You are not logged in

New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Comfort Diner

Comfort Diner Menu

  • Takeout Available | Delivery Available
  • Delivery Payment:
    $12 minimum
  • Delivery Hours:
    Mon-Fri, 7:30am-9pm; Sat-Sun, 9am-9pm
  • Delivery Area:
    38th St. to 52nd St., First Ave. to Madison Ave.

small plates
A Nice Bowl of Soup       4.95
Grandma's Chicken Soup loaded with chicken comforts celery and noodles       4.95
A Nice Green Salad with tomato cucumber and red onion our dressing choices: house vinaigrette, bleu cheese, thousand island, ranch, avocado, lime or citrus vinaigrette       4.95
Caesar Salad hearts of romaine shredded parmesan and homemade garlic croutons tossed with a delicious caesar dressing       4.95
A Cup of Vegetarian Chili with shredded cheddar cheese sour cream housemade salsa and crisp tortilla chips       4.95
Wild Mushroom Potato Pancakes with our homemade chunky applesauce and snow cream       5.95
Mozzarella Sticks made her mozzarella wedges battered fried and served with marinara sauce       5.95
Potato Skins baked stuffed with bacon and cheddar then topped with a dollop of sour cream       5.95
Add Our Vegetarian Chili       2
Buffalo Chicken Wings spicy wings with bleu cheese dressing carrot and celery sides       6.95
Grilled Chicken Skewers marinated chicken breasted grilled and served with honey mustard or barbecue dipping sauce and mixed greens       6.95
Comfort Quesadilla breaded with pepper jock cheese and black beans topped with fresh salsa and sour cream       6.95
Add Avocado For a buck, chicken, For       3
Grilled For       4
Sliders (mini burgers) six delicious 2 ounce burgers with lettuce and tomato on brioche rolls       12.95
Sliders make it a dozen for       19.95
sandwiches
All of Our Sandwiches Are Served With Homemade Coleslaw and a Great Pickle For $1.95 More Order a Deluxe and We Add Hand Cut Idaho or Sweet Potato French fries, Roast Garlic or Mock Mashed potatoes, Rice or Steamed Broccoli to Your Plate
Grilled Cheese no designer cheese here just good old grilled american cheese with tomato, with bacon, add a buck       6.50
B.l.t thick cut bacon ripe tomato red leaf lettuce & mayo on roasted whole grain bread       7.50
Mediterranean Melt goat cheese oven - roasted tomatoes and pesto - grilled on rosemary bread       8.50
Retro Turkey Sandwich remember this one from the 80 roasted turkey breast muenster cheese avocado sprouts tomato & honey mustard on whole grain       8.95
Grilled Chicken Club a triple - decker with grilled chicken bacon red leaf lettuce, ripe tomato & mayo       8.95
Classic Tuna Melt solid white tuna salad tomato & melted cheese served on a toasted english muffin       8.95
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich crispy chicken breast tossed with spicy buffalo wing sauce served with lettuce tomato shredded carrot and bleu cheese dressing on a hero roll       8.95
Pulled Bbq Pork slow cooked bbq pork an a soft bun with cheddar & caramelized onions melt in your mouth delicious       8.95
Southwestern Chicken Wrap grilled chicken avocado pepper jock cheese lettuce tomato & chipotle mayo in a black bean wrap       8.95
Philly Cheese Steak thinly sliced top round loads of sauteed mushrooms onions and cheese whiz provolone or american cheese an or hero roll       9.95
Maine Crab Burger a great crab cake served on a big bun with sweet potato french fries, zippy homemade tartar sauce and creamy coleslaw       13.95
Comfort Burger beef buffalo turkey or veggie a delicious half - round broiled to perfection and placed on a comfortable bun       7.95
Make It a Cheeseburger Add       1
Imagination Burger let your imagination run add choose any or all of these to top your burgers bacon mushrooms grilled onion avocado cheddar provolone swiss mozzarella bleu cheese or vegetarian chili       9.95
large plates
