New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Edgar's Cafe

Edgar's Cafe Menu

soup and quiche
Soup of the Day       6
Spinach & Mushroom Quiche Broccoli & Cheddar Quiche, quiche Lorraine       6.25
Combination of Two soup, quiche or small salad       12
salads
Edgar's Salad mixed green house salad includes red leaf, endive, radicchio and mescolanza, topped with walnuts       11
Caprese Salad bocconcini (mozzarella), tomato, basil, served with our house salad       11.25
Goat Cheese Salad toasted bread topped with goat cheese served with our house salad       11.25
Bocconcini Alla Paesana mozzarella melted over garlic bread served with our house salad and tomato       11.50
Bruschetta Romana toasted garlic bread slices topped with a chopped tomato and fennel mixture served with our house salad       11
Insalada di Tonno italian tuna in olive oil over a bed of mixed green salad and sliced red onions       12.25
Ramon's Salad roasted red peppers, bocconcini, tomato, basil, red onion and olives served over our house salad       12.25
Smoked Rainbow Trout served with our creamy horseradish sauce and mixed greens salad       12.25
Paesano Salad red potato, string beans, endive, tomato, red onion served with our house salad       12.50
Avocado Salad mixed green house salad surrounded by avocado and tomato slices       13
Avocado and Shrimp Salad avocado halves filled with shrimp salad and served with our house salad       14.50
Chicken Zingara chunks of chicken breast poached or grilled with avocado, tomato, red onion served with mixed green salad       13.75
Potato Milanese red potatoes, string beans, tomatoes, red onion and basil prepared with house dressing       11
Raven Salad baby spinach topped with goat cheese, surrounded with warm red potatoes, tomato, red onion and sprinkled with oregano       12.25
Mediterranean Bean Salad red kidney beans, peas, beets, red onions served over our mixed green salad       11.75
Garbanzo Salad chick peas mixed with tomato and italian parsley, topped with feta cheese, onions and cucumber       12.25
Mikos Salad feta cheese, red onion, fresh red peppers, cucumbers, tomato and kalamata olives       12.75
Shrimp and Arugula Salad shrimp, arugola, artichoke hearts and tomatoes       14
Smoked Turkey and Blue Cheese Salad served over mixed greens and topped with walnuts       12
Beef Carpaccio Salad thin slices of raw beef served over mixed greens salad topped with shaved grana cheese       14.25
Smoked Tuna Carpaccio Salad thin slices of smoked tuna served over mixed greens salad       14.25
Bresola Salad thin slices of cured beef served over mixed greens salad       14.25
Portobello Mushroom grilled portobello mushroom over mixed greens salad with mozzarella, basil and sun dried tomatoes       12.50
Vegetarian Asparagus Salad marinated grilled asparagus served over our house salad with sun dried tomatoes       12.50
Jenny's Salad chopped mixed greens, roasted red peppers, grilled egg plant, fresh mushroom, garnished with feta cheese       12.50
Aska Salad arugula, slices of cucumber, tomatoes, red pepper, avocado, feta cheese and red onion       12.50
sandwiches
All Sandwiches (except Snack side) Served With Our Mixed Greens Salad
Smoked Salmon Sandwich with cream cheese on pumpernickel bread       12.50
Focaccia toasted with choice of melted fontina and gruyere or bocconcini with bruschetta       12
With Goat Cheese & Bresaola (cured beef)       12
Vegetarian Sandwich mixed grilled vegetables eggplant, zucchini, peppers, mushrooms, onions on warm italian bread       12
With Goat Cheese or Melted Mozzarella       13.25
Roasted Red Pepper Sandwich roasted red pepper marinated in olive oil and garlic served over italian bread with mozzarella       12.25
Smoked Turkey Sandwich on italian baguette or pumpernickel       12
With Melted Gruyere Cheese       13
Poe's Sandwich italian baguette filled with goat cheese, dill, capers and cucumbers       12
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich on italian baguette       14
With Mozzarella       15
Snack Size Sandwiches choice of bocconcini; smoked turkey; bresaola or goat cheese on a semolina roll with lettuce and tomato       4
pizza & pasta
Pizza Margarita traditional thin crust pizza topped with mozzarella and fresh basil       9
Pizza Focaccia Caprese chopped red pepper, tomato, green olives and mozzarella topped with bruschetta and served with mixed greens       13
