New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Paul & Jimmy's

Paul & Jimmy's Menu

  • Takeout Available | Delivery Available
  • Delivery Payment:
    $25 minimum
  • Delivery Hours:
    Sun-Mon, noon-10pm; Tue-Thu, noon-11pm; Fri-Sat, noon-midnight
  • Delivery Area:
    14th St. to 23rd St., Second Ave. to Fifth Ave.

lunch

antipasti
Funghi Ripieni stuffed mushroom caps       8
Mozzarella, Pomodori E Peperoni Rossi fresh mozzarella, tomato and roasted sweet red peppers       8
Prosciutto E Melone imported italian ham with melon       8
Frutti di Mare assorted seafood marinated in olive oil, garlic, fresh herbs and lemon       10
Cocktail di Gamberi steamed shrimp served with cocktail sauce       10
Antipasto Caldo assorted hot appetizers       11
Vongole Arreganate baked clams with seasoned bread crumbs       9
Vongole Posillipo clams in marinara sauce       9
Spiedini Alla Romana baked mozzarella and bread topped with anchovy sauce       9
Calamari Fritti fried squid       10
Melanzane Rollatini rolled eggplant stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella cheese and baked in tomato sauce       10
Melanzane Alla Parmigiana eggplant parmagiana       10
insalate
Insalata Mista mixed greens, roasted peppers and tomatoes with olive oil and vinegar dressing       7
Arugula E Pomodori field lettuce and tomatoes wrapped with eggplant, shaved parmesan and tomatoes       8
Insalata Alla Cesare       8
Caesar Salad With Grilled Chicken or Shrimp       12
Insalata Nicosia leaf lettuce with tuna, roasted peppers, olives, green beans and anchovies       10
Pollo con Radicchio chicken breast with radicchio, leaf lettuce, tomatoes in a dijon vinaigrette dressing       10
Tricolore con Balsamico radicchio, arugula and endive with olive oil and balsamic vinegar       8
Insalate di Pera E Gorgonzola mixed greens with sliced pears and walnuts in gorgonzola dressing       10
Bietole E Carciofi salt roasted beets with braised artichokes and toasted walnuts       11
zuppa $7
Minestrone fresh vegetable soup      
Pasta E Fagioli cannellini beans with pasta      
Minestra di Lenticchie lentil soup with pasta      
Stracciatella Alla Fiorentine consommé with egg, spinach and romano cheese      
Tortellini in Brodo meat filled pasta in clear broth      
farinacci
Fettucini Filetto di Pomodoro homemade noodles with onion, proscuitto and plum tomatoes       15
Lasagna Alla Napoletana pasta layered with meat and cheeses and baked in tomato sauce       15
Tortellini Alla Panna meat-filled pasta in a cream sauce with peas       15
Ravioli or Manicotti homemade pasta filled with cheese       15
Cannelloni Alla Fiorentina thin pasta rolled and filled with spinach and veal and topped with beschemel sauce       15
Orecchiette Alla Bares hat-shaped pasta with sausage, peas, mushrooms and sundried tomatoes       15
Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina potato dumplings baked with ricotta cheese and tomato sauce       15
Spaghetti Alla Carbonara pasta in a cream sauce topped with bacon and prosciutto       15
Perciatelli Alla Puttanesca thick spaghetti with capers, olives, garlic, and anchovies in a plum tomato sauce       15
Rigatoni Alla Bolognese tubular pasta in a rich meat sauce       15
Penne Alla Vodka penne in a cream sauce with a touch of vodka and tomato       15
Ziti Alla Vesuvio tubular pasta baked with ricotta and mozzarella in a tomato sauce       15
Linguine Alla Vongole linguine with red or white clam sauce       16
Penne Portofino tubular pasta with shrimp, artichokes and sundried tomatoes       17
piatti principali
Pollo con Balsamico small pieces of chicken sautéed with shallots, vinegar, white wine and lemon       16
Pollo Alla Cacciatore boneless chicken simmered with mushrooms, proscuitto and tomato sauce, served with pasta       17
Pollo Alla Campagnola chicken and sausage sautéed with peppers and mushrooms       17
Vitello Alla Parmigiana veal cutlet topped with mozzarella and tomato sauce, served with pasta       19
Vitello Alla Milanese pan-fried breaded veal cutlet       19
Saltimbocca Alla Romano medallions of veal topped with prosciutto in butter and sage sauce       19
Spiedini Alla Siciliana veal rolled and stuffed with provolone and proscuitto in a garlic, lemon and white wine sauce       19
Scampi al Risotto shrimp broiled with garlic, lemon and butter, served with rice       19
Gamberi Francese batter-fried shrimp sautéed with butter, lemon and white wine       19
Calamari Affogati squid poached in white wine and shallots       18
Filetto di Salmone Alla Griglia grilled salmon       20
Dentice Livornese red snapper poached with white wine, olives, capers, anchovies and tomato       20
legumi
Broccoli o Scarola Saltati broccoli or escarole sautéed in garlic and oil       6
Asparagi Gratinata asparagus baked with romano cheese and butter       7
Broccoli di Rape Affogati bitter broccoli with garlic and oil       8
Piselli al Prosciutto peas sautéed with prosciutto and onion       6
Zucchini Fritti fried zucchini       6