A Large Caesar Salad romaine shredded parmesan & homemade garlic croutons tossed with a delicious caesar dressing       8.95
With a Delicious Chicken or Portabello Mushroom       3
Grilled Shrimp For       4
Pear and Gorgonzola Salad mixed greens peas gorgonzola pesto chips grapes & dried cranberries tossed with raspberry vinaigrette       10.95
Pear and Gorgonzola Salad add grilled chicken for       3
Grilled Shrimp For       4
Warm Taco Salad seasoned ground bee cheddar fresh salsa sour cream & tortilla chips a top shredded lettuce       11.95
Pistachio Chicken Salad Low Crab pistachio crusted chicken breast grilled asparagus & cherry tomatoes tossed with romaine lettuce & avocado lime dressing       11.95
Comfort Dinner Grilled Chicken Salad grilled chicken breast with oven roasted tomatoes artichoke hearts chickpeas and warm goat cheese atop balsamico vinaigrette tossed greens       11.95
Macaroni and Cheese macaroni & a yummy blend of cheese baked with crunchy golden top       10.95
A Bowl of Vegetarian Chili a hearty helping of our chili topped with cheddar sour cream fresh salsa & crisp corn com tortilla chips       10.95
Chili Mac we top half and order of our mac & cheese with half an order of our vegetarian chili it's a great combo make it chili mac con carne we an order of our mac & cheese with half on order of our vegetarian chili it’s a great combo       10.95
Make a Chili Mac con carne, We Add Seasoned Ground Beef For       2
Comforting Chicken Pot Pie savory chunks of chicken, carrots, celery, potatoes and peas in a velvety cream sauce baked with a flaky crust, it doesn't get better than this       11.95
Spinach and Ricotta Ravioli served with homemade marinara sauce and shaved parmesan       11.95
Grilled Soft Shell Chicken Tacos two soft tortillas filled with chicken, chopped lettuce, fresh salsa and shredded pepper jack cheese, served with black beans, spanish rice and guacamole       11.95
Soft Shell Chicken Tacos two soft tortillas filled with chicken, shredded lettuce, fresh salsa and shredded pepper jack cheese, served with black beans, spanish rice and guacamole       11.95
Thanksgiving Every Day talk about comfort food roasted turkey breast, stuffing, mashed potatoes, with gravy, homemade cranberry sauce & fresh veggie your will thanks us       12.95
Mom's Meatloaf (on Her Best day) with carmelized onion & mushroom gravy, roast garlic mashed potatoes, and today's vegetable sorry, mom, but yours never fasted this good       13.95
Chicken Fried Chicken chicken breast dusted in seasoned flour and pan fried until rice n crispy with roast garlic mashed potatoes, lumpy cream gravy and collard greens       12.95
Brinley's Lemon Chicken seared chicken breast served with sauteed mushrooms a lusciously tight lemon pan sauce jasmine rice and the vegetable of the day       12.95
Pecan Crushed Catfish drizzled with garlic lime butter and served with mashed sweet potatoes and collard greens       13.95
Honey dipt: Southern Fried Chicken with mac & cheese and collard greens       13.95
Gulf Coast Jambalaya chicken shrimp & chorizo sausage cooked in a spicy combo of rice tomatoes peppers celery and onions       14.95
Oven Crisped Fish and Chips if you love fish and chips but and afraid of the fryer this version is for you we top fillet with seasoned bread crumbs and out potatoes into nice thick wedges then bake both until they got nice and crispy and serve it to you with home made tartar sauce coleslaw and vinegar       14.95
Herb Crusted Salmon (low crab) pan seasoned and served with steamed broccoli and mock mashed potatoes       14.95
pancakes, waffles, french toast & more
We Serve 100% Maple Syrup Grade Amber
Belgian Waffle       6.50
Big Buttermilk Pancakes made from scratch of course for a buck add toasted pecans, bananas, strawberries, or blueberries       6.95
Big Bread Challah French Toast       7.50
Blueberry Lemon Ricotta Pancakes       7.95
Berry Stuffed French Toast       8.95
