New York Magazine

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Home > Restaurants > Sarabeth's

Sarabeth's Menu

breakfast

Served Until 3:30pm

fruity beginnings
Four Flowers Juice a special blend of orange, fresh pineapple, banana and pomegranate juice       6.75
Freshly Squeezed Orange or Grapefruit Juice       6.25
Morning Fruit Bowl grapefruit and orange sections, sliced banana and strawberries       8.50
cereals
Oatmeal Served Until 11:30am. Sarabeth’s Hot Porridge ‘three Bears style’
Baby Bear hot porridge, milk, honey       7.50
Mama Bear hot porridge, fresh cream, raisins, honey       7.50
Papa Bear hot porridge, strawberries, bananas, fresh cream, raisins, honey       8
Big Bad Wolf hot porridge, wheatberries, fresh cream, butter, brown sugar       8
Morning Crunch freshly roasted granola, bananas, raisins, honey, choice of milk or yogurt       8
extra ordinary eggs & omelettes
All Eggs Served With Choice of Muffin (english, corn, bran, banana, pumpkin, Berry corn) croissant, Scone or Toast (seven Grain or sourdough) and Preserves
Green and White scrambled eggs, scallions, cream cheese       13
Goldie Lox scrambled eggs, smoked salmon, cream cheese       14.74
Classic Eggs Benedict * canadian smoked ham, hollandaise sauce, peppers, chives       16.75
Salmon Eggs Benedict * irish smoked salmon, hollandaise sauce, peppers, chives       16.75
Frittata of Mixed vegetables, Gruyère and Bacon       13.75
Popeye Eggs * scrambled eggs on an english muffin, black forest ham, sautéed spinach       14.25
The Red Omelette chunky filling of red pepper and tomatoes, cheddar cheese, dollop of sour cream, chives       14.25
Garden Omelette broccoli, corn, carrots, vermont cheddar cheese       13.75
Farmer’s Omelette leeks, ham, chunks of potato and gruyère       14.25
Spinach and Goat Cheese Omelette       13.75
Cheese Omelette with gruyère or white cheddar cheese       12.75
Sunnyside up, coddled, Scrambled eggs, Plain Omelette       10.50
sides
Three-pepper Home Fried Potatoes       6.50
Country Bacon Strips       7.25
Fresh Chicken Apple Breakfast Sausage       7.25
Holland Pork and Apricot Sausage       7.25
sweet breakfast $14.75
Served With Warm Organic Maple Syrup From Doerfler’s Farm
Fat and Fluffy French Toast with fresh strawberries      
Lemon and Ricotta Pancakes with fresh berries      
Pumpkin Waffle topped with sour cream, raisins, pumpkin seeds and honey      
Buttermilk Pancakes with fresh strawberries      
Cheese Blintzes with sour cream and apple butter      
lunch
Mon-fri: 11:30am-3:30pm
Sara’s Famous Velvety Cream of Tomato Soup with cheddar cheese       8.75
Scrumptious Market Soups made daily from scratch your server will tell you all about them      
Caesar Salad romaine, aged parmesan, anchovy dressing, semolina parmesan croutons       14
Sliced Chicken Breast Additional       4.75
Poached Shrimp mixed baby greens, lime vinaigrette       19
Chopped Market Vegetable Salad Plate chopped seasonal vegetables, baby field greens, crumbled maytag bleu cheese, sherry shallot vinaigrette       15.75
Sliced Chicken Breast       additional 4.75
Roasted Chicken Salad With Walnuts and Chives endive, market vegetables and fresh chervil       18.75
Poached Organic Salmon Cobb Salad corn, tomato relish, chopped lettuce, peppers and cracked wheat, basil buttermilk dressing       18.50
Maine Lobster Roll cole slaw, home made chips, bread and butter pickles       25
Free-range Chicken Pot Pie pearl onions, baby carrots, potatoes, peas, puff pastry top       19.75
Penne Madison goat cheese, sautéed spinach, garlic, toasted pine nuts, and herbed breadcrumbs       17.50
Chicken Paillard Salad baby spinach, fava beans, yellow cherry tomatoes, hungarian feta       19
Grilled Portobello Sandwich roasted peppers, arugula, toasted ciabatta roll, olive tapenade, crisp fries       16.75
Grilled Tuna Nicoise organic greens, baby carrots, haricot vert, hard boiled egg, black olives, tomatoes, grilled onion, sherry shallot vinaigrette       21
One Great Burger freshly ground turkey or sirloin, or vegetable burger, grilled spring onion, lettuce, tomato, avocado salsa, brioche bun, fries       15.75
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake Sandwich matchstick fries, tartar sauce, roasted beets, watercress and apple salad       21
Lemon-zested Tuna Salad grilled sourdough, fresh tomatoes marinated in extra virgin olive oil, balsamic vinegar, basil       17
New Classic Club Sandwich turkey breast, fresh mozzarella, virginia ham, lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing, seven grain bread       16.50
Grilled Smoked Mozzarella Sandwich avocado and fresh tomatoes on seven grain bread       14.25
drink specials
Pickled House Bloody Mary       10
Four Flowers Mimosa       10
J. Rogét Mimosa orange, cranberry, four flowers or mango       9
Fresh Bellini       9

