New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Cheyenne Diner

Cheyenne Diner Menu

  • Takeout Available | Delivery Available
  • Delivery Hours:
    Daily, 24 hours
  • Delivery Area:
    23rd St. to 50th St., Fifth Ave. to Twelfth Ave.

eggs

Served With Potatoes & Toast

Two Eggs any style       3.75
With Bacon or Ham or Sausage       5.25
With Sausage Patties       5.25
With Turkey Bacon       5.95
With Beef Sausage       5.95
With Corned Beef Hash       6.75
With Canadian Bacon       5.95
Virginia Ham Steak & Eggs       10.95
Eggs Florentine       9.95

3 egg omelets

Served With Potatoes & Toast

Western Omelet       5.75
Broccoli Omelet       5.25
Spanish Omelet       5.75
Mushroom Omelet       5.50
Onion Omelet       4.50
Spinach Omelet       5.25
Cheese Omelet       5.50
Muenster, Swiss or Cheddar       5.95
Feta Cheese Omelet       5.95
Ham or Bacon Omelet       5.25
Ham or Bacon & Cheese Omelet       6.50
Salami Omelet       5.50
Broccoli & Cheese Omelet       6.50
Greek Omelet feta & tomato       6.95
Spinach & Feta Cheese Omelet       6.95
Mushroom & Cheese Omelet       6.75
Western & Cheese Omelet       6.95
Avocado, Turkey & Swiss Omelet       8.25
California Omelet mushroom, avocado & cheddar cheese       8.25
Chef's Omelet avocado, spinach & swiss cheese       8.25
Turkey, Mushroom & Cheddar       8.25
Vegetarian Omelet mushroom, onions, tomato & peppers       6.95
Vegetarian Omelet with cheese       7.95
L.e.o. Omelet lox, eggs, onions       8.95
Pizza Omelet       8.50
Steak & Eggs served with potatoes & toast       11.95
Eggs Benedict with canadian bacon on english muffin & hollandaise sauce       9.95

we offer egg whites for an additional $1, english muffin, bagel, roll or bialy add $0.50, any additional item on omelets $1.25, we also offer grits with our eggs & omelet platters instead of potatoes

cereal

Cold Cereal       2.95
Grits       2.95
Hot Oatmeal       2.95
With Brown Sugar & Raisins       3.75

muffins, breads & bagels

English Muffins       1
Assorted Muffins corn, bran, blueberry, or banana       1.75
Roll or Toast       1
Bagel or Bialy       1
Toasted Bagel with cream cheese       1.75
Toasted Bagel with cream cheese & nova scotia lox       7.95
Bagel, Nova Scotia Lox & Cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, Onion & Garnish       9.95

griddle specialties

Served With Butter & Syrup

Pancakes Golden Brown       4.25
With Two Eggs       5.25
With Bacon or Ham or Sausage       5.95
With Corned Beef Hash       6.25
With Canadian Bacon       6.25
French Toast Golden Brown       4.25
With Two Eggs       5.25
With Bacon or Ham or Sausage       5.95
With Corned Beef Hash       6.25
With Canadian Bacon       6.25
Lumberjack pancakes or french toast with ham or bacon or sausage & two eggs       7.50
Waffles       4.25
With Bacon or Ham or Sausage       5.95
With Fruit       5.95
With Ice Cream & Whipped Cream       6.25
Cheyenne Special pancakes with fruit - apple cinnamon, blueberry or strawberry with butter & syrup       6.95

sides

Bacon or Ham or Sausage       2.95
Beef Sausage       3.50
Turkey Bacon       3.50
Corned Beef Hash       3.75
Home Fries       2.95
Sausage Patties       2.95

lo-cal delights

Lo-cal Burger (8oz.) served on a tossed salad       8.95
Grilled Marinated Chicken Breast Diet with hot vegetables       9.50
Stuffed Tomato stuffed with tuna or chicken salad on lettuce with cucumbers & garnish       7.50
Stuffed Avocado stuffed with tuna or chicken salad on lettuce with tomato & garnish       7.95
California Cobb chicken strips, avocado, lettuce, tomato & cheese with hard boiled egg       8.75
Stuffed Avocado with shrimp salad on lettuce & tomato       8.50
Turkey & Avocado with tomato and mushrooms       8.50
Tuna Salad Diet on a bed of lettuce with tomato, cole slaw & garnish       7.25
Chicken Salad Diet on a bed of lettuce with tomato, cole slaw & garnish       7.25
Shrimp Salad Diet on a bed of lettuce with tomato, cole slaw & garnish       8.25
Tuna or Sardine Diet (individual) on a bed of lettuce with tomato, cole slaw & garnish       8.25
Salmon Diet (individual) on a bed of lettuce with tomato, cole slaw & garnish       8.25

