New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Café Fiorello

Café Fiorello Menu

  • Takeout Available | Delivery Available
  • Delivery Hours:
    Daily, noon-11pm
  • Delivery Area:
    59th St. to 72nd St., Central Park West to West End Ave.

lunch

Bottled Triple Purified Water Still or Lightly Carbonated (all You Can drink) $3.50 Pp

soups
21-Vegetable Minestrone       11
Stracciatella Chicken Soup poached egg       11
Pasta E Fagioli (the perfect protein) oil-free, whole wheat pasta, vegan       11
Garlic Bread       4
salads
Caesar       12
Baby Arugula & Caramelized Pear goat cheese fritter, black currant vinaigrette       14
Burrata Mozzarella Caprese house made burrata, beefsteak tomatoes, arugula       15
Avocado & Mozzarella Caprese house made burrata mozzarella, beefsteak tomatoes       16
antipasto bar
Chef Raffaele Prepares Additional Antipasti everyday. Please Feel Free to Visit Our Antipasto Bar
3 Vegetables       15
2 Vegetables with shrimp & scallops       17
6 Vegetables       26
4 Vegetables With 2 Seafood shrimp & scallops and seafood antipasto of the day       28
antipasto bar - vegetable antipasti
Bowl of Assorted olives*       6
Cauliflower Steak amandine*       9
Zucchini parmigiana*       9
Stuffed Artichokes oreganata*       12
Scalloped Potato gratin*       9
Beefsteak Tomatoes       6
Sicilian Eggplant Caponata       10
Roasted Red & Yellow Peppers       8
Caramelized Fennel butter bean honey       6
Whole Wheat Artichoke Couscous       9
Broccoli Rabe & Golden Raisins       11
Grilled Asparagus Spears       10
Roasted Red Beets       6
Cipollini Onions balsamic glaze       7
antipasto bar - seafood
Shrimp & Scallops       15
Grilled Seppie Calamari       12
Shrimp & Corona Beans       12
antipasto bar - mozzarella
House Made Burrata cream-filled mozzarella       12
With Prosciutto di parma, Add       8
With Any Vegetable antipasti, Add       6
antipasto bar - meats & prosciutto
House Made Fennel Sausage & peppers*       12
Bowl of meatballs*       12
Prosciutto di Parma       15
snacks & burger
Fried Artichokes Alla Giudea       16
Fried Shrimp & Calamari       14
Fravioli Grandi two large fried ravioli, stracchino cheese, burrata mozzarella, prosciutto di parma, soppressata       15
Caprino Goat Cheese Bruschetta Toast pesto beefsteak tomatoes, fresh-cut french fries       12
Jumbo Crabmeat Bruschetta Toast stracchino cheese, fresh-cut french fries       16
Caprese Hamburger burrata mozzarella, tomato, fresh-cut french fries       18
lunch
Served Weekdays Until 4pm
Caprese Hamburger burrata, tomato, roasted parmesan potatoes       18
entrée salads
Chef’s Chicken Salad prosciutto, burrata, asparagus       19
Organic "freedom food" Salmon Caprese Salad scotland. burrata, market greens       23
Seared Diver Scallop Caesar Salad newport, ri       24
Filet Mignon Caesar       23
Maine Lobster Caesar       (1lb) 28
pasta & risotto
Bucatini With Sausage Amatriciana pomodoro, house made fennel sausage       19
Fettuccine Carbonara whole fried egg, pancetta, pecorino cheese       21
Tagliatelle Bolognese hand made ribbon pasta, three meat ragú       21
Specialitá! café Fiorello’s Lasagna       27
Tagliolini al Forno homemade spinach pasta, lightly baked with parma ham & parmesan béchamel sauce       24
