New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Island Burgers and Shakes

Menus provided by Menupages

Island Burgers and Shakes Menu

  • Takeout Available | Delivery Available
  • Delivery Payment:
    $10 minimum | Cash Only
  • Delivery Hours:
    Sat-Thu, noon-10:30pm; Fri, noon-11pm
  • Delivery Area:
    40th St. to 64th St., Fifth Ave. to Twelfth Ave.

appetizers
Grilled Asparagus parmigiano reggiano, balsamic       5.25
Chili spicy with beef and red beans       5
Chili Works cheddar, sour cream, chopped onions       5.75
Chili Works and Chips       7.50
Guacamole and Chips (v)       7.50
Salsa and Chips (v)       7.50
Salsa, Guacamole and Chips (v)       9
Grilled Chicken Sticks choose one style: bbq, cajun, italian, mexican, plain, thai       6.75
small salads
Mixed Greens       4.50
Mixed Greens and Tomato       5.50
Antipasto       10
Small Caesar       6.50
Small Tabouleh       6.50
Lil' Ham mixed greens, tomato, mushrooms, italian herbs       6.25
Lil' Bacon Bleu mixed greens, croutons, bacon, bleu       6.25
sandwiches
Mozzarella, pesto, tomato, Onion (v) on ciabatta       8.75
Salsa, jack, guacamole, Jalapeno (v) on sourdough       8.25
Roasted pepper, mozz, onion, Tomato (v) on ciabatta       8.75
Genoa (v) pesto, roasted peppers, mozzarella, tomato, onions on ciabatta       9.50
Grilled Cheese (v) white cheddar on sourdough       7
B.l.t on sourdough       7
Add avocado, cheese, guacamole, Salsa or Ranch       8.25
Guacamole, bacon, cheddar, tomato, Onion on sourdough       8.25
Grilled Ham and Swiss on rye       8.50
main course salads
Tabouleh (v) on chicken       10
Add Grilled Chicken       14
Caesar no chicken       10
Add Grilled chicken. Choose One style: bbq, blackened, cajun, italian, mexican, plain, Thai       14
Cabo San Lucas (v) mixed greens, cheddar, jack, salsa, guac, jalapeno, onion, roasted peppers, tomatoes, tortilla chips       10
Add Mexican Chicken       14
Tuscan (v) mixed greens, mozzarella, mushrooms, onions, roasted peppers, olives, artichoke hearts, tomato, parmagiano reggiano       10
Add Italian Chicken       14
Tommy's Phuket (v) mixed greens, roasted peppers, avocado, jalapeno, tomato, onions, mushrooms       10
Add Thai Chicken       14
Cobb mixed greens, grilled chicken, bacon, bleu, avocado, egg, tomato       14
Chef mixed greens, grilled chicken, cheddar, swiss, ham, artichoke heart, olive, mushroom, tomato, onion, egg       14
Boo Zoo mixed greens, blackened chicken, bacon, cheddar, tomato, onion, mushrooms, jalapeno       14
chicken & salad plates
Choose One Style
Bbq, blackened, cajun, italian, mexican, plain, Thai served with mixed greens and tomatoes       11.50
chicken sticks & salad plates
Choose One Style
Bbq, cajun, italian, mexican, plain, Thai served with mixed greens and tomatoes       11
chicken fajitas
Fajitas with sauteed onions, roasted peppers, guacamole, salsa       12.75
Big Ass add cheddar, acapulco sauce, sour cream       14.25
Whitey's bacon, cheddar, sour cream       12.75
Sauteed onions, Roasted Peppers       4.75