specialties

Tuna Melt Deluxe served with french fries, cole slaw & pickle       7.95
Chicken Fingers served with french fries, salad & honey mustard sauce       8.50
Reuben Sandwich corned beef or pastrami, melted swiss cheese & sauerkraut with french fries       8.95
Fish & Chips       8.95
Mozzarella Sticks       5.95
Monte Cristo       8.95
Homemade Chili Bowl with onions & cheese       5.25
Platter with rice & salad       7.50
Individual Quiche Pie broccoli or lorraine       8.95
Cheyenne Steak Sandwich Deluxe on garlic bread with lettuce, tomato & french fries       9.50
Grilled Chicken Breast on a bun with lettuce & tomato       5.50
Deluxe       7.50
London Broil Sandwich       7.50
Pattie Melt on rye bread w/ cheese & sauteed onions, with french fries       7.50

tasty sandwiches

Served With pickle, Cole Slaw & Mayonnaise If Requested

meat
Fresh Roast Turkey       6.25
Roast Beef       6.25
Corned Beef       6.25
Pastrami       6.25
Salami       4.50
Boiled Ham       4.50
Salami or Ham & Cheese       5.50
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato       4.25
Meatloaf       4.95
London Broil       7.50
salad
Tunafish Salad       4.50
Chicken Salad       4.50
Egg Salad       4.25
Shrimp Salad       5.95
Egg Salad with bacon       5.50
Tuna Melt       5.95
egg
One Fried Egg       1.75
Two Fried Eggs       2.25
Bacon or Ham or Sausage & Egg       3.25
Fried Egg & Cheese       2.75
Bacon Egg & Cheese       3.75
Western Egg       4.75
fish
Fried Filet of Sole       5.75
Tuna individual       5.25
Salmon individual       5.25
Sardines individual       5.25
cheese
American Cheese Sandwich       3.75
Swiss, Muenster or Cheddar       3.95
Grilled American Cheese       3.75
With Bacon or Ham       4.50
With Tomato       4.25
With Bacon or Ham & Tomato       5.50
With Swiss or Muenster or Cheddar       add 0.50
chicken
Chicken Cutlet Hero       5.50
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero       6.25
special sandwiches
Fried Filet Deluxe served with french fries       7.75
Grilled Cheese Deluxe served with french fries       6.45
Philly Cheese Steak Deluxe with grilled peppers, onions and melted american cheese, served with french fries       7.50
Franks & Beans served with french fries       8.75
Corned Beef or Pastrami Deluxe served with french fries       8.95

1/2 lb. beefburgers

Served With Cole Slaw & Pickle, Deluxe Burgers Served With French fries, lettuce, tomato, Cole Slaw & pickle

Beef Burger     plain 4.25   deluxe 6.25
American Cheeseburger     plain 4.50   deluxe 6.50
Pizza Burger     plain 4.95   deluxe 6.95
Cheddar Burger     plain 4.95   deluxe 6.95
Bacon Burger     plain 5.25   deluxe 7.25
Bacon Cheeseburger     plain 5.75   deluxe 7.75
Chili Burger     plain 5.75   deluxe 7.75
Turkey Burger     plain 4.25   deluxe 6.25
Veggie Burger     plain 5.75   deluxe 7.75
Cheyenne's Super Special Deluxe Burger w/ swiss cheese, bacon, fried onion, mushrooms, lettuce, french fries, cole slaw & pickle       8.75
Bison Burger     plain 5.75   deluxe 7.75

onion rings, spicy curly fries or sweet potato fries instead of french fries add $1.75

cheyenne's famous triple deckers

Served With pickle, Cole Slaw & French Fries

Turkey with bacon, lettuce & tomato       8.75
Roast Beef with swiss cheese, lettuce & tomato       8.75
Tuna & Sliced Egg with lettuce & tomato       7.95
Egg Salad & Bacon with lettuce & tomato       7.95
Grilled Chicken Breast with bacon, lettuce & tomato       8.95
Chicken Salad Club with bacon, lettuce & tomato       7.95

side orders

French Fries or Home Fries       2.95
French Fries with cheese       4.25
Sweet Potato Fries       4.25
Spicy Curly Fries       4.25
Mashed or Baked Potato       3.25
Potato Salad or Cole Slaw       2.75
Onion Rings       4.25
Hot Vegetable       3.95
Cottage Cheese       2.75
Tossed Salad       3.95
Baked Beans       3.75