Whole Wheat Orecchiette al Pesto basil pine nut & hazelnut sauce       22
Pappardelle With Eggplant Parmesan       20
Spaghetti & Clams white or red sauce       25
Mediterranean Branzino Filet with seafood ta tagliatelle       29
Seafood Risotto scallops, shrimp, manila clams, mussels, calamari       29
local fish & seafood
All Fish Is Available Simply Grilled
Local Sea Trout Milanese (scarce, long island, ny) arugula, fennel       24
Clay Pot Porgy Livornese (long island, ny) tomatoes, black olives, capers       26
Crispy Fluke Mugnaia (montauk, ny) brown butter, lemon, parsley       25
Wild Striped Bas Salmoriglio (montauk, ny) black olives, shallots, red & yellow peppers       27
Seared Diver Scallops (newport, ri) roasted sliced herb potatoes       29
Atlantic Yellowfin Tuna Steak (bar harbor, me) balsamic glaze, lentil salad       27
Shrimp Scampi (louisiana) corona beans, pancetta, baby arugula       23
Jumbo Lump Crab Steak (maryland) fresh-cut french fries       35
Lobster and Seafood Fra Diavolo (buck’s harbor, me) lobster, clams, mussels, shrimp, linguine, tomato sauce       36
Imported Fish - Salmon Steak by "freedom food" (sutherland, scotland) braised zucchini, leeks       27
veal, steak & poultry
Veal Scaloppine Marsala hen of the woods mushrooms, parmesan potatoes       24
Veal Scaloppine Saltimbocca prosciutto di parma, sage       25
Vegetarian Veal Scaloppine Piccata artichokes, capers (seitan: wheat gluten)       24
Specialitá! Veal Chop Parmigiana       48
Calves Liver Steak Veneziana caramelized onions, aged balsamic       26
Filet Mignon hen of the woods mushrooms, brunello sauce, creamy polenta     (8oz) 38   (12oz) 45
Mama Perla’s Organic Lemon Chicken pan fried zucchini, lemon gremolata       25
our signature thin crust pizza
Margherita burrata mozzarella, tomatoes, basil     19   28
A Lot of Pepperoni & Baby Arugula     22   30
Meatball Pizza     22   30
House Made Fennel Sausage & Roasted Peppers     23   32
Parma Prosciutto & Baby Arugula aged balsamic vinegar     23   32
Supreme Pizza burrata mozzarella, prosciutto di parma, pepperoni, house made fennel sausage, pancetta, seasonal mushrooms, roasted peppers, black olives       34
Seafood Supreme Pizza scallops, manila clams, mussels, shrimp, calamari, burrata mozzarella, artichokes       34
vegan pizza
$24 / $34. Soy Mozzarella Cheese & Whole Wheat Flour
Virgin Margherita tomatoes, basil      
Mediterranean Grilled Vegetable Pizza sicilian oregano, capers      
dessert
Tiramisu lady fingers dipped in espresso, mascarpone cream & cocoa       11
Strawberry Blonde Cheesecake ny-style cheesecake with strawberries, whipped cream & warm chocolate sauce       12.50
Profiteroles puff-pastry shells with vanilla gelato & warm chocolate sauce       12
Limoncello Tart lemon curd with brulee top, graham cracker crust & whipped cream       11
Chocolate Mousse (to share) twin buckets of chocolate mousse & fresh whipped cream       15
Cannoli Sicilian almond tuille shell filled with ricotta cheese, chocolate chips & blueberry sauce       12
Tartufo hand made chocolate & vanilla gelato rolled in chocolate chips       12
Gelato vanilla, pistachio, chocolate       8
Sorbetto lemon, chocolate, raspberry       8