dinner

Sample Menu

appetizers
Sara’s Famous Velvety Cream of Tomato Soup with cheddar cheese       8.75
Daily Market Soups      
Organic Spinach and Fried Green Tomato goat cheese and spiced walnuts, apple cider vinaigrette       10.25
Smoked Salmon Potato Pancake baked latke with sliced nova scotia salmon, sour cream drizzle and golden caviar       11.25
Pumpkin Seed Crusted Sea Scallops anjou pears, hearts of palm and organic arugula, walnut vinaigrette       12.50
Seasonal Market Salad accented with a small dice of prosciutto and montgomery cheddar       9.50
Grilled Eggplant and Fresh Mozzarella organic baby arugula, sundried tomatoes, grilled herb focaccia, balsamic vinaigrette       12.50
Pan-seared Jumbo Lump Crab Cake fresh corn and black bean salsa, roasted red pepper remoulade       14
Chicken Quesadilla vermont cheddar, sour cream, guacamole and tomato salsa       12.25
Rock Shrimp Risotto oven-roasted tomatoes, fava beans, and fresh chervil       12
Sara’s Organic Greens orange supreme, blue cheese croutons, grape tomatoes, mustard herb vinaigrette       8
Caesar Salad romaine, anchovy dressing, parmesan crisp and brioche croutons       9
entrees
Grilled Long Island Duck Breast dried apricots and cranberries, port wine sauce, wild rice scallion pancakes, sautéed haricot vert       24
Free-range Chicken Pot Pie pearl onions, baby carrots, english peas, fingerling potatoes, topped with puff pastry       20
Seafood Cobb Salad fresh lobster, lump crabmeat, shrimp, avocado, chopped romaine, tomato onion relish, hard-boiled eggs, blue cheese, crisp bacon, sherry vinaigrette       25
Nature Calves Liver smoked bacon, caramelized onions and red peppers, chive mashed potatoes, baby carrots       21
Lemon Zest and Fresh Herb Crusted Organic Chicken Breast bacon cheddar mashed potatoes and haricot vert       23
Atlantic Salmon israeli couscous with caramelized onions and aromatic vegetables, grilled portobello and red wine jus       25
Broiled Jumbo Shrimp coconut curry sauce, peach chutney, saffron risotto, sautéed spinach       24
Grilled Prime Dry Aged Sirloin Steak oyster mushrooms, caramelized onions, roasted peppers, zinfandel wine sauce, sweet potato fries, sautéed broccoli       29
Mozzarella & Roasted Pepper Stuffed Ravioli with asparagus, oven-roasted tomatoes, toasted pine nuts, olive oil, garlic and fresh herbs       22
One Great Burger fresh ground sirloin or turkey, or vegetable with arugula, tomato, avocado, hand-cut fries and slaw       16
Macadamia Nut Crusted Cod seven vegetable broth, apple-celery root purée, sautéed haricot vert       24
Maine Lobster Roll cole slaw, home made chips bread and butter pickles       24
(1/2) Pound Lobster Special with crabmeat stuffing, mashed potatoes and garlic butter served with sara's organic greens or a daily market soup to start and your choice of our fresh fruit bowl or truffle slice       34
side dishes $6.50 each
Seasonal Vegetables sautéed or steamed      
Hand-cut French Fries      
Sweet Potato Fries      
Half and Half 1/2 spinach 1/2 mashed cheddar potatoes      

