• Critics’ Pick
  • Patsy’s Pizzeria

  • Pizza Italian $15-$25
  • 2287 First Ave.
    New York, NY 10035
  • Neighborhood: Spanish Harlem
  • Phone: 212-534-9783
This is where you’ll find the city’s only coal-oven pizza sold by the slice, and for pizza scholars, that alone is reason enough to leg it up to the original Patsy’s in East Harlem. To make the most of the experience, the thing to do is to consider this genre-defining slab, with its cooked-in aged-mozzarella-and-tomato topping, as a sort of amuse-bouche. Enjoy it in the dimly lit takeout storefront by the ancient oven before repairing to the red-sauce dining room next door. (Like Ralph Lauren has acquired a sizable chunk of Madison Avenue, Patsy’s has, over the years, gobbled up a series of adjacent storefronts, bringing the Patsy’s lifestyle brand to a wider audience.) Here, under the incongruous gaze of a leaping marlin, you can tuck into an even better whole pie made with fresh mozzarella. It’s a well-cooked, exceptionally thin-crusted pizza, perfumed with the heady scent of 75 years of bituminous-coal-oven cookery.

Feature Links

  • Hours

    Mon-Sat, 11am-midnight Sun, 11am-11pm

  • Prices


  • Payment

    Cash Only

  • Special Features

    Lunch Take-Out Classic NY

  • Alcohol

    Full Bar

  • Reservations

    Not Accepted

Avg. Rating 0

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • E-mail
  • Save to foursquare
See the Full NYMag Site »