dinner

antipasti
Antipasto Mista assorted cold appetizers       11
Frutti di Mare assorted seafood marinated in olive oil, garlic and lemon       13
Cocktail di Gamberi steamed shrimp served with cocktail sauce       12
Caprese fresh mozzarella and tomato       9
Peperoni Rossi Arrostiti con Accinghe fresh roasted sweet red peppers with anchovies       9
Prosciutto E Melone imported italian ham with melon       10
Zucchini Fritti fried zucchini       8
Carciofi Aglio Olio fresh artichokes sautéed in garlic and oil       11
Antipasto Caldo assorted hot appetizers       13
Funghi Ripieni stuffed mushroom caps       9
Vongole Arreganate baked clams with seasoned bread crumbs       10
Vongole Posillipo clams in a marinara sauce       11
Spiedini Alla Romana baked mozzarella and bread topped with anchovy sauce       11
Calamari Fritti fried squid       12
Scallops al Vino Bianco sea scallops with garlic, wine and lemon       12
Melanzane Rollatini rolled eggplant stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella cheese and baked with tomato sauce       12
Melanzane Alla Parmigiana eggplant parmagiana       12
insalate
Insalata Alla Cesare caesar salad       9
Insalata Mista mixed greens, roasted peppers and tomatoes with olive oil and vinegar dressing       8
Insalata di Portobello grilled portobello mushroom with radicchio, arugula and endive       10
Insalata Speciale leaf lettuce with tomatoes, red peppers, olives, mozzarella, salami and shrimp       10
Tricolore con Balsamico radicchio, arugula and endive with olive oil and balsamic vinegar       9
Insalata di Arugula field lettuce wrapped with eggplant, shaved parmesan and tomatoes       9
Insalata di Pera E Gorgonzola mixed greens with sliced pears and walnuts in gorgonzola dressing       10
zuppa $8
Minestrone fresh vegetable soup      
Pasta E Fagioli cannellini beans with pasta      
Minestra di Lenticchie lentil soup with pasta      
Stracciatella Alla Fiorentine consommé with egg, spinach and romano cheese      
primi piatti
Fettucini Filetto di Pomodoro homemade noodles with onion, pancetta and plum tomatoes       17
Lasagna Alla Napoletana pasta layered with meat and cheese and baked in tomato sauce       18
Tortellini Alla Panna meat-filled pasta in a cream sauce with peas       17
Ravioli or Manicotti homemade pasta filled with cheese       17
Cannelloni Alla Fiorentina thin pasta rolled and filled with spinach and veal and topped with beschemel sauce       18
Orechiette Alla Barese hat-shaped pasta with sausage, peas, mushrooms and sundried tomatoes       17
Gnocchi Alla Sorentina potato dumplings baked with ricotta cheese and tomato sauce       17
Spaghetti Alla Carbonara cream sauce topped with bacon and prosciutto       16
Bucatini Puttanesca thick spaghetti with capers, olives, garlic, and anchovies in tomato sauce       16
Fettuccine Alla Bolognese homemade pasta with meat sauce       16
Penne Alla Vodka penne in a cream sauce with a touch of vodka and tomato       17
Linguine Alla Vongole linguine with red or white clam sauce       17
Penne Portofino tubular pasta with shrimp, artichokes and sundried tomatoes       18
Fusilli Alla Primavera spiral-shaped pasta in a sauce of fresh vegetables       17
Vermicelli con Gamberi thin spaghetti with shrimp in a garlic and tomato sauce       18
pollo $20
Pollo Alla Scarpariello small pieces of chicken sautéed with garlic, vinegar, white wine and lemon      
Petto di Pollo Alla Bolognese boneless chicken breast topped with proscuitto and mozzarella in a marsala sauce      
Pollo Alla Cacciatore chicken simmered with mushrooms, proscuitto and tomato sauce      
Pollo Alla Forno half roasted chicken with fresh herbs      
Petto di Pollo Francese boneless chicken sautéed with prosciutto, lemon, white wine, and butter      
Pollo Alla Campagnola chicken and sausage sautéed with peppers, onions, and mushrooms      
Pollo Alla Toscana boneless chicken topped with fontina cheese in a beschemel and tomato sauce      
vitello
Vitello Alla Capriciosa pan-fried breaded veal cutlet topped with grilled eggplant and chopped salad       22
Vitello Alla Fiorentina veal cutlet sautéed in butter and wine served with spinach       22
Lombata con Portobello veal chop with portobello mushroom, shallots and balsamic vinegar       29
Lombata Arrabiata veal chop with hot cherry peppers, garlic, olive oil and white wine       29
Scallopini a Limone scallops of veal sautéed in lemon and white wine       22
Spiedini Alla Siciliana rolled veal stuffed with provolone and proscuitto in a garlic, lemon and white wine sauce       23
Lombata Mediterraneo veal chop with shallots, white wine, rosemary and tomato sauce       29
Saltimbocca Alla Romano medallions of veal topped with prosciutto in a butter and sage sauce       22
Scallopini Porto con Funghi scallops of veal with shitake mushrooms in a port wine sauce       22
Scallopini Sorrentina scallops of veal baked with eggplant, proscuitto, mozzarella and a dash of tomato sauce       22
Rollatini Marsala E Funghi rolled veal stuffed with mozzarella and prosciutto in a marsala wine and mushroom sauce       23
carne
Bistecca Alla Griglia grilled n.y. strip steak       28
Bistecca Alla Siciliana n.y. strip steak topped with bread crumb seasonings, wine and lemon       29
Bistecca Alla Pizzaiola n.y. strip topped with shitake mushrooms in marinara sauce       29
Salsiccia con Broccoli di Rape cipolle e broccoli di rape sausage sautéed with onions, red peppers, garlic and broccoli rabe       20
Fegato Alla Veneziana calves liver sautéed with onions, white wine and vinegar       22
pesce
Scallops Gratinata sea scallops, peppers and zucchini baked with bread seasonings       22
Scampi al Risotto shrimp broiled with garlic, lemon and butter, served with rice       22
Gamberi Francese batter-fried shrimp sautéed with butter, lemon and white wine       22
Filetto di Sogliola Marechiaro filet of sole poached with garlic, onion, white wine and a dash of tomato       21
Filetto di Salmone con Asparagi salmon with asparagus, sundried tomatoes in a mustard cream sauce       23
Dentice Livornese red snapper poached with white wine, olives, capers, anchovies and tomato       23
Zuppa di Pesce red snapper poached with clams, sole, squid and shrimp in a light tomato sauce       26
Fresh Fish of the Day      
Aragosta Fresche Priced Accordingly fresh lobster, any size or style available with 24 hours notice      
contorni
Spinaci, Broccoli o Scarola Saltati spinach, broccoli or escarole sautéed in garlic and oil       7
Broccoli di Rape Affogato bitter broccoli with garlic and oil       9
Asparagi Gratinata asparagus baked with cheese and butter       8
Piselli al Prosciutto peas sautéed with prosciutto and onion       7

