New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Peanut Butter & Co.

Menus provided by Menupages

Peanut Butter & Co. Menu

  • Takeout Available | Delivery Available
  • Delivery Payment:
    $12 minimum
  • Delivery Hours:
    Daily, 11am-7pm
  • Delivery Area:
    Spring St. to 14th St., Lafayette St. to Varick St.

classic peanut butter sandwiches
Lunchbox Special our all natural peanut butter, spread thick over a layer of strawberry or grape jam, for something different, try it with raspberry or apricot preserves       5
Fluffernutter remember this recipe, peanut butter on one side and gobs of marshmallow fluff spread on the other it's heaven       5.75
Peanut Butter Cup peanut butter, kissed by a chocolate layer of nutella, who hasn't craved this one before       6.25
The Elvis a grilled peanut butter sandwich, stuffed with bananas and honey, try it with bacon for that extra indulgence long live the king       7.50
Add       1
Cookie Dough Surprise peanut butter on one side and velvety vanilla cream cheese on the other, stuffed with chocolate chips, it really does taste like cookie dough       6.75
Peanut Butter Blt we use toasted bread and fresh cut bacon to give this sandwich great flavor and texture       7
Black & Tan peanut butter on toast, drizzled with chocolate syrup cheers       5.75
Pb&j Club double your pleasure and enjoy two layers of peanut butter and two layers of jelly between three slices of toasted bread       6.75
Pregnant Lady peanut butter & pickles you bet a strange sounding but great tasting combination better watch out though this sandwich has been known to induce labor       6.25
Bagel Nosh a toasted bagel and sides of smooth or crunch peanut butter, jam and vanilla cream cheese for you to schmear       6.50
Jerry Seinfeld's Comedy Special our most famous customer shared his favorite peanut butter sandwich in the foreword the wrote for the peanut butter & co cookbook, and here it is for you to try a sliced toasted bagel topped with peanut butter, drizzled with honey and sprinkled with cinnamon yum       6.50
Ants on a Log * memories of kindergarten will come flooding back as you munch on freshly cut celery sticks, stuffed with smooth or crunchy peanut butter and topped with raisins       4.50
gourmet peanut butter sandwiches
The Heat Is on Sandwich spicy peanut butter and chilled grilled chicken, with a little blt of pineapple jam, like a thai satay only butter       7.25
Cinnamon Raisin swirl, Sandwich cinnamon raisin peanut butter and vanilla cream cheese, stuffed with crisp apples slices crunchy       6.75
White Chocolate Wonderful Sandwich white chocolate peanut butter and orange marmalade with a crunchy layer of thinly sliced almonds it's like a peanutty creamsicle ooh la la       6.75
Dark Chocolate Dreams Sandwich dark chocolate peanut butter and cherry jam, stuffed with shredded coconut it's pb&j meets black forest cake       6.75
The Bee's Knees Sandwich the bee's knees peanut butter with apple butter, sprinkled with wheat germ wholesome and beelicious       6.50
Mighty Maple Sandwich mighty maple peanut butter with crispy bacon, a mighty fine combination       6.50
Peanut Butter Sampler a sampling of our peanut butters, served with melba toast and freshly cut carrots, celery, and apple slices, it's crudite our way       8
Pb&j of the Week a new take on america's favorite sandwich every seven days please ask your server for details       7
other homestyle fare
Tuna Fish Sandwich mom’s secret recipe, made with solid white albacore tuna and served with lettuce and tomato       6.75
Tuna Melt a grilled tuna fish & cheese sandwich always satisfying       7.25
Chicken Salad Sandwich all white meat chicken breast and the freshest herbs served with lettuce and tomato it's the best you'll ever try       6.75
Grilled Cheese Sandwich made with real butter and american cheese - it melts in your mouth       5.75
Add Even Better With Bacon       1
Add Sliced Tomato       .50
Baloney & Cheese Sandwich all beef bologna, served with mayo, mustard and american cheese       6
