New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > The Mermaid Inn

The Mermaid Inn Menu

raw bar
Selection of East and West and Coast Oysters      
Littleneck Clams       (6) 10
Classic Shrimp Cocktail       13
Chilled 1/2 Lobster      
Baby Grand Platter 6 oysters, 6 clams, tuna crudo       29
Grand Platter 12 oysters, 6 clams, tuna crudo, shrimp cocktail, chilled 1/2 lobster       65
Tuna Crudo jalapeño, avocado, lime & sea salt       12
appetizer
Mermaid Chopped Salad maytag blue cheese & apple smoked bacon       11
Fried Naked Cowboy Oysters cucumber, carrot, jicama & scallion       13
Crispy Rock Shrimp Buffalo Style pickled celery, carrots & hot sauce       12
Lobster Knuckle "escargot" grilled country bread, parsley & garlic butter       14
Cast Iron Jumbo Prawns bagna cauda & bread crumbs       15
Grilled Romaine Salad white anchovies, capers, shaved parmesan, lemon dressing       10
Seared Calamari cremini, shiitake, frisée, feta       12
Steamed Mussels red curry broth, escarole & smoked bacon       12
entrees
Roasted Local Skate spring peas, organic baby carrots & carrot purée       23
Blackened Catfish hush puppies, collard greens, & crawfish butter       22
Pan Seared Idaho Trout fava beans, beach mushrooms & guanciale       24
Spaghetti With Salad on Top seafood fra'diavolo, garlic bread       24
Mermaid Fish Tacos marinated red cabbage, pickled jalapeño & pico de gallo       21
Lobster Sandwich griddled bun, old bay fries       26
Grilled Whole Market Fish extra virgin olive oil, sea salt, and lemon      
Double Pork Chop escarole & mustard maple glaze       24
sides
Grilled Asparagus pecorino cheese       8
Old Bay Fries       6
Hush Puppies       8
Fried Brussel Sprouts bacon & marcona almonds       7
Shishito Peppers lemon & sea salt       8
Mac & Cheese       8

happy hour & a half

raw bar
East Coast Oyster       1
West Coast Oyster       1.75
Littleneck Clams       1
snack
Fried Calamari       7
Mini Fish Taco blackened tilapia, avocado, smoked jalapeño       ea 3
Classic Slider plum tomatoes, shredded lettuce       ea 7
Shrimp & Avocado Slider       ea 7
Shrimp Corndogs creole mustard, coleslaw       ea 3
Shishito Peppers sea salt, lemon       8
beverage
Aperol Spritz prosecco, aperol, orange twist       7
Tommy Collins bulldog gin, q tonic, cucumber, lime       7
Old Bay Bloody Mary hangar one, old bay spiced bloody mary mix       7
Dark and Stormier gosling's rum, domaine de canton, ginger beer       7
Chilly Margaret milagro tequila, cointreau, fresh lime, jalapeño sugar       7
Red, white, and rosé Wine Selection by the Glass       6
Porkslap Pale Ale       5
lobsterpalooza
Every Sunday a pound and 1/4 lobster with opening acts from grilled corn on the cob and red bliss potatoes       24
beer by the bottle
Blue Point Toasted Lager crisp and clean with a balanced bitterness (patchogue, ny)       7
Harpoon Ufo Hefeweizen golden wheat ale, light body and lively citrus (boston, ma)       7
Stone I.p.a lively hops with lemon and spice (escondido, ca)       7
Left Hand Milk Stout creamy and mildly sweet with coffee and chocolate (longmount, co)       6
Founder's Red Rye lemony hops blended with caramel malt (grand rapids, mi)       7
Mad River Steelhead Extra Pale Ale spicy floral hops with a crisp citrus finish (blue lake, ca)       6
Narragansett Lager 16oz Can refreshing lager, mildly sweet and grainy (providence, ri)       5
beer on tap $7
Pacifico Pilsner light, crisp and refreshing      
Old Speckled Hen Ale old speckled hen ale      
cocktails
Aperol Spritz prosecco, aperol, orange twist       11
The Gotham michter's rye, campari, carpano antica       12
Tommy Collins bulldog gin, q tonic, cucumber, lime       11
Dark and Stormier gosling's rum, domaine de canton, ginger beer       11
Chilly Margaret milagro tequila, cointreau, fresh lime, jalapeno sugar       11
Corpse Reviver bombay sapphire gin, lillet blanc, cointreau, pernod       11
Old Bay Bloody hangar one, old bay spiced mary mix, skewered shrimp       12
Old Fashioned Ron ron zacapa rum, hella citrus bitters       11
French Grandma chambord, pineapple, grand marnier, ketel one       11

wines by the glass

sparkling
Cava Brut 2009 "kila" Vinos el Cep (penedes)       9
Prosecco Nv venegazzu (veneto)       11
whites
Ugni Blanc 2010, Domaine de Pouy cotes des gasgogne       9
Rioja Blanco 2010 mencos (rioja)       10
Pinot Gris 2009, Cristom willamette       12
Chardonnay 2010 ind. producers (washington)       11
rosé
Grenache 2010 terminus (rhone)      
reds
Pinot Noir 2010 lockhart (napa)       10
Cotes Du Rhone 2010 vignerons estezargues (france)       9
Malbec 2009, Durigutti mendoza       11
Advertising