stuffed baked potatoes

Any Cheese with (choice of american, cheddar, swiss, mozzarella or feta cheese)       4.25
Any Vegetable with (choice of mushrooms, spinach or broccoli)       4.25
Vegetable topped with melted cheese       5.50
Bacon or Ham       4.25
Chili & Cheese       5.50
Meatball Parmigiana       5.50
Ham & Cheese       5.50

each additional item $1 / bleu cheese add $1

cold salad platters

Tossed Salad small       3.95
Tunafish or Chicken Salad Platter on a bed of lettuce with potato salad, cole slaw, tomato, cucumbers, hard boiled egg & garnish       7.50
Egg Salad Platter with potato salad, cole slaw, lettuce, tomato & garnish       6.95
Shrimp Salad Platter with potato salad, cole slaw, lettuce, tomato, hard boiled egg & garnish       8.25
Tuna or Sardines (individual) with potato salad, cole slaw, lettuce, tomato, hard boiled egg & garnish       8.25
Salmon (individual) with potato salad, cole slaw, lettuce, tomato, hard boiled egg & garnish       8.50
Greek Salad with feta cheese, anchovies, olives, stuffed grape leaves, lettuce, tomato, onions and cucumbers       7.95
With Grilled Marinated Chicken Breast       9.95
Chef's Salad w/ fresh turkey, roast beef, ham & swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, hard-boiled egg & garnish       8.50
Fresh Spinach Salad fresh spinach, mushrooms, bacon bits, hard boiled egg and croutons with our special dressing       7.50
With Grilled Marinated Chicken Breast       9.75
Caesar Salad romaine lettuce salad with caesar's special dressing       6.95
With Grilled Marinated Chicken Breast       9.25
With Sliced London Broil       10.95
With Grilled Salmon Steak       10.95
Greek Antipasto with taramosalata, feta cheese, anchovies, stuffed grape leaves, lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, olives & hard boiled egg with our house dressing       9.95

our famous burgers & specialties

1Wyoming topped with bbq sauce & bacon     plain 6   deluxe 7.75
2Indian topped with guacamole, raw onion & cheddar cheese     plain 6.75   deluxe 8.50
3Apache topped with fried onions, any cheese & mushrooms     plain 6.20   deluxe 7.95
4Cherokee fried onions, mushrooms, green peppers & any cheese     plain 6.20   deluxe 7.95
5Geronimo grilled onions, mushrooms, green peppers & any cheese     plain 6.20   deluxe 7.95
6Tonto ham, bacon, tomatoes, mushrooms, fried onions & any cheese     plain 6.50   deluxe 8.20
7Mohegan bbq sauce, bacon, fried onions & cheese     plain 6.20   deluxe 7.95
8Tomahawk lettuce, tomatoes, raw onion & mayonnaise     plain 5.20   deluxe 6.95
9Chief lettuce, tomatoes, any cheese & mayonnaise     plain 6.20   deluxe 7.95
10Sioux guacamole & raw onions     plain 6.20   deluxe 7.95
11Iroquois bacon, any cheese & fried onions     plain 6.20   deluxe 7.95
12Canarsie ham, any cheese, & fried onions     plain 6.20   deluxe 7.95
13Wrangler bacon & blue cheese     plain 6.50   deluxe 8.20
14Greek topped with feta cheese & tomatoes     plain 6   deluxe 7.75
15English served on an english muffin & virginia ham     plain 5.75   deluxe 7.50
16Mexican any cheese & jalapeno peppers     plain 5.20   deluxe 6.95
17Monterrey Jack topped with melted jack cheese     plain 5   deluxe 6.75
18Bronco canadian bacon & melted cheddar cheese     plain 6.20   deluxe 7.95
19Cheyenne Stampede 1 pound burger, bacon, fried onions, mushroom & cheese     plain 7.50   deluxe 9.20

served w/ cole slaw & pickle. deluxe served w/ french fries, lettuce, tomato, cole slaw & pickle; onion rings, spicy curly fries or sweet potato fries instead of french fries add $1.75; choice of bison, turkey burger, grilled chicken or veggie burger add $1.50

