New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Brother Jimmy's BBQ Menu

  • Takeout Available | Delivery Available
  • Delivery Hours:
    Daily, noon-11pm
  • Delivery Area:
    70th St. to 85th St., East End Ave. to Madison Ave.

dinner

beginnings
Hush Puppies w/ maple butter       7.25
Fried Green Tomatoes w/ spicy aioli       8.25
Frickles w/ horseradish sauce       7.95
Peel & Eat Shrimp w/ lemon & old bay       12.50
Popcorn Shrimp w/ cajun mayo       9.75
Onion Straws       7.50
Spinach and Artichoke Dip       10.25
Brother Jimmy’s Bbq Humongous Nachos chips, bbq beans, chili, cheese, sour cream, salsa & guacamole       12.50
Fried Buffalo Chicken ‘minis’ topped w/ blue cheese & lettuce on a slider roll       (3 per order) 10.50
Rib Tips northern style       9.50
Bucket o’ Tips       17.50
Hot Wings buffalo, chipotle or crispy naked       9.95
Bucket o’ Hot Wings       17.50
Bbq Wings cut wings dusted w/ our southern rub & basted w/ our "special" wing sauce       9.95
Chicken Fingers original, buffalo or chipotle       9.25
Jalapeño Poppers homemade & stuffed w/ a mixture of cream cheese & spices served w/ ranch dressing       9.25
Quesadilla w/ salsa & sour cream pulled pork, bbq grilled chicken or smoked brisket       9.50
salads & stews
House Salad       6.95
With Chicken Any Style       add 3
With Pulled Pork       add 4
Chopped Cobb Salad lettuce, onion, tomato, bacon, crumbled blue cheese, avocado & grilled, fried or buffalo chicken       12.25
Jimmy’s Wedge iceberg lettuce, bacon bits, diced tomato, smothered in blue cheese dressing & covered w/ onion straws       9.50
The Wright Salad romaine, wild rice, yams, pecans, sweet onions, dried cherries, apples, poblano peppers & herb vinaigrette       10.95
With Grilled Chicken       add 3
Brunswick Stew a tomato based southern stew w/ corn, smoked chicken & pork       5.75
Brother Jimmy’s Bbq Chili topped w/ melted cheddar, served w/ sour cream & onion       6.25
sandwiches n’ burgers
W/ One Side and Pickles
Po’ Boys blackened or fried catfish, blackened chicken or fried shrimp on french bread w/ lettuce, tomato & cajun mayo       10.75
Bbq Grilled Chicken basted with bbq sauce on a roll w/ lettuce, tomato & onion       9.95
Press’d Bourbon Bbq Brisket with bourbon bbq sauce, gouda & onion straws pressed on texas toast       10.75
Fried Chicken buffalo style or original on a roll       10.25
Burgers       9.75
With chili, Applewood Bacon or Cheese       add 1
Bj’s Bbq Burger grilled w/ chipotle bbq sauce, cheddar & topped w/ onion straws       10.75
southern specialties
W/ Two Sides and Pickles
Country Fried Steak w/ Gravy top round steak, tenderized & dredged in our seasoned flour, fried ‘til crisp & tender and topped w/ gravy       17.25
Fried Chicken Dinner tossed in our seasoned flour then finished off w/ toasted garlic       16.50
Choose Any Four Sides       14.50
Blackened Chicken dipped in our special blackening spice nice & spicy       15.50
Blackened Catfish a southern seafood staple with a kick to it       12.95
Nag’s Head Veggie beer battered yams, grilled zucchini & squash, onion rings & wild rice salad no sides included       12.95
bbq
All of Our Bbq Is Smoked Over Hickory Wood For 5-12 Hours Served w/ Two Sides Cornbread and pickles. a Half Rack of st. Louis Style Ribs
Northern Style Ribs smoked & then grilled w/ brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce       20.75
Southern Style Ribs smoked w/ brother jimmy’s memphisstyle rub       20.75
Brother Jimmy’s Dry Rub Ribs smoked w/ brother jimmy’s signa ture rubtastes like a country sausage       20.75
Combo Rib Platter choose from our 3 styles of ribs, ‘lil’ more than a half rack       21.75
Carolina Pulled Pork pork shoulder slow smoked & pulled w/ brother jimmy’s carolina bbq       16.95
Pulled Chicken smoked & pulled w/ brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce       15.95
Sliced Brisket smoked for up to 12 hours lean or moist       17.95
1/2 Bbq Chicken smoked, grilled & basted in brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce       16.50
Bbq Chicken & Ribs       19.50
Bbq Meatloaf beef & pork wrapped in bacon & smoked       15.95
sandwiches
W/ One Side and Pickles,slaw $0.50 Extra
Carolina Pulled Pork       10.50
Pulled Chicken       10.50
Sliced Brisket lean or moist       10.75
Bbq Meatloaf on grilled texas toast w/ tomato       10.25
jimmy’s pig pick $23.95
Choose Any 4 Items From the Following Selections
Northern      
Southern or Dry Rub Ribs      
Pulled Pork      
Brisket      
Bbq Chicken or Pulled Chicken served with hush puppies and coleslaw      
sides
Potato Salad       4
Cole Slaw       4
French Fries       4
Fried Okra       4
Sweet Potato Fries       4.50
Spiced String Beans       4.50
Black Eyed Peas w/bacon       4.50
Mashed Potatoes w/ gravy       4.50
Collard Greens       4.50
Corn on the Cob 2 ears       4.50
Macaroni & Cheese       5.25
Bbq Baked Beans w/ pulled pork       5.25
Candied Yams w/ walnuts       5.25
Fried Brussel Sprouts       5.25
Wild Rice Salad       5.25