prix-fixe

Served Daily From 12:00-3:00 $20 Per Person / Served Daily From 4:00-6:30 $28 Per Person

appetizer
Choice of One
Funghi Ripieni stuffed mushroom caps      
Melanzane Rollatini rolled eggplant stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella cheese and baked with tomato sauce      
Peperoni Rossi Arrostiti con Mozzarella fresh roasted sweet red peppers with mozzarella      
Vongole Arreganate baked clams with seasoned bread crumbs      
Insalata Mista mixed greens, roasted peppers and tomatoes with olive oil and vinegar dressing      
Minestrone fresh vegetable soup      
entrée
Choice of One
Fusilli Alla Primavera spiral-shaped pasta in a sauce of fresh vegetables      
Vitello Alla Fiorentina veal cutlet sautéed in butter and wine served with spinach      
Scallopini Pizzaiola scallops of veal sautéed in garlic, mushrooms, white wine and tomato sauce      
Pollo Alla Scarpariello small pieces of chicken sautéed with garlic, vinegar, white wine and lemon      
Petto di Pollo Francese boneless chicken breast sautéed with prosciutto, lemon, white wine and butter      
Filetto di Sogliola Marechiara filet of sole poached with garlic, onion, white wine and a dash of tomato      
Vermicelli con Gamberi thin spaghetti with shrimp in a garlic and tomato sauce      
Pesce Alla Griglia broiled fish      
dessert
Choice of One
Torta di Ricotta creamy italian cheese cake      
Zuppa Inglese rum cake      
Cannoli italian pastry shell filled with cream      
Spumoni vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream      
Tortoni vanilla ice cream topped with crushed almonds      
Melon in season      
Advertising