Turkey Sandwich all white meat smoked turkey breast, served with lettuce, tomato, mayo & mustard       7
Salad Bowl light and refreshing salad greens with lots of fresh chopped veggies       6
Add Tuna or Chicken Salad       1.50
save room for dessert
Peanut Butter Cookies our own recipe, famous the world over crunchy peanut butter cookies with that familiar crisscross pattern we all came to love as children     each 1.50   (4 for) 5
Peanut Butter Brownies a rich, chocolaty brownie, with swirls of peanut butter baked right in an unbelievable treat     each 3   (2 for) 5
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie made from scratch, this cool & creamy treat has a chocolate covered cookie crust and a rich peanut butter cream filling, each slice is topped with chopped peanut, chocolate and peanut butter chips       4.50
Peanut Butter Parfait a healthy treat, sliced bananas, creamy dannon vanilla yogurt, a dollop of peanut butter, honey and granola       4.50
Pb&j Pretzel Sundae simply fabulous our own crunchy outside and smooth inside peanut butter pretzel pieces on vanilla ice cream topped with raspberry sauce so yummy       5
Death by Peanut Butter Sundae peanut butter lovers, this is your sundae three scoops of ice cream on a bed of peanut butter cap n' crunch topped with peanut butter, whipped cream, reese's pieces, peanut butter chips and peanut butter sauce       6
Bananarama Sundae what a banana split three scoops of ice cream, sliced bananas, graham crackers, peanut butter, marshmallow fluff whipped creamy and chocolate sauce, wonderful for sharing if you are so inclined       6
Peanut Butter Brownie Black Sundae what could be better than peanut butter brownies and ice cream topped with peanut butter, chocolate and peanut butter chips, whipped cream & chocolate sauce       6
Peanut Butter Wafflewich Sundae waffles kicked up a notch two toaster waffles with peanut butter, ice cream, whipped cream & chocolate sauce       7
Peanut Butter Bliss Sundae all it will take is a scoop of vanilla ice cream with peanut butter, chocolate sauce and a dollop of whipped cream to bring you to a blissful slate       4.50
wash it down
Fresh Milk whole, lowfat or skim       1.75
Add chocolate, Strawberry or Malt Syrup       .50
Soy Milk, Rice milk       2.70
Add chocolate, Strawberry or Malt Syrup       .50
Coca-cola, Diet coke, Sprite       1.75
Flavored Coke chocolate, cherry, vanilla or lime       2.60
Cherry Lime Rickey       3.20
Stewarts Sodas orange & cream, cherries & cream, ginger beer, root beer, diet root beer, birch beer, cream soda, black cherry, key lime       2.25
Ny Egg Cream chocolate, vanilla or strawberry       3.10
Milkshakes chocolate, vanilla, strawberry       4.20
Add Peanut butter, Malt or Banana       .50
Peanut Butter Smoothie soy milk, peanut butter, bananas and honey, blended with ice       4.75
Tropicana Pure Premium Orange Juice       2.60
Sunkist Lemonade       2.25
Welch's Grape Juice       2
Martinelli's Apple Juice       2.50
Coffee-regular or Decaf       1.60
Iced Coffee       2.50
Espresso double shot       2.10
Cappuccino double shot       3.10
Mochaccino       3.60
Cafe Latte       3.10
Cafe Au Lait       2.10
Hot Chocolate       3.10
Hot Tea & Herbal Tea       1.60
Oregon Chai Tea       3.10
Iced Tea       2.50
Bottled Water       1.60
ice cream sodas $3.60
Root Beer Float root beer and vanilla ice cream      
Black Cow root beer and chocolate ice cream      
Purple Cow grape soda and vanilla ice cream      
Creamsicle orange soda and vanilla ice cream      
specialty shakes $5.25
Pb&j Shake peanut butter & jelly      
Mary Jane Shake peanut butter & honey, fluffernutter shake      
Peanut Butter & Marshmallow Fluff      
Coffee Shake with a shot of espresso      
peanut butter to go
Smooth operator*       5
Crunch Time       5
Cinnamon Raisin Swirl       6
The Heat Is on       6
White Chocolate wonderful*       6
Dark Chocolate dreams*       6
The Bee's Knees       6
Mighty Maple       6
The Big Six Gift Box       34

Menus provided by Menupages

Advertising