wrap combinations

1Chicken Caesar Wrap       7.20
2Greek Salad Chicken Wrap       7.20
3Turkey, Ham & Cheese Wrap       7.20
4Vegetable Wrap grilled onions, lettuce, tomatoes, mushrooms & guacamole       6.20
5Beef, Jalapeno Peppers & Cheese       7.20
6Tonto Wrap grilled chicken, cheddar cheese & canadian bacon       7.20
7Bleu Wrap grilled chicken with melted bleu cheese, lettuce and tomatoes       7.20
8Sweet & Sour Wrap with roasted turkey, swiss cheese, jalapeno peppers and honey mustard       7.20
9Cheeseburger Wrap       5.20
10Chicken Cutlet Wrap with mozzarella cheese, lettuce and tomatoes       7.20
11Pastrami & Cheese Wrap       7.20
12Tuna or Chicken Salad Wrap       5
13B.l.t. Wrap       5
14Reuben Wrap with corned beef, sauerkraut and swiss cheese       7.20
15Bbq Chicken Breast & Cheese       7.20

with french fries add $1

soups

Soup of the Day       2.95
Matzoh Ball       3.50

entrees

Served With Cup of Soup or salad, Potato & Vegetable

Roast Young Turkey with stuffing       12.95
Roast Top Sirloin of Beef Au Jus       11.95
Roast Chicken with stuffing       9.95
Virginia Ham Steak       11.95

hot open sandwiches

Served With Cup of Soup or salad, Potato & Vegetable

Hot Open Meatloaf       9.75
Hot Open Turkey       9.95
Hot Open Roast Beef       9.95

fresh seafood

Served With Cup of Soup or salad, Potato & Vegetable

Broiled Filet of Sole       12.95
Broiled Filet of Scrod       11.95
Broiled Filet of Bluefish       10.95
Broiled Salmon       14.95
Low fat, Heart-healthy Bison Steak served with cup of soup or salad, potato & vegetable       19.95

appetizers

Mozzarella Sticks       5.95
Chicken Fingers       6.95
Buffalo Wings       6.95
Stuffed Grape Leaves       5.95
Fruit Cocktail       3.75
Half Grapefruit       1.95
Zucchini Sticks       5.50
Cheese Fries       4.75
Taramosalata       4.50
Sweet Potato Fries       4.25
Spicy Curly Fries       4.25
Feta & Kalamata Olives       6.95
Fried Calamari       6.95

steaks & chops

Served With Cup of Soup or salad, Potato & Vegetable

Sirloin Steak with onion rings       17.95
Chopped Steak with fried onions       9.75
Calves Liver with onions or bacon       8.95
Broiled Pork Chops w/ apple sauce       12.95
London Broil with mushroom sauce       12.95
Broiled Chicken half       10.95
Chicken Breast Scampi over rice       10.95
Chicken Breast Souvlaki over rice       10.95
Chicken Breast Teriyaki over rice       10.95
Fried Chicken       8.95

cheyenne's pasta & sauté specials

Served With Soup or Salad

pasta
Eggplant Parmigiana topped with mozzarella & tomato sauce, served with spaghetti       8.95
Fettuccine Carbonara with bacon, prosciutto & romano cheese in a cream sauce       9.95
Fettuccine Puttanesca with tomato, basil capers, black olives & anchovies       9.95
Portobello Pasta sauteed fresh portobello mushrooms w/ zucchini, eggplant, carrots, shallots & plum tomatoes w/ penne pasta       11.95
Pasta Alla Couzanas penne pasta w/ mozzarella blended w/ basil, sun-dried tomatoes & romano cheese in olive oil garlic sauce       11.95
Pasta Alla Vongole linguine sauteed with fresh clams in white or red sauce       11.95
Fettuccine Alfredo fettuccine pasta in a creamy white sauce       9.95
Fresh Tortellini in Cream Sauce       10.95
Fresh Fettuccine or Linguine with broccoli & garlic       8.95
Ravioli in Cream or Marinara Sauce       8.95
Fresh Linguine in Marinara Sauce       6.95
Spaghetti in Marinara Sauce       6.95
With Meatballs       8.95
With Meat Sauce       8.95
Linguine Primavera with fresh vegetables       7.95
Meat Lasagna       9.95
Vegetable Lasagna       9.95
chicken
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana topped w/ mozzarella & tomato sauce, with spaghetti       11.95
Chicken Village sauteed with green peppers & mushrooms in a white lemon sauce       11.95
Chicken Mexicana sauteed with hot peppers, onions mushrooms & fresh tomatoes       11.95
Chicken Dijon sauteed with dijon mustard, heavy cream, mushrooms & artichokes       11.95
Chicken Primavera sauteed with carrots, broccoli mushrooms & fresh tomatoes       11.95
Chicken Carbonara sauteed w/ bacon, prosciutto & romano cheese in a cream sauce       11.95
Chicken Marsala sauteed breast of chicken in marsala wine sauce       11.95
Chicken Piccata sauteed breast of chicken with capers in a white wine & lemon sauce       11.95
Lemon Chicken sauteed breast of chicken with broccoli in a white lemon sauce       11.95
Chicken & Broccoli sauteed breast of chicken with fresh linguine       11.95
Chicken Teriyaki sauteed breast of chicken served over rice       11.95