Lasagna homemade with parmesan, ricotta, mozzarella and fresh tomato sauce       13
With Salad       15
Penne All Marinara pesto or bolognese       10
cakes $5.75
Black Forest cocoa short pastry base, two layers of cocoa sponge cake soaked with cherry liquor and filled with custard and cherries, covered on the sides with crusted cocoa sponge and flaky chocolate dusted with cocoa      
Profiterol With Whipped Cream pastry puffs filled with custard and covered with chocolate      
Frutti di Bosco (wild berries) crumb crust filled custard, thin layer of cake topped with chantilly with raspberries, blueberries, strawberries, blackberries, red and black currents      
Lemon Tart butter tart crust with lemon custard and whipped cream      
Pecan Tart traditional pecan tart pecans in buttery syrup filled with shortbread shell      
Pear Tart butter tart crust filled with marzipan, pear slices and glazing      
Tiramisu (homemade) our tiramisu, very light italian mascarpone cheese mixed with coffee syrup, coffee liquor layered between two thin layers of lady fingers and topped with chocolate powder      
Chocolate Mousse layer* layers of chocolate chiffon cake filled in between with smooth chocolate mousse glazed with chocolate ganache      
White and Chocolate Mousse Cake (flour less)* chocolate mousse and white chocolate mousse covered with dark chocolate glaze topped with white chocolate curls      
Cappuccino mousse* chocolate butter cookie crust filled with creamy dark chocolate and coffee mousse flavor topped with roses of whipped cream      
Chocolate Velvet boule* velvety chocolate mousse, thin layer of sponge cake all ground it covered with chocolate ganache      
Chocolate Peanut Butter Mousse (non-dairy) chocolate cake bottom topped with thick chocolate fudge and a mound of peanut butter mousse      
Banana Chocolate Mousse two layers of mousse: one layer of banana mousse and one layer of chocolate mousse, topped with chocolate ganache      
Autumn flower* layers of chocolate cake filled with thick and melting chocolate ganache      
Chocolate Truffle (flourless) rich not too sweet flourless chocolate truffle cake      
Lemon Raspberry delice* two delicious lemon cake layers filled with a creamy lemon custard and a layer of raspberry preserve, topped with a sweet apricot glaze      
Lemon Cake crumb crust lemon custard with meringue on the top      
Vesuvius rich brownie cake topped with a layer of chocolate fudge, cheesecake, then a mound of chocolate mousse on top, dark chocolate truffles around the edge, finished off with caramel, chocolate and white chocolate chips nuts      
Cappuccino Cheesecake a thick layer of chocolate butter cookie crust topped with cappuccino flavor cream cheesecake      
Oreo Cheesecake our rich new york style cheesecake on a graham cracker crust, inside this cake are layers of oreo cookies, covered with rich chocolate and decorated with oreo cookie pieces      
Chocolate Mousse Cheesecake butter cookie crust topped with creamy cheesecake and a thick layer of chocolate mousse, covered with chocolate ganache      
Brownie Cheesecake a mix of creamy cheesecake and chunks of brownie, topped with more brownies      
New York Cream cheesecake* melts in your mouth! 100% pure cream cheese, sour cream, fresh pasteurized eggs, real vanilla extract and a hint of lemon baked to a golden perfection in a deluxe cookie dough crust. the classic!      
With Strawberries in Season Extra       .75
Cognac Pumpkin cheesecake* cognac graham crumb topped with a spiced creamy smooth cheese mixture and a layer of whipped cream      
Caramel Apple dandy* cookie dough filled with crushed apples, cream cheese, brown sugar and spices. topped with crumbs and a lot of caramel      
Apple Brown betty* this 200 year old early american southern apple recipe has a graham cracker crust which if packed with apples and topped with powdered sugar. densely packed with flavor      
Carrot Walnut cake* two thick layers of fluffy carrot cake filled in between with cheese finished with frosting and crushed walnuts      
German chocolate* layers of chocolate cake and coconut (pecans, coconut, milk, butter, flour, eggs, vanilla, salt and baked powder)      
Chocolate Raspberry blackout* three moist bitter-sweet chocolate layers, filled with raspberry jam and generously topped with raspberry glaze. decorated with bitter chocolate      
