New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Nick's Pizza

Nick's Pizza Menu

  • Takeout Available | Delivery Available
  • Delivery Payment:
    $15 minimum
  • Delivery Hours:
    Daily, 11:30am-10:30pm
  • Delivery Area:
    80th St. to 102nd St., First Ave. to Fifth Ave.

dine in

macaroni
Sgl / Fam
Manicotti     12   18
Spaghetti & Meatballs     14   20
Penne Vodka w/ prosciutto & onions     14   20
Rigatoni Tomato & Basil     10   15
Spaghetti Marinara or fra diavolo     12   18
Fettucini Alfredo     12   18
Fettucini Prosciutto     14   20
Penne "meat sauce" w/ peas     14   20
Spaghetti & Broccoli     12   18
Orecchiette "rabe" & Sausage     15   22
Bowtie Shrimp & Asparagus     16   24
Spaghetti w/ shrimp marinara     16   24
Linguine White or Red Clam Sauce     15   22
Linguine Shrimp "zi peppe"     16   24
&Quot;seafood linguine"     19   28
Linguine w/ mussels (red or white)     14   20
Spaghetti Garlic & Oil     10   15
Add Anchovies & Capers       2
Lasagna     15   22
mains
Sgl / Fam
Chicken Lemon & Butter     14   20
Chicken Francese     14   20
Chicken Marsala     14   20
Chicken Parmesan     15   22
Chicken Pizzaiola w/ mushrooms & peppers     15   22
Chicken Milanese     16   24
Chicken "in-the-oven" w/ eggplant or broccoli     16   24
Veal Lemon & Butter     16   24
Veal Francese     16   24
Veal Marsala     16   24
Veal Parmesan     19   28
Veal Pizzaiola w/ mushrooms & peppers     16   24
Veal Milanese     19   28
Veal "in-the-oven" w/ eggplant or broccoli     18   26
Filet of Sole served oreganato, francese, or livornese w/ mussels       sgl 18
Salmon       sgl 18
Shrimp Oreganato       sgl 18
Scallops Seared       sgl 20
sides $8
Asparagus      
Broccoli Rabe      
Spinach      
Roasted Potatoes      
Sauteed Mushrooms      
Broccoli      
Sausage      
Meatballs      
appetizers
Sgl / Fam
Baked Clams     10   20
Shrimp Marinara     11   22
Shrimp "zi pepe"     11   22
Mussels Red or White     9   18
Fried Calamari     9   18
Scallops Seared     10   20
Josephine’s Eggplant     8   16
Mozzarella & Tomato     9   18
Cold Antipasto     10   20
Peppers & Onion     9   18
Stuffed Mushrooms     8   16
Stuffed Artichoke       sgl 12
salads
Sgl / Fam
Mixed Greens     7   10
House     7.50   11
Caesar     8   12
&Quot;the Frankie portobello"     11   16
Warm Spinach     11   16
&Quot;5 leaf"     9   13
pies & calzones
Sm / Lg
Pie Round     14   17
White Pie Round     15   18
Calzone     8   17
pizza toppings
On the Half or Whole $2.50. Calzone Stuffings Lg $2.50 / Sm $1.25
Mushrooms      
Peppers       3
Broccoli      
Eggplant      
Onions      
Meatballs      
Olives      
Chopped Tomatoes      
Sausage      
Prosciutto       3.50
Extra Cheese      
Spinach      
Chicken       3.50
Pepperoni      
Anchovies      
Sun-dried Tomatoes      
beverages
Saranac 1888 Root Beer       3.50
Saranac 1888 Shirley Temple       3
Apple Juice       2
Milk       2
Bottled Water Carbonated       6.75
Bottled Water Flat       6.75
Coffee       1.75
Tea       1.75
Cappuccino       3.75
Iced Cappuccino       4
Espresso       2.50
Double Espresso       5
soda $2
Kid Soda $1.75
Pepsi      
Diet Pepsi      
Orange      
Sprite      
Ginger Ale      
Lemonade      
Raspberry Iced Tea      
Unsweetened Iced Tea      
Club Soda      
desserts
Cannoli       7
Tiramisu       7
Brownie       5
Cheese Cake       6
Chocolate Cake       6
Tartufo       7
Sorbett various       6
Gelato Cup       3.50
beer - draught $5.50
Amstel Light      
Moretti      
Stalla Artois      
Brooklyn Lager      
beer - bottled
Budweiser       5
Blue Moon       6.50
Coors Light       5.50
Rolling Rock       5.50
Sam Adams       6.50
Corona       6
Peroni       6.50
Heineken       6.50
Heineken Light       6.50
Beck's Dark       6.50

