• Critics’ Pick
  • Nick & Toni's

  • American Nouveau Italian $23-$42
  • 136 N. Main St.
    East Hampton, NY 11937
  • Neighborhood: Long Island
  • Phone: 631-324-3550
As you crane your neck in the small dining room to catch a glimpse of Spielberg, Lohan, or a stray Baldwin brother, the aromas from the wood-fired oven in the partially open kitchen afford a preview of the real attraction: a hearty Mediterranean/Tuscan menu that makes good use of Long Island's farms and waters. Local ingredients are more than a boast here, whether you're considering the small selection of pizzas or a bottle from the stellar wine list. This is still the house that Jeff Salaway built (the owner died in a car accident a few years ago and a memorial collage sits propped near the hostess’ stand) and the spot has seen every famous part- and full-time Hamptonite you can think of. One bite and you’ll know why. Nick & Toni's is haute without being haughty. Folk art and children’s drawings relate simple pleasures to a less-than-simple clientele.
  • Hours

    Oct-Apr: Wed-Sun, 6pm-10pm Mon-Tue, closed May-Sep: Daily, 6pm-10pm

  • Prices


  • Payment

    American Express MasterCard Visa

  • Special Features

    Dine at the Bar Open Kitchens / Watch the Chef Hot Spot Outdoor Dining Kid-Friendly Online Reservation

  • Alcohol

    Full Bar

  • Reservations


Avg. Rating 0

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • E-mail
  • Save to foursquare
See the Full NYMag Site »