prix fixe lunch - three course lunch mon-fri $25

dinner

Bottled Triple Purified Water Still or Lightly Carbonated (all You Can drink) $3.50 Pp

soups $12
21-Vegetable Minestrone (vg)      
Stracciatella Chicken Soup poached egg      
Oil-free, Whole Wheat Pasta E Fagioli (vg) the perfect protein      
salads
Caesar       12
Baby Arugula & Caramelized Pear goat cheese fritter, black currant vinaigrette       14
Caprese tomatoes, avocado, arugula       16
antipasto bar
Vegetables Change daily. Your Server Will Choose For You or Pick Your Own At the Antipasto Bar
3 Vegetables       16
2 Vegetables with 1 seafood       18
6 Vegetables       25
4 Vegetables with 2 seafood       28
antipasto bar - vegetable antipasti
Served Warm
Assorted Olives       6
Cauliflower Steak       9
Zucchini Parmigiana       9
Stuffed Artichokes       12
Whole Wheat Couscous       9
Black Trumpet Mushrooms       10
antipasto bar - seafood
Shrimp & Scallop Salad       15
Grilled Seppie Calamari       12
Shrimp & Corona Beans       12
Mussels in Lobster broth*       (per lb) 19
antipasto bar - mozzarella
Burrata Mozzarella       12
With Prosciutto Add       8
With Any Vegetable Antipasti Add       6
antipasto bar - meats & prosciutto
House Made Fennel Sausage & peppers*       12
Bowl of meatballs*       12
Prosciutto Plate       15
specialty appetizers
Fried Artichokes Alla Giudea       16
Fried Shrimp & Calamari       15
Fravioli Grandi two large fried ravioli, stracchino cheese, burrata mozzarella, prosciutto di parma, soppressata       15
Caprino Goat Cheese Bruschetta pesto beefsteak tomatoes       12
pasta & risotto
Specialitá! café Fiorello’s Lasagna       27
Fettuccine Carbonara fried egg, pancetta, pecorino cheese       24
Bucatini Sausage Amatriciana pomodoro, pecorino cheese       22
Tagliatelle Bolognese hand made ribbon pasta, three meat ragú       24
Tagliolini al Forno homemade spinach pasta, prosciutto & parmesan bechamel sauce       24
Whole Wheat Orecchiette al Pesto basil pine nut & hazelnut sauce       24
Pappardelle with eggplant parmesan       24
Spaghetti & Clams white or red sauce       25
Whole Porgy with seafood tagliatelle       32
Lobster Seafood Risotto scallops, shrimp, manilla clams, mussels       32
local fish & seafood
Sourced From Waters Spanning Maryland to Maine
Whole Sea Trout (l.i., ny) grilled, olive oil & lemon, zucchini       28
Porgy Livornese (l.i., ny) firm texture; mild flavor, tomatoes, black olives       30
Whole Porgy with seafood tagliatelle       32
Fluke (montauk, ny) grilled, delicate flavor & texture, arugula       35
Seared Diver Scallops (rhode island) baby artichokes       30
Jumbo Lump Crab Steak (maryland) roasted parmesan potatoes       36
Shrimp Scampi (louisiana) corona beans, pancetta, arugula       29
Yellowfin Tuna (cape cod) balsamic glaze, lentil salad       34
Lobster Seafood Risotto (arborio rice) scallops, shrimp, manila clams, mussels       32
Lobster Fra Diavolo (maine) lobster, clams, mussels, shrimp, linguine, tomato sauce       36
imported fish
Italy, Holland & Greece
Dover Sole (holland) pan-seared, olive oil & lemon, zucchini       (per lb) 55
Whole San Pietro (italy) sweet & mild; firm-textured, olive oil & lemon, zucchini       (per lb) 39
Whole Branzino (mediterranean sea bass) grilled, olive oil & lemon, zucchini       (1 1/4lb) 36
Organic Salmon Steak by "freedom food" (scotland) grilled, baby arugula       32
veal & poultry
Veal Chop Milanese arugula, fennel       48
Specialita Veal Chop Parmigiana       48
Grilled Veal Chop roasted parmesan potatoes, sage       48
Veal Scaloppine Marsala black trumpet mushrooms, roasted parmesan potatoes       29
Veal Scaloppine Piccata artichokes, roasted parmesan potatoes       29
Vegetarian Veal Parmigiana seitan       26
Calves Liver Alla Veneziana caramelized onions, roasted parmesan potatoes       26
Duck Steak parmesan potatoes       34
Lamb Shank Ossobuco braised & served with pappardelle pasta       32
Lemon Chicken (organic) pan-fried zucchini       28
Chicken Cacciatora       27
Chicken Pepperoni Parmigiana       28
usda prime steaks
Dry-aged 28 days. Served With Roasted Parmesan Potatoes
Filet Mignon     (8oz) 42   (12oz) 48
Prime New York Strip Steak saffron risotto cake, brunello sauce       (14oz) 47
Prime Bone-in Rib-eye Fiorentina arugula       (22oz) 58
our signature thin crust pizza
All of Our Pizzas Are Baked With House Made Burrata Mozzarella
Margherita       21
A Lot of Pepperoni & Baby Arugula       23
Meatball Pizza       23
House Made Fennel Sausage & Roasted Peppers       23
Prosciutto & Arugula aged balsamic vinegar       24
Supreme Pizza prosciutto, pepperoni, house made fennel sausage, pancetta, black trumpet mushrooms, peppers, olives, burrata       26
Seafood Supreme scallops, clams, mussels, shrimp, calamari, artichokes, burrata       28
vegan pizza $24
Soy Mozzarella & Whole Wheat Flour
Virgin Margherita      
Mediterranean Five Vegetable Pizza sicilian oregano, capers      
beverages $4.95
Coke      
Diet Coke      
Ginger Ale      
Sprite      
Iced Tea      
Orange Juice      
Grapefruit Juice      
Cranberry Juice      