wine by the glass

red
Special House Red served chilled       4.50
&Quot;baby amarone", Campofiorin "ripasso" Masi-italy       9
Cabernet sauvignon, beringer, Stone Cellars-ca       5.75
Cabernet sauvignon, Mirassou-ca       7
Chianti, Gabbiano-italy       5.75
Chianti, classico, Cecchi-italy       8.50
Merlot, penfolds, Rawson's Retreat Australlia       6.50
Merlot, beringer, Stone Cellars-ca       5.75
Monteoykcuabi d' abruzzo, Bove-italy       6.25
Nero D'avola Carvo Sicily       6.75
Pinot noir, Matua-new Zealand       8.50
Shiraz Cabernet Rosemount Australia       7.50
Zinfandel, Fetzer Valley Oaks-ca       7
Valpolicella, Bolla-italy       6.25
white
Special House Wine       4.50
Chardonnay, beringer, Stone Cellars-ca       5.75
Chardonnay, Hess-ca       9.25
Insolia, Corvo Sicily       5.75
Pinot grigio, beringer, Stone Cellars-ca       5.75
Pinot grigio, Campanile-italy       7.50
Sauvignon black, Matua - New Zealand       8
Reisling, Jekel Vineyards - Ca       7.25
Frascati, Fontana Candida - Italy       6.75
White zinfandel, Bel Arbors - Ca       5.50

lunch

macaroni
Manicotti       12
Spaghetti & Meatballs       10
Penne Vodka w/ prosciutto & onions       10
Rigatoni Tomato & Basil       8
Spaghetti Marinara or fra diavolo       9
Fettucini Alfredo       9
Fettucini Prosciutto       10
Penne "meat sauce" with peas       10
Spaghetti & Broccoli       9
Lasagna       11
Orecchiette "rabe"       11
Browtie shirmp, Asparagus & Tomato       1
Spaghetti with shrimp marinara       12
Linguine White or Red Clam Sauce       11
Linguine Shrimp "zi peppe"       12
Seafood Linguine       14
Linguine with mussels, red or white       10
Spaghetti Garlic & Oil       8
Add Anchovies & Capers       1
mains
Chicken Lemon & Butter       10
Chicken Francese       10
Chicken Marsala       10
Chicken Parmesan       1
Chicken Pizzaiola with mushrooms & peppers       11
Chicken Malanese       12
Chicken in the Over with eggplant or broccoli       12
Veal Lemon & Butter       12
Veal Francese       12
Veal Marsala       12
Veal Parmesan       14
Veal Pizzaiola with mushrooms & peppers       12
Veal Milanese       14
Veal in the Over with eggplant or broccoli       13
Filet of Sole served oreganato, francese, or livornese with mussels       12
appetizers
Baked Clams       10
Shrimp Marinara       11
Shrimp "zi pepe"       11
Mussels Red or White       9
Fried Calamari       9
Josephine’s Eggplant       8
Mozzarella & Tomato       9
Cold Antipasto       10
Peppers & Onions       9
Stuffed Mushrooms       8
Stuffed Artichoke       12
salads
Mixed Greens       5
House       6
Caesar       6
&Quot;the Frankie portobello"       8
Warm Spinach       8
&Quot;5 leaf"       7
sandwiches
Meatball Parm       7
Grilled Chicken w/ peppers & mozz       9
Chicken Cutlet w/ peppers & mozz       9
Prosciutto, Tomato w/ fresh mozzarella       9
Fried Eggplant w/ peppers & mozz       9
Chicken Parm       8
pies & calzones
Sm / Lg
Pie     14   17
White Pie     15   18
Calzone     8   17
pizza toppings
On the Half or Whole $2.50. Calzone Stuffings Lg $2.50 / Sm $1.25
Mushrooms      
Peppers       3.50
Broccoli      
Eggplant      
Onions      
Meatballs      
Olives      
Chopped Tomatoe      
Sausage      
Prosciutto       3.50
Extra Cheese      
Chicken       3.50
Pepperoni      
Anchovies      
Sun-dried Tomatoes      
Spinach      