drinks

concoctions
Served in a Jumbo (16 oz) Mason Jar or in a Pitcher
Plantation Punch a carolina rum runner containing sailor jerry’s spiced rum and coconut rum     8   28
Carolina Cooler brother jimmy’s classic cocktail made with vodka, lemonade and blue curacao     8   28
Drunken Sailor sailor jerry‘s spiced rum, cheerwine, sprite and cherry garnish     9   31
Louisville Lemonade a whiskey infused glass of lemonade made with maker’s mark bourbon, triple sec and sprite     8   28
Charlotte Tea a southern version of a long island iced tea made with five kinds of booze and a hint of the tropics     10   34
The Charleston A.p south carolina sweet tea infused vodka, fresh lemonade and a splash of soda     8   28
Myrtle Beach Margarita a jumbo margarita either frozen or on the rocks add a flavor: strawberry, raspberry, peach or mango     8   28
The Grand Strand Margarita a top shelf margarita made with milagro silver tequila, grand marnier and lime     12   40
The Battle of Antietam Bloody Mary a classic spicy bloody with a festive array of garnishes and a taste of the old bay       9
Jimmy’s ole’ Fashioned our twist on the classic; jim beam, grand marnier and muddled fruit       9
party drinks
Swamp Water our legendary cocktail served in a 64 oz fish bowl. hasn’t changed in 20 years       19
Trashcan Punch 2.5 gallons of high octane punch served in a mason jar a perfect drink for a party       90
Aunt jess’ Award Winning Sangria Pitcher a refreshing way to get your daily allowance of fruit. your choice of red or white wine       28
bottled beer
Abita amber       7
Turbo Dog       7
Flying Dog snake dog ipa       7
Magic Hat #9       7
Saranac black and tan       7
Sierra Nevada pale ale       7
Amstel Light       6
Blue Moon       6
Corona       6
Hard Core Cider       6
Heineken       6
Heineken Light       6
Bud       5
Bud Light       5
Miller High Life       5
Miller Lite       5
O’douls       5
draft beer
Pitcher
Brooklyn Penant     6   20
Ale     6   20
Sam Adams     6   20
Sam Seasonal     6   20
Shock Top belgium white     6   20
Stella     6   20
Yuengling     6   20
Bud     5   16
Bud Light     5   16
cans $3.75
(16Oz)
Natural Light      
Pbr      
soda pop
Boylans Soda grape, orange, ginger ale, root beer, diet root beer, black cherry       3
Coke       3
Diet Coke       3
Sprite       3
Fiji Water       3
Cheerwine Cherry Soda a carolina favorite since 1917       3
Cheerwine Icecream Float       5
top shelf
Johnny Walker Blue       45
Johnny Walker Gold       25
Hennessey Xo       35
Patron Platinum       40
Jose Cuervo Reserve de la Familia       20
Milagro Select Barrel Anejo       18

wine by the glass

white
Penfolds Chardonnay       7.50
Beringer Pinot Grigio       7
Beringer Sauvignon Blanc       7
red
Beringer Pinot Noir       7.50
Beringer Cabernet Sauvignon       7
Penfolds Shiraz       7
Advertising