supper

Starts At 8pm. Bottled Triple Purified Water Still or Lightly Carbonated (all You Can drink) $3.50 Pp

soups
21-Vegetable Minestrone       11
Stracciatella Chicken Soup poached egg       11
Oil-free Pasta E Fagioli (the perfect protein) whole wheat pasta, vegan       11
Garlic Bread       4
salads
Café Fiorello Caesar       12
Baby Arugula & Caramelized Pear goat cheese fritter, black currant vinaigrette       14
Burrata Mozzarella Caprese house made burrata, beefsteak tomatoes, arugula       15
Avocado & Mozzarella Caprese house made burrata mozzarella, beefsteak tomatoes       16
antipasto bar
Chef Raffaele Prepares Additional Antipasti everyday. Please Feel Free to Visit Our Antipasto Bar
3 Vegetables       15
2 Vegetables with shrimp & scallops       17
6 Vegetables       26
4 Vegetables With 2 Seafood shrimp & scallops and seafood antipasto of the day       28
antipasto bar - vegetable antipasti
Bowl of Assorted olives*       6
Cauliflower Steak amandine*       9
Zucchini parmigiana*       9
Stuffed Artichokes oreganata*       12
Scalloped Potato gratin*       9
Beefsteak Tomatoes       6
Sicilian Eggplant Caponata       10
Roasted Red & Yellow Peppers       8
Caramelized Fennel butter bean honey       6
Whole Wheat Artichoke Couscous       9
Broccoli Rabe & Golden Raisins       11
Grilled Asparagus Spears       10
Roasted Red Beets       6
Cipollini Onions balsamic glaze       7
antipasto bar - seafood
Shrimp & Scallops       15
Grilled Seppie Calamari       12
Shrimp & Corona Beans       12
antipasto bar - mozzarella
House Made Burrata cream-filled mozzarella       12
With Prosciutto di parma, Add       8
With Any Vegetable antipasti, Add       6
antipasto bar - meats & prosciutto
House Made Fennel Sausage & peppers*       12
Bowl of meatballs*       12
Prosciutto di Parma       15
snacks, burger & entrée salads
Fried Artichokes Alla Giudea       16
Fried Shrimp & Calamari       14
Fravioli Grandi two large fried ravioli, stracchino cheese, burrata mozzarella, prosciutto di parma, soppressata       15
Caprese Hamburger burrata mozzarella, tomato, fresh-cut french fries       18
Caprino Goat Cheese Bruschetta Toast caprino goat cheese bruschetta toast       12
Jumbo Crabmeat Bruschetta Toast stracchino cheese       16
Niçoise Salad with yellowfin tuna or grilled shrimp       22
Seared Diver Scallop Caesar       24
pasta & risotto
Specialitá! café Fiorello’s Lasagna       27
Fettuccine Carbonara whole fried egg, pancetta, pecorino cheese       24
Bucatini With Sausage Amatriciana pomodoro, house made fennel sausage       22
Tagliatelle Bolognese hand made ribbon pasta, three meat ragú       24
Tagliolini al Forno homemade spinach pasta, lightly baked with parma ham & parmesan béchamel sauce       24
Whole Wheat Orecchiette al Pesto basil pine nut & hazelnut sauce       24
Pappardelle with eggplant parmesan       24