dinner prix fixe $32

appetizers
Daily Market Soups
Market Salad accented with a small dice of prosciutto and montgomery cheddar      
Artichoke Risotto oven-roasted tomatoes, fava beans, and fresh chervil      
entrees
Atlantic Salmon israeli couscous, caramelized onions and aromatic vegetables, grilled portobello, red wine jus      
Grilled Flat Iron Steak gorgonzola butter, red wine jus, garlic mashed potatoes, sautéed broccoli      
Arugula & Ricotta Stuffed Ravioli with roasted peppers, grilled squash, toasted pine nuts, olive oil, garlic and fresh herbs      
desserts
Sarabeth’s Cookie Plate      
Chocolate Truffle Cake      
Fruit Bowl      

brunch

Sat-sun: 8am-4pm

fruity beginnings
Four Flowers Juice a special blend of orange, fresh pineapple, banana and pomegranate juice       6.75
Freshly Squeezed Orange or Grapefruit Juice       6.75
Sundials of Fresh Grapefruit and Orange Sections with yogurt and sprinkled with roasted granola       8.50
cereals
Oatmeal Served Until noon, Granola Until 4pm. Sarabeth’s Hot Porridge ‘three Bears style’
Baby Bear hot porridge, milk, honey       7.50
Mama Bear hot porridge, fresh cream, raisins, honey       8.50
Papa Bear hot porridge, strawberries, bananas, fresh cream, raisins, honey       8.50
Big Bad Wolf hot porridge, wheatberries, fresh cream, butter, brown sugar       8.75
Morning Crunch freshly roasted granola, bananas, raisins, honey, choice of milk or yogurt       9.50
extra ordinary eggs & omelettes
All Eggs Served With Choice of Muffin (english, corn, bran, banana, pumpkin, Berry corn) croissant, Scone or Toast (seven Grain or sourdough) and Preserves
Green and White scrambled eggs, scallions, cream cheese       13.50
Goldie Lox scrambled eggs, smoked salmon, cream cheese       15.75
Classic Eggs Benedict * canadian smoked ham, hollandaise sauce, peppers, chives       17.50
Salmon Eggs Benedict * irish smoked salmon, hollandaise sauce, peppers, chives       17.50
Frittata of Mixed vegetables, Gruyere and Bacon       14
Country Breakfast scrambled eggs, warm cheddar grits custard, bacon strips, roasted red pepper sauce       16
Huevos Rancheros * eggs, black beans, tomatillo, tortillas       18.50
The Red Omelette chunky filling of red pepper and tomatoes, cheddar cheese, dollop of sour cream, chives       14.75
Popeye Eggs * scrambled eggs on english muffin, black forest ham, sautéed spinach       14.75
Farmer’s Omelette leeks, ham, chunks of potato and gruyere       14.75
Spinach and Goat Cheese Omelette       14
Cheese Omelette with gruyere or white cheddar cheese       13
Sunnyside up, coddled, Scrambled eggs, Plain Omelette       11
sweet breakfast $15.75
Served With Warm Organic Maple Syrup From Doerfler’s Farm
Buttermilk Pancakes with fresh strawberries      
Lemon and Ricotta Pancakes with fresh berries      
Whole Wheat Pancakes with bananas and wheatberries      
Pumpkin Waffle topped with sour cream, raisins, pumpkin seeds and honey      
Crisp Potato Waffle with chicken apple breakfast sausage, chunky apple sauce and sour cream      
Fat and Fluffy French Toast      
Apple-cinnamon French Toast with bananas      
Almond-crusted French Toast with cranberry-cherry sauce      
Cheese Blintzes with sour cream and apple butter      
sides
Basket of Sarabeth’s Muffins and Legendary Preserves       13
Three-pepper Home Fried Potatoes       6.50
Country Bacon Strips       7.25
Fresh Chicken Apple Breakfast Sausage       7.25
Holland Pork and Apricot Sausage       7.25
lunch extras
11Am-4pm
Sara's Famous Velvety Cream of Tomato Soup with cheddar cheese       9
Scrumptious Market Soups made daily from scratch      
Roasted Chicken Caesar Salad romaine, aged parmesan, anchovy dressing, brioche crouton       18.50
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake Sandwich matchstick fires, tartar sauce, roasted beet, watercress and apple salad       21
Maine Lobster Roll cole slaw, home made chips, bread and butter pickles       25
Lemon-zested Tuna Salad grilled sourdough, fresh tomatoes marinated in extra virgin olive oil, balsamic vinegar, basil       17.75
New Classic Club Sandwich turkey breast, fresh mozzarella, virginia ham, lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing, seven grain bread       16.50
Seafood Cobb Salad fresh lobster, lump crabmeat, shrimp, avocado, chopped romaine, tomato onion relish, hard boiled eggs, blue cheese, crisp bacon, sherry vinaigrette       26
harney & sons fine teas $4.25
English Breakfast      
Darjeeling      
Earl Grey      
Decaffeinated Earl Grey      
Decaffeinated Darjeeling      
Organic Sencha      
Citron Green      
Egyptian Chamomile      
Spiced Plum Herbal      
Peppermint Herbal      
Raspberry Herbal      
Jasmine      
drink specials
Pickled House Bloody Mary       10.50
Four Flowers Mimosa       10.50
J. Rogét Mimosa orange, cranberry, four flowers or mango       9
Fresh Bellini       9
cocktails
Five Flowers Cocktail       11.50
Sangria       12.50
Four Flower Martini       12.50
Apple Martini       11.50
Cosmopolitan       11.50
Mojito       12.50
Margarita del Rey       11.50
Pitcher of Mojito or Sangria       26
bottled beer
Bass Ale       7
Amstel Light       7
Heineken       7
Stella Artois       7.50
Haack Beck non-alcoholic       6.50
Hoegaarden       8.50
Beck’s Dark       8
Redhook       8.50
beverages
Pitcher of Harney and Sons Iced Tea       5.50
Martinelli’s Sparking Apple Cider       4.75
Vero Bottled Water sparkling or natural     sm 3.25   lg 6.50
Pepsi, Diet pepsi, 7up, Schweppes Ginger Ale       3.50
Freshly Brewed Sunberry ‘special blend’ Coffee       4
Sunberry Organic Espresso       4
Cappuccino       4.75
Sara’s Hot Chocolate Parisienne       5.50