Cinnamon Coffee Cake sour cream bundt coffee cake with swirls of cinnamon and walnuts      
Almond Raspberry marzipan* white sponge cake, custard, raspberry puree topped with almond marzipan      
Chocolate Madness (non-dairy)* chocolate cake bottom layered with thin layer of chocolate mousse, topped with a rich thick and dense chocolate fudge      
Chocolate mud* rich chocolate cake filled with gummy chocolate mousse and fudge      
Fresh Strawberries (seasonal) with whipped cream      
pies $5.75
Key Lime Pie lime, sugar, heavy cream in a butter cookie (no nuts)      
Sour Cherry Pie sour cherries baked in a deep-dish homemade pie      
Apple Cranberry Walnut Pie fresh apples, cranberries and walnuts baked in a deep-dish homemade pie      
Peach Crumb Pie (non-dairy)* crumb crust filled with peaches      
Strawberry Rhubarb pie* strawberries, rhubarb, walnuts, pecans, eggs, salt, butter, sugar, flour, canola oil and corn starch      
Apple Crumb pie* apples baked in a pastry shell and topped with a chunky crumb (apples, flour sugar, butter, canola oil, eggs, salt, cinnamon)      
Three Berry pie* strawberries, blueberries, raspberries and cranberries, eggs, salt, butter, sugar, flour, canola oil, cornstarch      
Blueberry Crumb pie* blueberries, lemon juice, walnuts, pecans, eggs, flour, sugar, butter, canola oil, corn starch and topped with a chunky crumb      
gelati and sorbetti
Vanilla       5.75
Chocolate       5.75
Hazelnut       5.75
Strawberry       5.75
Coffee       5.75
Mixed Berries Sorbetto       6
Lemon Sorbetto       6
Sorbettos in Their Natural Shells orange, lemon, pineapple, coconut or peach       6
Tartufo       6
cookies and pastries $5
Per 1/4lb or For 2 Cookies
Almond Biscotti       1.50
Sesame Biscotti       1.50
Pignoli Cookies       1.50
Chocolate Chip Butter Cookies       1
Cinnamon Raisin rugelach*       ea 1
Sugar Free Raspberry rugelach*       ea 1
Chocolate Covered Almond biscotti*       ea 1.50
Muffins or Croissants       ea 1.95
coffee and hot drinks
Espresso       2.75
Espresso Tranquillo       3.50
Espresso Doppio       5.50
Espresso Doppio Tranquillo       6
Espresso Macchiato       3.50
Espresso Macchiato Tranquillo       4
Espresso Corretto       4
Cappuccino       3.50
Cappuccino Tranquillo       4
Cappuccino with whipped cream       4.50
Viennese       5.50
Viennese Tranquillo       6
Caffe Latte       4
Caffe Latte Tranquillo       4.50
Mochaccino       3.75
Mochaccino Tranquillo       4.25
With Whipped Cream       5
Cioccolato Caldo       3.75
With Whipped Cream       4.75
Latte Caldo steamed       3.75
With Orzata       4.75
Hot Cider with cinnamon       4.50
American Coffee       1.75
American Coffee Tranquillo       1.95
teas - decaffeinated teas $3.75
Chamomile      
Peach Apricot      
Red Raspberry      
Earl Grey      
Peppermint      
Lipton      
English Breakfast      
teas - traditional blends $3.75
Darjeeling      
Lipton      
English Breakfast      
Apple Cinnamon      
Jasmine Green Tea      
Orange Pekoe      
Earl Gray      
Blueberry Vanilla      
cold drinks
Acqua Minerale       3
Boylan's Sodas root beer, diet root beer, creme, black cherry, grape       3
Coca Cola       2
Diet Cola       2
Ginger Ale       2
Sprite       2
Apple Juice       3
Cranberry Juice       3
Fresh Orange Juice       3.75
Fresh Grapefruit Juice       3.75
Fresh Lemonade unsweetened       3.50
Milk       3
With Orzata       3.50
Orzata with mineral water       3.75
Grenadine with mineral water       3.75
Iced Espresso       4
With Whipped Cream       5.50
Iced Cioccolato with whipped cream       4.75
Iced Viennese       5.50
Iced Mochaccino       4.75
Iced Mochaccino Tranquillo       5
Iced Cappuccino       4.25
With Gelato       6.25
With Whipped Cream       5.50
Iced Cappuccino Tranquillo       4.50
Iced Caffe Latte       4.50
Iced Tea unsweetened       3.75
Iced American Coffee       3.75
Iced American Coffee Tranquillo       4
Frappuccino       5
With Mocha       5.25
With Gelato       6.50
Milk Shakes chocolate, vanilla, coffee, hazelnut, strawberry       6.50
side orders
Fresh Wrapped Cream       2
Gelati Side Scoops       3.25
wine and beer
House Red - Montepulciano       6.50
House White - Trebiano       6.50
Amstel Lite       5.25
Heineken       5.25
Corona       5.50
Advertising