takeout

appetizers
Half / Family
Baked Clams     10   20
Shrimp Marinara     11   22
Shrimp "zi pepe"     11   22
Mussels Red or White     9   18
Fried Calamari     9   18
Scallops Seared     10   20
Josephine’s Eggplant     8   16
Mozzarella & Tomato     9   18
Cold Antipasto     10   20
Peppers & Onions     9   18
Stuffed Mushrooms     8   16
Stuffed Artichoke       12
salads
Mixed Greens       10
House       11
Caesar       12
&Quot;the Frankie portobello"       16
Warm Spinach       16
&Quot;5 leaf"       13
salad add ons
Chicken       4
Shrimp       6
Shaved Parm       3
pies & calzones
Large Pie       17
Large White Pie       18
Small Pie       14
Small White Pie       15
Large Calzone       17
Small Calzone       8
pizza toppings
On the Half or Whole $2.50. Calzone stuffings: Lg $2.50 / Sm $1.25
Mushrooms      
Peppers       3.50
Broccoli      
Eggplant      
Sausage      
Prosciutto       3.50
Extra Cheese      
Spinach      
Chicken       3.50
Onions      
Meatballs      
Olives      
Chopped Tomatoes      
Pepperoni      
Anchovies      
Sun-dried      
Tomatoes      
sandwiches
Available For Lunch Only
Meatball Parm       7
Grilled Chicken with peppers & mozz       9
Chicken Cutlet with peppers & mozz       9
Prosciutto, tomato, Fresh Mozzarella       9
Fried Eggplant with peppers & mozz       9
Chicken Parm       8
macaroni
Half / Family
Manicotti     12   18
Spaghetti & Meatballs     10   20
Penne Vodka     10   20
Rigatoni Tomato & Basil     8   15
Spaghetti Marinara     9   18
Fettucini Alfredo     9   18
Fettucini Prosciutto     10   20
Penne "meat sauce" with peas     10   20
Spaghetti & Broccoli     9   18
Orecchiette "rabe" & Sausage     11   22
Bowtie Shrimp & Asparagus     12   24
Spaghetti with shrimp marinara     12   24
Linguine White or Red Clam Sauce     11   22
Linguine Shrimp "zi peppe"     12   24
&Quot;seafood linguine"     14   28
Linguine with mussels (red or white)     10   20
Spaghetti Garlic & Oil     8   15
Lasagna     11   22
sides $8
Asparagus      
Broccoli Rabe      
Spinach      
Roasted Potatoes      
Sauteed Mushrooms      
Broccoli      
Sausage      
Meatballs      
mains
Half / Family
Chicken Lemon & Butter     10   20
Chicken Francese     10   20
Chicken Marsala     10   20
Chicken Parmesan     11   22
Chicken Pizzaiola with mushrooms & peppers     11   22
Chicken Milanese     12   24
Chicken "in-the-oven" with eggplant or broccoli     12   24
Veal Lemon & Butter     12   24
Veal Francese     12   24
Veal Marsala     12   24
Veal Parmesan     14   28
Veal Pizzaiola with mushrooms & peppers     12   24
Veal Milanese     14   28
Veal "in-the-oven" with eggplant or broccoli     13   26
Filet of Sole served oreganato, francese, or livornese with mussels       18
Salmon       18
Shrimp Oreganato       18
Scallops Seared       18
drinks $1.50
Pepsi      
Diet Pepsi      
Sprite      
Ginger Ale      
Club Soda      
Bottled Water      
desserts
Cannoli       7
Brownie       5
Tiramisu       7
Cheese Cake       6
Chocolate Cake       6
Advertising