greek specialties

Spinach Pie served with small greek salad       8.75
Moussaka served with small greek salad       9.25
Greek Pizza served with small greek salad       7.75
Greek Salad with feta cheese, anchovies, olives, stuffed grape leaves, lettuce, tomato, onions and cucumbers       7.95
Greek Salad with grilled chicken breast       9.95
Feta & Kalamata Olives       5.95
Greek Antipasto w/ taramosalata, feta cheese, anchovies, stuffed grape leaves, lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, olives & hard boiled egg w/ our house dressing       9.95
Chicken Gyro sandwich served with cole slaw and pickle. deluxe served with lettuce, tomatoes and french fries platter served with french fries and small greek salad   sandwich 5.50   deluxe 7.50   platter 8.50
Beef Gyro sandwich served with cole slaw and pickle. deluxe served with lettuce, tomatoes and french fries. platter served with french fries and small greek salad   sandwich 4.95   deluxe 7.50   platter 8.50
Souvlaki sandwich served with cole slaw and pickle. deluxe served with lettuce, tomatoes and french fries. platter served with french fries and small greek salad   sandwich 5.25   deluxe 7.50   platter 8.50
Chicken Souvlaki sandwich served with cole slaw and pickle. deluxe served with lettuce, tomatoes and french fries. platter served with french fries and small greek salad   sandwich 5.25   deluxe 7.50   platter 8.50

desserts

#1 In n.y. Baby Watson's Creamy Cheese Cake       3.95
Carrot Cake       3.75
Seven Layer Cake       3.50
Chocolate Mousse       3.50
Apple, Blueberry or Cherry Pie       2.95
Cream Pies       3.50
Rice Pudding       2
Fruit Salad       3.50
Jello       2

whipped cream $0.50 extra

danish & cookies

Apple Fritters       2.50
Croissants       2.50
Cheese, Cinnamon or Fruit Danish       2.50
Apple Turnover       2.50
Linzer Tarts       2.50
Cinnamon Horns       2.50
Pound Cake       2.50
Chocolate Chip Cookies       2.50
Cheyenne's Chocolate Cake with hard icing       4.25
Cheyenne's Famous Pound Cake       2.50

we serve fresh fruit smoothies

fruits & juices

Fresh Fruit Salad       3.75
Melon in season       2.75
Half Grapefruit       1.95
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice     med 3.50   lg 4.50
Assorted Juice grapefruit, tomato, cranberry       2

fountain delights

Ice Cream Soda       4.25
Milk Shake       4.25
Egg Cream       2.50
Chocolate Milk       2.50

extra thick shake $1 extra

ice cream creations

Sundae Fantasies two scoops of your favorite flavor ice cream, covered with fruit sauce, nuts and whipped cream       4.95
Pie Ala Mode hot apple pie, topped with your favorite flavor ice cream and whipped cream       4.25
Banana Split a split ripe banana, three jumbo scoops of creamy ice cream, covered with your choice of fruit sauce, topped with whipped cream and chopped nuts       6.50
ice cream
One Scoop       1.75
Two Scoops       2.75

special dairy bar

California Health Salad cottage cheese, fruit salad & jello       7.25
Tropicana Health Salad cottage cheese & fruit salad       6.75
Melon with cottage cheese       5.25

beer & wine

beer
Imported       4.50
Domestic       3.95
Corona       4.50
house wine
Glass       4.50

beverages

hot
Coffee or Tea       1
Brewed Decaffeinated Coffee       1
Assorted Herbal Teas       1.35
Hot Chocolate       1.50
Espresso       2
Cappuccino steamed milk with espresso coffee and a hint of cinnamon       3.75
cold
Fountain Sodas       2
Milk       2
Chocolate Milk       2.50
Iced Coffee or Iced Tea       2
Juice apple, cranberry, tomato, grapefruit, lemonade       2
Assorted Tropicana Juices      
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice     med 3.50   lg 4.50
Fresh Vegetable Juice      
Advertising