New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Ithaka

Ithaka Menu

  • Takeout Available | Delivery Available
  • Delivery Payment:
    $20 minimum
  • Delivery Hours:
    Daily, 4:30pm-10pm
  • Delivery Area:
    76th St. to 96th St., FDR Dr. to Fifth Ave.

menu
Soupa Imeras soup of the day       6.50
Kotosoupa Avgolemono chicken egg lemon soup with vegetables and rice       7
salads
Horiatiki (country) romaine lettuce, feta cheese, olives, tomatoes, cucumber, extra virgin olive oil     sm 9.50   lg 12.50
Ithaka's Salad arugula, watercress, endives, avocado and kalamata olives with ithaka dressing     sm 9.50   lg 12.50
Maroulosalata thinly chopped romaine lettuce, scallions and dill with extra virgin olive oil       9.50
Salata Apo Thalasina salad from the sea with shrimp, scallops, crabmeat and avocado       24
cold appetizers
Tzatziki yogurt, cucumber, dill       7
Yogurt, cucumber, Dill smoked eggplant puree       7
Taramosalata carp mousse       7
Fava yellow pea puree with olive oil and chopped onions       7
Tirokafteri spicy spread with feta cheese, olive oil & red, green peppers       9
Skordalia potato, garlic, almond       6
Pikilia choice of 3 from the above       14
Dolmadakia home made grape leaves stuffed with rice and fine herbs       8
Feta Cheese greek feta with vine ripe tomatoes olives & oregano       7.50
With Tomato Salad       9.50
Shrimp Cocktail jumbo shrimp, served with tomato cocktail sauce       16
hot appetizers
Melitzana Santorini stuffed baby eggplant with freshly sautéed vegetables and herbs       9
Oktapodi Scharas charcoal grilled octopus with greek seasoning       13
Kalamarakia baby squid pan-fried       10.50
Garides Saganaki seared and baked butterfly shrimp with feta, herbs and tomato       13
Bakaliaro Scordalia crispy pan-fried salted codfish served with garlic spread       13
Loukaniko Sparta char grilled greek sausage with orange zest, fresh herbs and spices       9
Glikadakia sweetbread sautéed in white wine sauce       12
Media Krasata mussel's sautéed in white wine sauce       13
Keftedakia seasoned meatballs, lightly broiled       9.50
Ortykia quail, marinated in red wine and herbs, grilled and served on a bed of arugula       10.50
Saganaki       11
Flambé kefalograviera lightly fried with butter and lemon or flambé       12
Tiganites Piperyes green peppers stuffed with three kinds of cheese and drizzled with olive oil and lemon       9
Kolokythakia pan-fried zucchini with garlic spread       8
Spanakotiropita homemade spinach pie with feta cheese and dill       7.50
Gigantes Fournou giant lima beans baked with tomatoes and scallions       9
entrees
Mousaka layers of eggplant, potatoes, chopped lamb and beef, topped with béchamel       20
Pasticio pasta layers with chopped lamb and beef meat, topped with béchamel       19
Kapamas boneless lamb simmered in fresh tomato sauce       23
Arni Youvetsi baby lamb baked in a clay pot with orzo pasta, fresh tomato sauce and feta cheese. please allow 25 minutes       26
Lago Stifado rabbit stew with pearl onions & red wine sauce       24
Arni Souvlaki marinated cubes of tender lamb with tomatoes, green peppers and onions       22
Kotopoulo Souvlaki marinated chicken with tomatoes, green peppers and onions       19
Paidakia Arnisa charcoal grilled lamb chops with greek seasoning with roast lemon potatoes       34
Brizola Moscharisa rib steak, charcoal grilled with roast lemon potatoes       (20oz) 33
Kota Sta Karvouna grilled whole boneless chicken with oregano       22
Chef's Vegetarian Plate       19
from the sea
Psari Tis Imeras selection of fresh fish of the day      
Kakavia rich seafood and fish broth thickened with root vegetables and garnished with shrimp, scallops and sea bass       24
Daily Seafood Pasta shrimp, blue point prawn and sea scallops in a fresh tomato sauce       26
Garides Grecolimano jumbo shrimp, individually baked in a clay pot with fresh tomato, garlic, a splash of ouzo and topped with melted cheese       24
Garides Sta Karvouna char-grilled, marinated shrimp with lemon and extra virgin olive oil       24
Souvlaki Apo Thalassina broiled shrimp and scallops with tomato, green peppers and onions       24
Solomos Scharas charbroiled salmon steak       23
Kalamari Scharas whole marinated calamari, charbroiled with lemon and olive oil       22
Psari Plaki daily fish baked with feta cheese, fresh tomato sauce, fresh herbs, onions and garlic       23
sides
Horta steamed wild greens in lemon and extra virgin olive oil       7
Patzaria beets and garlic spread       7
Fries Oregano       6
Spanaki sautéed spinach       6
desserts
Loukoumades crisp greek donuts glazed with honey and walnuts       7.50
Baklava layers of walnuts between filo topped with honey       7.50
Revani semolina almond cake with orange zest       8
Galaktoboureko milk pudding with crisp filo       8
Yiaourti Sakoulas home strained yogurt with honey and walnuts       8
Frouta Epohis fresh fruits       7.50

