Dosa Garden

The rating scale of 0 to 100 reflects our editors’ appraisals of all the tangible and intangible factors that make a restaurant or bar great — or terrible — regardless of price.

Read more about the new ratings
77 Solid

The half-vegetarian menu devotes a lot of space to South Indian staples.

323 Victory Blvd., Staten Island, NY, 10301


Known For

The lowdown

On a forlorn strip of halal meat shops and Indo-Pakistani eateries, under lemony yellow lights, Dosa Garden lets you choose from more than a dozen variations of rice-lentil crêpes, which might be spread with chutney, stuffed with potato and onions, or topped with chicken or egg. The menu’s other 100-plus items include mutton fry, pancakelike utthappam, and fried doughy samosas, paneer, or idly patties. The half-vegetarian menu devotes a lot of space to South Indian staples: Malai chicken tikka, bite-size spiced kebabs, arrive moister than the bone-dry salmon tikka, but still fairly parched. But there’s ghee-slathered Kashmiri naan as well, with a buttery peanut pancake feel. The shrimp khoruma, cradled in a mini-wok, bathes in a thick coconut-milk curry, while the chicken biryani subtly meshes juicier chicken with fragrant rice and wild red spices. The sweet gulab jamun, starchy fried-cheese balls in a hot honey soup, is a satisfying meal-ender, if you have room.

What you need to know

Recommended DishesKashmiri naan; rasam; paper masala sosa; chicken biryani; gulab jamun.


Noise LevelCivilized