New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Miss Lily’s Favourite Cake

Miss Lily’s Favourite Cake Menu

  • 132 W. Houston St., New York, NY Choose... 40.727741 -74.001325
    nr. Sullivan St.  See Map | Subway Directions Hopstop Popup
  • 646-588-5375

bake shop

sandwiches & roti
Jerk Hot Dog beef       6
Jerk Chicken Sandwich       9
Grilled Fish Sandwich       10
Curry Chicken Roti       9
Jerk Chicken Roti       10
Vegetable Roti       9
salads
Jerk Chicken Salad       11
Mixed Green Salad       7
Grilled Fish Salad       12
organic vegan raw $8
Mushroom Salad      
Quinoa Salad      
Vegan Salad      
caribbean classics
Jerk Chicken served with rice & peas       14
Oxtail served with rice & peas       15
Curried Goat with white rice       16
Curried Chicken with white rice       13
Grilled Jerk Corn       5
famous patties
Beef       4
Curried Chicken       4
Callaloo & Potato       4
Coco-bread       3
sides
Rice & peas, Quinoa       4
Brown/white rice, Plantains       3
Callaloo       6
dessert $6
Banana Pudding      
Cake of the Day      
beverages
Ting/pink ting, Ginger Beer       4
Hildon water, Pepsi Cola       3
Poland Spring       1.50
Fresh Organic Coconut Water       6
coffee
Jamaican Blue mtn. Blend     2.15   2.60
Espresso       2.50
Americano       2.75
Cappuccino       3.50
Latte       2.50
Iced Coffee       2.75
Organic Tea       2.50
Hot Chocolate       2.50

dinner

Monday-saturday: 5:00pm-1:30am, Sunday 5:00pm-11:30pm

appetizers
Half Dozen Oysters hellshire mignonette sauce       18
Fish Soup       8
Jerk Grilled Corn with toasted coconut       5
Ackee Dip and Plantain Chips       10
Cod Fish Fritters curry dipping sauce       9
Middle Quarters Pepper Shrimp peel and eat       10
Grilled Pork Ribs       14
Ceviche fluke, scotch bonnet, avocado       14
Smoked Mackerel Salad avocado, pickled red onion, citrus       14
Organic Greens balsamic vinaigrette, cucumber, mango       9
Jaquitos (three jamaican style mini tacos, choose one). ackee & saltfish, callaloo & plantain. jerk chicken & avocado, curried lobster       9
entrees
Curry Vegetable Roti       16
Vegan Bushman Plate jerk seitan, quinoa, stir fry vegetables, callaloo       19
Grilled Lobster garlic butter, grilled corn, organic greens       32
Steamed Fish fillet of branzino with okra, peppers, carrots       25
Hellshire Style Fried Whole Snapper boneless with escoveitch vegetables       29
Mussels Linguini with jerk, cilantro, parsley       18
Curry Goat pasture raised goat, jamaican curry, irish potatoes       23
Jerk Chicken slow cooked and grilled, marinated cucumber salad       19
Jerk Pork Burger red onion, avocado, mango chutney       15
Oxtail Stew natural gravy, broad beans       21
sides $5
Plantains      
Festivals      
Rice and Peas      
Potato Salad      
Callaloo*      
desserts $8
Favorite Cake of the Day      
Mango Mousse with mixed berries      
Seasonal Fruit Plate      
Banana Cream Pudding      
Guinness Float      
Ice Cream guinness, grape nut, rum raisin      
beverages
Sodas       3
Fresh Lemonade       5
Sorrel       6
Coconut Water       5
Ting / Pink Ting       4
Ginger Beer       4
Coffee / Tea       3
Espresso       3
Cappuccino / Latte       4

brunch

Saturday and Sunday 11:00am-4:30pm

Jamaican Breakfast ackee and saltfish, sautéed callaloo, fruit, festivals and ripe plantains       18
Buttermilk Pancakes served with warm maple syrup       10
Coconut Pancakes shaved coconut and warm maple syrup       12
Brioche French Toast with bananas foster topping       12
&Quot;bare naked" Granola and Organic Yogurt served with fresh seasonal fruit       11
eggs
Jerk Pork Belly Hash served with 2 fried eggs       13
Egg White Omelette callaloo, baked tomato, sliced avocado       12
Jamaican Rancheros over easy eggs, plantains, stew peas, scotch bonnet       12
Smoked Mackerel Scramble with roasted potatoes and green salad       12
2 Eggs Any Style with roasted potatoes and green salad       10
sandwiches and salads
Jerk Pork Burger red onion, avocado, mango chutney       13
Grilled Fish Sandwich shredded lettuce, escoveitch tartar sauce       12
Curry Lobster Roll toasted potato bun, organic greens       18
Jerk Chicken Salad organic greens, mango vinaigrette       14
Organic Green Salad mango, cucumber and citrus vinaigrette       9
sides
Grilled Jerk Corn       5
Jerk Chicken Sausage       7
Festivals       5
Callaloo       7
Roasted Potatoes       5
Country Bacon       5
Seasonal Fruit Bowl       8

juice box

shakes
Strawberry Riddim apple, banana, strawberry       8
Midnight apple, blueberry, banana, spirulina, lecithin       8
Coral Reef coconut milk & jelly       8
Caribbean Coco coconut with 2-choices of fruits: strawberry, blueberry, pineapple or banana       9
Tropical Storm coconut with 2-choices of fruits: strawberry, blueberry, pineapple or banana, and wheat grass       10
Harry Fontabella rice milk, banana, blueberry or strawberry, granola       8
Cococado coconut, avocado, lecithin       9
Rootsman coconut, kale, banana       9
Reggae Gold carrot, coconut       9
protein shakes $10
Give ‘em a Run banana, blueberry or strawberry, protein powder, spirulina, lecithin      
Peanut Butter & Jelly blueberry or strawberry, banana, protein powder, lecithin, spirulina, granola, organic peanut      
Coco-fuel coconut with 2-choices of fruits: strawberry, blueberry, pineapple or banana, and protein powder      
fresh juices
Green Light kale, celery, collard greens, green chard, parsley, lemon, ginger       9
The Real V-8 kale, collard greens, cabbage, red onion, rep pepper, tomato, lemon, ginger, garlic, apple cider vinegar, cayenne pepper       9
Jamaican Green kale, apple, lemon, ginger, celery       9
Body Good kale, collard greens, green chard, celery, apple, lemon, ginger       9
Sweet & Dandy apple, beet, lemon, ginger, carrots, pineapple       8
Catch a Fire apple, beets, lemon, ginger       8
Lightning Bolt Immune Booster apple, beets, ginger, garlic, carrots, vitamin c, spirulina, echinacea, golden seal, b-complex, banana       10
Rise-up wheat grass, pineapple, apple, bee pollen, strawberry, banana       10
simple juice
Apple Juice       (16oz) 7
Orange Juice       (16oz) 7
Grapefruit Juice       (16oz) 7
Fresh Coconut       6
legalize it
Wheat Grass       (1oz) 2.50
Wheat Grass With ginger, garlic, Cayenne pepper, Lemon       (2oz) 3.50
Ginger Shot apple, cayenne pepper, ginger       3
Advertising