Spaghetti & Clams white or red sauce       25
Mediterranean Branzino Filet with seafood tagliatelle       29
Seafood Risotto scallops, shrimp, manila clams, mussels, calamari       29
local fish & seafood
All Fish Is Available Simply Grilled
Local Sea Trout Milanese (scarce, long island, ny) arugula, fennel       26
Claypot Porgy Livornese (long island, ny) tomatoes, black olives, capers       29
Crispy Fluke Mugnaia (montauk, ny) brown butter, lemon, parsley       29
Wild Striped Bass Salmoriglio (montauk, ny ) black olives, shallots, red & yellow peppers       32
Seared Diver Scallops (newport, ri ) roasted sliced herb potatoes       34
Atlantic Yellowfin Tuna Steak (bar harbor, me ) balsamic glaze, lentil salad       30
Shrimp Scampi (louisiana) corona beans, pancetta, baby arugula       29
Jumbo Lump Crab Steak (maryland) fresh-cut french fries       35
Lobster and Seafood Fra Diavolo (buck’s harbor, me) lobster, clams, mussels, shrimp, linguine, tomato sauce       36
imported fish
Dover Sole (holland) 1lb, asparagus spears, lemon-caper brown butter sauce (served on the side)       55
Branzino mediterranean sea, (sea bass) pine nut & black currant sauce       32
Salmon Steak by "freedom food" (sutherland, scotland) braised zucchini, leeks       30
veal & poultry
Veal Scaloppine Marsala hen of the woods mushrooms, parmesan potatoes       29
Veal Scaloppine Saltimbocca prosciutto di parma, sage       30
Vegetarian Veal Scaloppine Piccata artichokes, capers (seitan: wheat gluten)       24
Veal Chop Milanese arugula, fennel       48
Specialitá! Veal Chop Parmigiana       48
Grilled Veal Chop sage sauce, fresh-cut french fries       48
Calves Liver Steak Veneziana caramelized onions, aged balsamic       26
Mama Perla’s Organic Lemon Chicken pan fried zucchini, lemon gremolata       28
usda prime steaks
Dry-aged 28 Days
Filet Mignon hen of the woods mushrooms, brunello sauce, creamy polenta     (8oz) 38   (12oz) 45
Prime New York Strip saffron risotto cake, brunello sauce       (14oz) 47
Prime Bone-in Rib-eye Fiorentina 12-year balsamic, grilled onion, baby arugula, roasted garlic       (22oz) 58
our signature thin crust pizza
Margherita burrata mozzarella, tomatoes, basil     19   28
A Lot of Pepperoni & Baby Arugula     22   30
Meatball Pizza     22   30
House Made Fennel Sausage & Roasted Peppers     23   32
Parma Prosciutto & Baby Arugula aged balsamic vinegar     23   32
Supreme Pizza burrata mozzarella, prosciutto di parma, pepperoni, house made fennel sausage, pancetta, seasonal mushrooms, roasted peppers, black olives       34
Seafood Supreme Pizza scallops, manila clams, mussels, shrimp, calamari, burrata mozzarella, artichokes       34
vegan pizza
$24 / $34. Soy Mozzarella Cheese & Whole Wheat Flour
Virgin Margherita tomatoes, basil      
Mediterranean Grilled Vegetable Pizza sicilian oregano, capers      
Advertising