mini-shredded Beef With Salad       8.95
Bbq Beef in a tomato tortilla       9.75
Super Shredded Beef like the shredded beef burrito with guacamole, sour cream and salsa cruda inside       9.95
Super Beef Picadillo like the picadillo burrito with guacamole, sour cream and salsa cruda inside       9.75
vegetarian
Good Burrito creamy black beans, spanish rice and monterey jack cheese in a flour tortilla       7.75
Good No-dairy Burrito creamy black beans, brown rice & soy cheese wrapped in a whole wheat tortilla, salsa and tofu "sour cream" on the side       7.75
Mini-good or Mini-good No-dairy With Salad       7.75
Super Veg the same as the good with lettuce, fresh salsa cruda, guacamole inside a flour tortilla       9.50
Super Veg No-dairy the same as the super veg in a whole wheat tortilla, with brown rice and soy cheese, tofu "sour cream"       9.50
Fresh Roasted Vegetable (in a Tomato tortilla)       8.95
Mini-vegetable With Salad       8.95

any burrito can be made non-dairy and heart-smart by substituting soy cheese, our homemade tofu "sour cream", brown rice, and a whole-wheat tortilla at no extra charge and any burrito can be made "wet" by topping with our own spicy sofrito sauce for $1

benny's platters

Quesadilla Grande a giant 12" flour tortilla lightly grilled and folded over melted monterey jack cheese, creamy black beans, jalapenos, salsa cruda, spanish rice and fresh guacamole       8.95
With Chicken grilled or pulled       10.95
Mini-quesadilla Grande With Salad       8.95
With Chicken grilled or pulled       10.95
Nachos Grande fresh tortilla chips with melted monterey jack cheese, vegetarian chili, guacamole, fresh salsa cruda, and sour cream       8.95
With Chicken (grilled or pulled) or Beef Picadillo       10.95
Beans and Rice Plate generous helpings of our creamy black beans and spanish rice       4.95
Topped With Melted Monterey Jack Cheese       add 0.90
Topped With Sofrito Sauce       add 1
Fresh Roasted Vegetables Plate fresh roasted vegetables, creamy black beans and spanish rice       7.50
Topped With Melted Jack Cheese       add 0.90
Topped With Sofrito Sauce       add 1
Red or Green Enchilada 2 tender soft corn tortillas folded over creamy black beans and spanish rice, topped with your choice of tangy green tomatillo sauce or red sofrito sauce and melted monterey jack cheese; served with lettuce, fresh salsa cruda, guacamole and sour cream on the side       8.95
Roasted Vegetable Enchilada       10.95
Beef Picadillo Enchilada       10.95
Chicken Enchilada grilled or pulled       10.95
Shredded Beef Enchilada       10.95

fish

Baked Fish Fajita Burrito tortilla crusted baked tilapia wrapped in a flour tortilla with lettuce tomatillo salsa cruda, tangy green sauce, and served with rice, beans, jalapenos and chipotle tartar sauce on the side       11.95
Baked Fish Taco Plate (2 tacos) tortilla crusted baked tilapia with tomatillo salsa cruda, served with rice & beans or house salad and chipotle tartar sauce on the side       9.25

lo-carb

Lo-carb Burrito Platter special low carb whole wheat tortilla (5 net carbs) stuffed with char-grilled chicken breast, guacamole and monterey jack cheese, served with house salad       10.95
Lo-carbsadilla low carb (5 net carbs) whole wheat tortilla lightly grilled and folded over melted jack cheese, salsa cruda, guacamole and char-grilled chicken breast, served with house salad       10.95

amazing lunch deals

1Chicken Burrito (grilled or pulled) served with chips & soda       8.75
2Good Burrito served with chips & soda       7.75
3Double Shell Taco Plate chicken (grilled or pulled) or beef, served with rice & beans, chips & soda       8.50
4Mini-burrito & Salad chicken (grilled or pulled), beef or vegetable served with chips & soda       8.75
5Mexican Chicken Wrap served with chips & soda       8.75
6Mini-quesadilla Grande served with chips & soda       8.75

sides

Chips       1
Salsa Cruda       1.75
Salsa Bambino       1.75
Guacamole       4
Sour Cream       1.25
Small Sour Cream       0.50
Tofu Sour Cream       1.25
Small Tofu Sour Cream       0.50
Creamy Black Beans       2.50
Spanish Rice       2.50
Brown Rice       2.50
Green Sauce       1.25
Sofrito Sauce       1.25
Bbq Sauce       1.25
Jalapenos       1.25
Flour Tortilla       0.50
Whole Wheat Tortilla       0.50
Flavored Tortilla       0.75
2 Corn Tortillas       0.75
Roasted Vegetables       2.50

catering menu

platters
Serves 10 People
Burrito Bonanza a great assortment of our famous burritos       20 pieces 75
With chips, 2 salsas, Guacamole and Sour Cream       105
Superlative Sandwich Wraps a beautiful tray of assorted sandwich wraps       20 pieces 75
With chips, 2 salsas, Guacamole and Sour Cream       105
Cool Combo mix & match superlative wraps and famous burritos       75
With chips, 2 salsas, Guacamole and Sour Cream       105
Make Your Own Taco Party includes 20 crisp taco shells, grilled chicken and ground beef picadillo, monterey jack cheese, spanish rice, creamy black beans, shredded lettuce, fresh salsa cruda and sour cream       85
With guacamole, chips, Extra Salsa and Sour Cream       115
Chicken Fingers tender strips of chicken breast, breaded and fried golden brown, served with our chili-molasses bbq sauce       55
With chips, 2 salsas, Guacamole and Sour Cream       85
Wings, wings, wings (requires 24 hours notice) mix and match hot buffalo. jamaican jerk, tangy bbq; all with blue cheese dressing       55
With chips, 2 salsas, Guacamole and Sour Cream       85
sides
Fresh Corn Tortilla Chips       14.95
Slow-cooked Salsa fresh chips       23.95
Spanish Rice       25
Roasted Vegetable Medley zucchini, yellow squash, mushrooms, peppers, corn, onion, carrots       34.95
Salsa Cruda fresh chips       24.95
Guacamole fresh chips       32.95
Creamy Black Beans       25
House Salad mixed fresh field greens and chopped tomato with our own mustard vinaigrette dressing       34.95
Box of Cookies 36 assorted: chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin & key lime       10

homemade desserts

Homemade Flan       2
Chocolate Kahlua Flan       2
12 Little Cookies in a Bag assorted: chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin & key lime       3.50

beverages

Stewarts Root Beer       1.75
Tazo Iced Tea giant peach, plum delicious, lemon ginger, organic iced tea (low calorie), organic iced green tea (low calorie)       1.95
Bottled Water       1.50
Canned Sodas       1.25
Advertising