Banana Hazelnut French Toast with this version of our stuffed french toast we load it up with sliced bananas, and toasted hazelnut and a course we add more on top       8.95
Red, White & Blue Waffle we just love piling fruit on top of things this waffle gets strawberries bananas, and blueberries that provide the meal       8.95
The Lumber Lack 2 buttermilk, pancakes, 2 eggs, any style & your choice of bacon, ham or sausage       10.95
The New Yorker a toasted bagel with smoked salmon, cream cheese, tomato, capers, & red onion       11.95
sides
Half a Grapefruit       2.50
Home Fries or Grits       2.50
Half a Melon or Fresh Fruit Cup       3.50
Bacon, Ham or Sausage       3.50
Red Hannel Hash       4.95
coffee & other good things to drink
Coffee or Tea       2.25
Hot Chocolate       2.75
Espresso       2.95
Cappuccino or Latte       3.95
Freshly Squeezed Orange or Grapefruit Juice     2.95   3.95
Cranberry, Pineapple or Tomato Juice     2.50   3.50
A Tail Glass of Lemonade       3
Strawberry Lemonade       3.50
Sandy's Fruit & Yogurt or Susie's Fruit & Sorbet Smoothie       4.50
gourmet sodas from boylans
Orange Cream      
Diet Orange Cream      
Root Beer      
Diet Root Beer      
Birch Beer      
Diet Birch Beer      
Creamy Red Birch Beer      
Black Cherry      
Diet Black Cherry      
Cream Soda and Diet Cream Soda      
brunch
The All American 2 farm fresh eggs cooked any style with home fries and your choice of toast add bacon ham or sausage       4.95
Country Breakfast 2 eggs cooked any style, 2 fluffy buttermilk biscuits with white sausage gravy and grits       6.95
Breakfast Burrito scrambled eggs triple bean chili, avocado, shredded off rolled inside peasant bread burrito style       7.50
Add Bacon Ham or Sausage For       2.50
The Bbc no its not an english television station it is our most popular omelet, made with bacon, broccoli, and cheddar cheese, with home fries & toast       7.95
Comfort Healthy Omelet egg whites and grilled vegetable omelet, served with sliced tomato and whole grain toast       8.95
Huevos Rancheros crisp tortilla chips topped with fried eggs fresh salsa, black beans, jack cheese, and sour cream, served with grits or home fries       8.95
Imagination Omelet let your imagination run wild add up to 3 of the following your oyster, ham, bacon, mushroom, triple bean, onions, peppers, or any of our green cheese       8.95
Red Flannel Hash homemade corned beef, hash made with sweet potato & roasted beets, with poached eggs & toast       8.95
Eggs Benedict Sandy's Way poached eggs on toasted english muffin flavored with american, bacon, & hollandaise sauce       8.95
The Leo (lox, Eggs & onions) 3 scrambled eggs with smoked salmon and caramelized onions, with fries & toast       9.90
Steak & Eggs grilled black angus steak, 2 eggs, any style, horrie, fries and toast       13.95

daily specials

Sample Menu

eat good food
Soups of the Day grandma's chicken noodles or chilled asparagus & avocado with crabmeat      
Sandwich Specials or order a half sandwich and a cup of soup, tuna salad club with avocado, lettuce & tomatoes on toasted 7 grain chicken philly cheese steak hero with onion, mushrooms & cheese       8.95
Pasta Special chilled tricolor fusilli with broccoli, roasted plum tomatoes, asparagus, mushrooms & a garlic olive oil drizzle       11.95
Captain's Catch blackened catfish with baked sweet potato & sauteed spinach with mushrooms and tomatoes       14.95
blue plate special
Pork Chop and Applesauce center cut shop served with chunky applesauce garlic mashed potatoes & veggie of the day, today's veggie: sauteed brussels sprouts with bacon & shallots      
dessert
Key Lime pie: Made With 100% Fresh Squeezed Key Limes
Chocolate Mousse Cake      
Apple Pie      
Blueberry Pie      
Carrot Cake      
Cherry Pie      
Russian Coffee Cake      
Peach Pie      
Blueberry Cheesecake      
Brownie Sundaes      
Big Cookies      
S' More & More      
Advertising