hamburgers and churascos

A Churrasco Is a Grilled Chicken Sandwich

simple
Hamburger / Churrasco
Basic served wtih lettuce, red onion, pickles     8.50   9
Bangkok a thai chili, curry, peanut sauce     9.50   10
Cheese     9.50   10
Choose one: White cheddar, swiss, bleu, Monterey jack, mozzarella, american, boursin, Parmesan spread, Goat       2
Guacamole     10   10.50
Hsb Sauce horseradish-sour cream-black pepper     9.50   10
Mike's Pool Hall jack, sauteed onions on dark rye     10   10.50
Mushroom     9.50   10
Pesto on ciabatta     10   10.50
Ranch     9.50   10
Salsa     9.50   10
Sauteed Onion and Mushroom     10   10.50
Au Poivre a black pepper cream sauce     10.75   11.25
mild
Hamburger / Churrasco
Cordon Bleu ham and swiss on sourdough     10.75   11.25
Frog boursin, bacon, sauteed onions     11.25   11.75
Mulberry Street sauteed onions, peppers on ciabatta     11.25   11.75
Patty Melt swiss, sauteed onions on toasted rye     10.75   11.25
Charlie's Sweet and Sour relish, honey mustard, swiss     11   11.50
Parmigiana marinara, mozzarella, parmesan on ciabatta     11   11.25
Riviera sauteed onions, peppers, mushrooms on ciabatta     11.25   11.75
The Peoples's Choice swiss, mushrooms, sauteed onions     10.75   11.25
Vito's roasted peppers, mozzarella on ciabatta     12   12.50
Boss's bacon, jack, ranch on sourdough     12   12.50
El Camino bacon, jack, ranch on sourdough     12   12.50
Here's Gianni parmesan spread, roasted peppers, bacon on ciabatta     12   12.50
Route 66 avocado, swiss, bacon on dark rye     12   12.50
Sans Spud bacon, cheddar, sour cream, chives     12   12.50
Saratoga Hsb sauce, bacon, cheddar on sourdough     12   12.50
The Derby avocado, bleu, bacon     12   12.50
a little kick
Hamburger / Churrasco
Jalapeno and Jack     11.25   11.75
Bbq spicy barbeque sauce     10.50   11
Blackened cajun style rub, seared in a cast iron pan     10.50   11
Cajun grilled with cajun spices     10.50   11
Derrick's blackened, pesto on ciabatta     11.25   11.75
Roma thyme, rosemary, garlic, oregano, red pepper flakes     9.50   10
Black n' Blue blackened, blue     11.25   11.75
Miss Hula ham, swiss, honey mustard, pineapple     12   12.50
Chesky's mozzarella, honey mustard     11.25   11.75
Cowboy bbq sauce, sauteed onions, bacon cheddar, ranch on sourdough     12   12.50
Honey West ham, cheddar, honey mustard     12   12.50
Tijuana bacon, jack, guacamole, sauteed onions     12   12.50
Slick Willie's ham, relish, american, bacon, sour cream, bbq sauce, sauteed onions     12.75   13.25
decadent
Hamburger / Churrasco
Best Western ham, jack, sauteed onions, chives, pepper on sourdough     12   12.50
Hippo curried sour cream, bacon, cheddar, guacamole, sauteed onions, scallions on pita     12   12.50
Julius caesar salad on pita     12   12.50
Mona Lisa mozzarella, pesto, sauteed onions, mushrooms, peppers, parmigiana reggiano on ciabatta     12   12.50
Pizza mozzarella, marinara, sauteed onions, mushrooms, peppers, parmigiano reggiano on ciabatta     12   12.50
Princess Grace ham, boursin, sauteed onions, mushrooms, peppers on ciabatta     12   12.50
Sam I Am pesto, ham, american, hard boiled egg     12   12.50
Will's bacon, cheddar, sour cream, sauteed onions, scallions on sourdough     12   12.50
Hobie's au poivre, bleu, sauteed onions, bacon on sourdough     12.75   13.25
Raoul's au poivre, swiss, mushrooms on ciabatta     12.75   13.25
Marco's pesto, ranch, bacon, parmesan on ciabatta     12   12.50
hot
Hamburger / Churrasco
Acapulco a sweet and spicy mexican sauce with blended roasted onions, jalapeno, garlic and cilantro     10.50   11
Chili homemade beef and bean chili on sourdough toast     10.50   11
Barzel's blackened, jack, bacon, horseradish on ciabatta     12   12.50
Bourbon Street blackened, bacon, jack, bayou mayo, sauteed onions on sourdough     12   12.50
Deluxe Chili chili, cheddar, sour cream, bbq sauce on sourdough toast     12   12.50
Duke's blackened, jalapeno, jack on sourdough     12   12.50
Hermosa Beach jack, salsa, jalapeno, sauteed onions     12   12.50
Napalm blackened, bbq sauce, jalapeno, cheddar, habanero sauce     12   12.50
Pancho's mexican sauce, bacon, cheddar     12   12.50
Pepe's blackened, jack, guacamole, bacon, sauteed onions     12   12.50
Pop and Top's thai sauce, jalapeno, roasted peppers     12   12.50
South of the Border jack, salsa, guacamole, jalapeno     12   12.50
It's a Mad Mad World blackened, pesto, salsa, swiss, pickle relish on pita     12.75   13.25
The Clyde blackened, salsa, bleu, avocado, bacon     12.75   13.25
Crescent City blackened, bayou mayo, onion, sourdough     11.25   11.75
sides
Fries       3.75
real big baked potatoes
Naked plain       2.50
Standard butter and/or sour cream       3.25
Classic butter, sour cream, cheddar, chives and bacon       5
It's Your Thing add extras to naked potato      
Per Topping       .75
Bacon       2
Avocado       2
dirty potato chips $1.75
Regular Chips      
Jalapeno      
Barbeque      
Onion & Sour Cream      
Salt and Vinegar      
beverages
Snapple Iced Tea lemon, diet lemon, peach, diet peach       2
Snapple Lemonade lemonade, pink lemonade       2
Soda coke, diet coke, 7-up, diet 7-up, dr. pepper, diet dr. pepper, root beer, cream soda, sunkist, ginger ale, seltzer       1.75
Poland Spring       1.75
from the fountain
Milk Shakes vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, black & white       5.75
Malteds add malt powder to a milkshake       5.95
Floats ice cream and your choice of soda       5.95
breads
Sesame Bun      
Whole Wheat Pita      
Dark Rye      
Rye Pullman Sourdough      
Ciabatta       1.25
sodas & iced tea $1.75
Snapple Lemonade       1.75
Snapple Pink Lemonade       1.75
Snapple Iced Tea       1.75
Snapple Peach Iced Tea       1.75
Diet Iced Tea       1.75
Diet Peach Iced Tea       1.75
Coke       1.50
Diet Coke       1.50
7-Up       1.50
Diet 7-up       1.50
Root Beer       1.50
Cream Soda       1.50
Dr. Pepper       1.50
Diet dr. Pepper       1.50
Sunkist       1.50
Ginger Ale       1.50
Seltzer       1.50
Poland Spring       1.75
beer
Coors Lights       4
Sierra Nevada       5
Corona       4.50
Red Stripe       5
Chimay Rouge       8
Anchor Steam       5.50
old fashioned cookies $2
Chocolate Chip Cookies      
Oatmeal Raisin with walnut cookies      
Kitchen Sink Cookies      
Chocolate Chip with walnut cookies      
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies      

Extras $1, Au Poivre Sauce $3, Ciabatta Bread $1.25, Avocado $2. All Hamburgers and Churascos Are Served With lettuce, Red Onion and Pickles on the side, Tomatoes and Sauteed Onions Available Upon request, When Bread Is Not specified, Served on Bun

Menus provided by Menupages

Advertising