New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Penelope Café

Penelope Café Menu

  • Takeout Available | Delivery Available

breakfast

Eggs Any Style two farm fresh eggs any way you like ‘em. served with toast and house made home fries       8.50
Three Egg Omelette filled with your choice of three: mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, peppers, spinach, bacon, ham, sausage, or cheese (cheddar, american, swiss, brie, fontina, provolone, feta, or goat) served with toast and house made home fries       10
Buttermilk Pancakes dusted with powdered sugar & served with fresh fruit       9.75
I Love Waffles strawberry and toasted coconut waffles served with fresh fruit       9.75
Irish Oatmeal old school style, sprinkled with brown sugar then topped with fresh blueberries & dried cranberries       8
French Toast brioche french toast made with a hint of cinnamon, dusted with powdered sugar, and served with fresh fruit       9.75
Penny Egg Sandwich scrambled eggs with american cheese & pesto on a croissant or english muffin       8
With ham, sausage, Bacon, soysage, or fakin’ bacon       9
Abuelo’s Egg Sandwich eggs over medium with swiss cheese, grilled ham, and balsamic-mayo with black pepper on somun bread       9
Mabel’s Homemade Granola honey-sweetened oats, almonds, coconut, dried figs, apricots, and dried cranberries. served with milk       8
With Yogurt       9
Bag to Take to Your Sweetie       12
sides
Bacon or Grilled Ham       3.50
Chicken Apple sausage, soysage, or fakin’ Bacon       4.75
Side Salad with roasted garlic balsamic dressing       6
House Made Home Fries or French Fries       5
Fresh-baked Muffin       3.75
Raspberry Sour Cream Coffee Cake       5.50
Fresh Fruit       5
With Yogurt       6.50
beverages
Tea or Bottomless Coffee       2
Iced, Add       .75
Fresh Squeezed Lemonade       3.50
Fresh Squeezed Oj or Grapefruit Juice     sm 3.75   lg 5.50
Cranberry Juice     sm 2.50   lg 4
Espresso     sgl 2.50   dbl 3.50
Cappuccino or latté     sgl 3.75   dbl 4.50
Mocha     sgl 4   dbl 4.75
Coca cola, Diet coke, Cherry coke, Root beer, Ginger ale, & Sprite       2.50
spirits
Summer Rose Mimosa       9.50
Doreen's Sake Bloody Mary       9.50
White Peach Bellini       9.50
Southampton Beer Shandy       7.50
Lamberti Rose Spumante     gl 10   btl 36
Cava Brut Cristalino     gl 9   btl 33
Rose Sangria with papaya and strawberries     gl 9.50   pitcher 27

lunch & dinner

appetizers & sides
Hummus Plate       9
Abundio’s Guacamole       9.50
Warm Artichoke-spinach Dip       9.75
Side Salad with roasted garlic balsamic dressing       6
Chicken Meatballs with pesto       8.50
Mac & Cheese       7
French Fries       5
salads
Served With Lovely Handmade Bread
Curried Chicken Salad grilled chicken, currants, green apple, and peppers in a sweet and spicy curry dressing, garnished with toasted coconut       10.50
When Veggie Met Sally chopped greens with red onion, grilled veggie burger, and green apple tossed with goat cheese in a roasted garlic balsamic vinaigrette       11
Arugula With Warm Chicken Meatballs tossed in lemon-pesto vinaigrette with a light flurry of pecorino cheese       11
Arugula and White Bean with red onion and artichokes in lemon-pesto and green goddess dressings       10
Spinach and Beets with goat cheese, avocado, and crunchy croutons in a roasted garlic balsamic vinaigrette       11
Calamari Salad arugula with avocado and papaya in lemon-pesto and green goddess dressings, topped with panko-crusted calamari       14
plates
Mac & Cheese baked with fontina, american, and white cheddar, topped with tomato and breadcrumbs. served with a side salad       10.50
Ellie’s Spinach Pie yia yia’s greek country recipe with rich cheeses and flaky filo dough. served with a side salad       10.50
C.j.’s Fish and Chips tender haddock fillets served with tartar sauce, our homemade fries, and a dollop of balsamic mayo for good dippin’ times       14.50
Turtle Cove Lobster Roll fresh lobster meat tossed in a light lemon-mayo tucked snug in a brioche roll with greens. served with homemade fries       22
sandwiches
Served With a Side Salad Tossed in a Roasted Garlic Balsamic Vinaigrette
Warm Brie and Green Apple with honey mustard on 7-grain toast       9.50
With chicken, Ham or fakin’ Bacon       11
Grilled Chicken With Artichokes arugula, tomato, and pesto mayo on somun bread       11
Hummus and Avocado with tomato, red onion, arugula, and a drizzle of balsamic dressing on somun bread       10.50
Jason’s Egg Salad and Asparagus in a lemon-mayo on toasted black bread with greens       9.50
grilled sandwiches
Served on Our Lovely Breads With Homemade French Fries Cooked in Canola Oil
Grilled Three Cheese with swiss, fontina, and white american on sourdough       9.50
With pesto, tomato, And/or Artichoke Hearts       10.50
Bblt double bacon, lettuce, and tomato with black pepper balsamic mayo on toasted sourdough       10
Fblt fakin’ bacon, avocado, lettuce, and tomato with black pepper balsamic mayo on toasted sourdough       11.50
Veggie Burger Heaven flame-grilled garden burger on a toasted english muffin with pesto mayo, red onion, lettuce, and tomato       11
Juicy Beef Burger lean ground sirloin, flame-grilled, with red onion, lettuce, and tomato on a toasted sesame seed brioche bun       11.50
The Hilly Cheesesteak thinly sliced pieces of steak, grilled together with melted provolone cheese, red peppers, onions, and mushrooms with mayo on lightly toasted somun bread       11.50
Grilled Chicken Club grilled chicken with crispy bacon, melted fontina, honey mustard, mayo, lettuce, and tomato on toasted baguette       11
Nice Chicken Meatballs chicken meatballs, melted fontina, tomato, and pesto mayo on hollowed out baguette       11