delivery & take out

cold appetizers
Traditional dips. Served With 1/2 pita, 1/2 Regular bread.
Tzatziki yogurt, cucumber, dill and garlic       7
Taramosalata carp mousse       7
Tirokafteri Crete spicy spread with feta cheese, olive oil and red and green peppers       9
Pikilla choose from three dips:tzatziki, melitzanosalata, taramosalata, fava, tirokafteri crete, skordalia       14
Feta Cheese greek feta       7.50
Tomato and Olive Salad       add 2
Melitzanosalata smoked eggplant puree       7
Fava yellow peas puree with olive oil, lemon and chopped onions       7
Skordalia potato, garlic and almond       6
Dolmadakia homemade grape leaves stuffed with rice and fine herbs       8
Shrimp Cocktail jumbo shrimp, served with tomato cocktail sauce       16
hot appetizers
Served With Half pita, Half Regular bread.
Melitzana Santorini stuffed baby eggplant with sauteed vegetables, herbs and feta cheese       9
Kalamarakia baby squid, pan-fried       10.50
Bakaliaro Scordalia crispy pan-fried salted codfish served with garlic spread       13
Glikadakia sweetbread sautéed in white wine sauce       12
Keftedakia seasoned meatballs, lightly broiled       9.50
Scallops broiled in olive oil, paprika and black pepper       10.50
Tiganites Piperyes green peppers stuffed with three kinds of cheese, drizzled with olive oil and vinegar       9
Gigantes Fournou giant beans baked with tomatoes, carrots and celery       9
Oktapodi Scharas charcoal grilled octopus with greek seasoning       13
Garides Saganaki seared and baked butterfly shrimp with feta, herbs and tomato       13
Loukaniko Sparta homemade chargrilled greek sausage with orange zest, fresh herbs and spice       9
Media Krasata mussels sautéed in white wine sauce       13
Ortykia quail, marinated in red wine and herbs, grilled, served on arugula       10.50
Saganaki kefalograviera lightly fried with butter and lemon or flambé       11
Flambéed       add 1
Spanakotiropita homemade spinach pie with feta cheese and dill       7.50
soup
Served With Half pita, Half Regular bread.
Soup Imeras soup of the day       6.50
Kotosoupa Avgolemono chicken, egg and lemon soup with vegetables and rice       7
salad
Served With Half pita, Half Regular bread.
Horiatiki (country) romaine lettuce, feta cheese, olives, tomatoes, cucumber, onions and green peppers with ithaka dressing     sm 9.50   lg 12.50
Grilled Chicken       add 5
Extra Feta Cheese       add 2
Maroulosalata thinly chopped romaine lettuce, scallions and dill with extra virgin olive oil       9.50
Ithaka's Salad arugula, watercress, radicchio, avocado and olives with ithaka dressing     sm 9.50   lg 12.50
Salata Apo Thalasina salad with shrimp, scallops, calamari, arugula, watercress, radicchio, avocado, tomatoes and olives       24
from the sea
Kakavia rich seafood and fish broth thickened with root vegetables and garnished with shrimp, scallops and sea bass       24
Garides Grecolimano jumbo shrimp, baked in a clay pot with fresh tomato, garlic, a splash of ouzo and topped with melted cheese. served with rice       24
Thalasino Youvetsi shrimp, scallops, calamari and mussels with orzo pasta, fresh tomato sauce and feta cheese. please allow 25 mins       28