brunch $15

Prix-fixe With a Summer rosé mimosa, White Peach bellini, or Coffee/tea and Juice

Nutella French Toast brioche french toast filled with warm chocolate hazelnut filling, dusted with powdered sugar, served with a side of fresh fruit      
One Night Stand Waffles toasted coconut and luscious strawberry waffles served with fresh fruit. these are not the marrying kind      
Farmer’s Market Omelette farm fresh egg omelette filled with your choice of three: mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, peppers, spinach, bacon, ham, sausage, or cheese. served with toast and house made home fries      
Salmon Wrapped Poached Eggs two farm fresh eggs wrapped in smoked salmon on toasted black bread with green goddess dressing. served with a side salad      
Sam I Am two farm fresh eggs scrambled with grilled asparagus and crumbled feta cheese. served with your choice of toast and homemade home fries      
Ellie’s Spinach Pie yia yia’s greek country recipe with rich cheeses and flaky filo dough. served with a side salad      
When Veggie Met Sally chopped greens with red onion, grilled veggie burger, and green apple tossed with goat cheese in a roasted garlic balsamic vinaigrette      
Bblt double bacon, lettuce, and tomato with black pepper balsamic mayo on toasted sourdough. served with homemade french fries      
Fblt fakin’ bacon, avocado, lettuce, and tomato with black pepper balsamic mayo on toasted sourdough. served with homemade french fries      
a la carte
Eggs Any Style two farm fresh eggs any way you like ‘em. served with toast and house made home fries       8.50
Mabel’s Homemade Granola honey-sweetened oats, almonds, coconut, dried figs, apricots, and dried cranberries. served with milk       8
With Yogurt       9
Irish Oatmeal old school style. sprinkled with brown sugar then topped with fresh blueberries & dried cranberries       8
Penny Egg Sandwich scrambled eggs with american cheese & pesto on a croissant or english muffin       8
With ham, sausage, Bacon, soysage, or fakin’ bacon       9
Abuelo’s Egg Sandwich eggs over medium with swiss cheese, grilled ham, and balsamic-mayo with black pepper on somun bread       9
Veggie Burger Heaven flame-grilled garden burger on a toasted english muffin with pesto mayo, red onion, greens and tomato. served with homemade french fries       11
sides
Cinnamon Bun       4
Fresh-baked Muffin or Scone       3.75
Raspberry Sour Cream Coffee Cake       5.50
Bacon or Grilled Ham       3.50
Chicken Apple sausage, soysage, or fakin’ Bacon       4.75
Side Salad with roasted garlic balsamic dressing       6
House Made Home Fries or French Fries       5
Fresh Fruit       5
With Yogurt       6.50
beverages
Tea or Bottomless Coffee       2
Iced, Add       .75
Fresh Squeezed Lemonade       3.50
Fresh Squeezed Oj or Grapefruit Juice     sm 3.75   lg 5.50
Cranberry Juice     sm 2.50   lg 4
Espresso triple (go back to bed)     sgl 2.50   dbl 3.50
Cappuccino or latté     sgl 3.75   dbl 4.50
Mocha     sgl 4   dbl 4.75
Coca cola, Diet coke, Cherry coke, Root beer, Ginger ale, & Sprite       2.50
dessert
Mama’s Carrot Cake with ginger cream cheese frosting       5.50
Red Velvet Cake with cream cheese frosting       5.50
Sour Cream Raspberry Coffee Cake with toasted almonds       5.50
Strawberries and Warm Nutella       5
Milk & Cookies choose two with a glass of milk or get one at a time for a tasty treat. (peanut butter oatmeal chocolate chip, chocolate chocolate chip, or classic chocolate chip) (2. per cookie)       5
Magic Bar with coconut, chocolate chips, and walnuts       3
Peanut Butter Blondie with heath bar crunch       3
Vanilla Cupcake with vanilla buttercream       2.50
Chocolate Cupcake with mocha buttercream       2.50
Seasonal treat(s) ask your server about our special seasonal something. yum      
dessert wine
Chateau de caladroy, Muscat de Rivesaltes 2007 roussillon, France a sweet complex nose of white fruits. enjoy the notes of citrus and orange flowers while you canoodle with your favorite cupcake       gl 7
Advertising