Solomos Scharas charbroiled salmon steak. served with rice, roast lemon potato and veggies       23
Psari Piaki red snapper baked with feta cheese, fresh tomato sauce, fresh herbs, onions and garlic       23
Daily Seafood Pasta shrimp and sea scallops in a fresh tomato sauce       26
Garides Sta Karvouna chargrilled, marinated shrimp with lemon and virgin olive oil. served with rice, roast lemon potato and veggies       24
Souvlaki Apo Thalassina broiled shrimp and scallops with tomato, green peppers and onions. served with rice, roast lemon potato and veggies       24
Kalamari Scharas whole marinated calamari, charbroiled with lemon and olive oil. served with rice, roast lemon potato and veggies       22
Psari Tis Imeras choice of fish served with rice, roast lemon potato and veggies      
Bronzini or Red Snapper       32
Dorado or Stripe Bass       29
entrees
Mousaka layers of eggplant, potatoes, chopped lamb and beef, topped with bechamel. served with rice, roasted lemon potato and veggies       20
Kapamas boneless lamb simmered in fresh tomato sauce. served with rice       23
Lago Stifado rabbit stew with pearl onions, red wine and tomato sauce. served with rice       24
Kotopoulo Souviaki marinated chicken with tomatoes, green peppers and onions. served with rice, roasted lemon potato and veggies       19
Brizola Moscharisa rib steak (20oz.), charcoal grilled. served with rice, roast lemon potato and veggies       33
Keftedakia four large seasoned meatballs, lightly broiled. served with rice, roast lemon potato and veggies       18
Pasticio pasta layers with chopped lamb and beef meat, topped with bechamel. served with rice, roasted lemon potato and veggies       19
Arni Youvetsi baby lamb baked in a clay pot with orzo pasta, fresh tomato sauce and feta cheese. (please allow 25 mins)       26
Arni Souviaki marinated cubes of tender lamb with tomatoes, green peppers and onions       22
Paidakia Arnisa charcoal grilled lamb chops (4) with greek seasoning served with rice, vegetable, and roast lemon potato       34
Full Rack of Lamb       34
Koto Sta Karvouna grilled whole boneless chicken marinated in white wine, lemon and oregano. served with rice, roast lemon potato and veggies       22
Chef's Vegetarian Plate spinach pie, 3 cheese stuffed pepper, giant lima beans, eggplant appetizer dish, veggies and roast lemon potato       19
sides
Horta steamed wild greens in lemon and extra virgin olive oil       7
Oregano Pan Fries       6
Broccoli       5
Rice       5
Feta Cheese       5
Patzaria beets and garlic spread       7
Spanaki sauteed spinach       6
Sauteed Asparagus       5
Roast Lemon Potato       5
Extra Pita       1
desserts
Loukoumades round donuts with honey and crushed walnuts       7.50
Revani sponge almond cake       8
Yiaourti strained yogurt with honey and crushed walnuts       8
Baklava fillo dough pastry with chopped nuts and honey       7.50
Galaktoboureko layers of fillo dough with milk custard       8
beverages
Ioli 1 liter of imported greek water       6
Ioli selection: Regular Ioli, Sparkling ioli      
Soda soda selection: coke, diet coke, sprite, ginger ale, club soda       3
Advertising