tea

specialty soup $8.75
Sara’s Famous Velvety Cream of Tomato Soup with cheddar cheese      
Daily Market Soups made fresh daily ask your server about today’s selections      
Spinach and Goat Cheese Omelette served with choice of muffin or toast       13.75
Roasted Chicken Caesar Salad romaine, aged parmesan, anchovy dressing, and brioche croutons       19
Maine Lobster Roll coleslaw, homemade chips, bread and butter pickles       25
Penne Madison goat cheese, sautéed spinach, garlic, toasted pine nuts and herbed breadcrumbs       17.50
One Great Burger freshly ground turkey or sirloin, or vegetable burger, grilled spring onion, lettuce, and avocado salsa on a brioche bun, served with fries       15.75
New Classic Club Sandwich turkey breast, fresh mozzarella, virginia ham, lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing, on seven grain bread       16.50
Free-range Chicken Pot Pie pearl onions, baby carrots, potatoes, and peas, topped with puff pastry       19.75
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake Sandwich matchstick fries, tartar sauce, roasted beets, and watercress apple salad       21
Lemon-zested Tuna Salad grilled sourdough, fresh tomatoes marinated in extra virgin olive oil, balsamic vinegar, and basil       17
afternoon tea
With Finger Sandwiches
Smoked Salmon with cucumber, cream cheese and fresh mint       14.50
Chicken Salad with raisins, walnuts and dill       14.50
Radish and Cucumber with lettuce and cream cheese       14.50
Black Forest Ham with brie cheese       14.50
Scones, cookies, Jams and Clabber       21
harney & sons loose-leaf tea
Your Choice of
English Breakfast classic blend of formosa and ceylon teas      
Earl Grey Supreme citrusy blend of premium ceylon vintage silver tips and bergamot      
Orange Pekoe classic blend of strong assam and smooth liquoring ceylon for a mellow cup of tea      
Darjeeling light, mellow tea from the himalayan highlands      
Decaffeinated Earl Grey decaffeinated ceylon tea scented with natural oil of bergamot      
Organic Sencha japanese green tea with a fresh vegetal taste      
Jasmine pouching tea with jasmine flowers      
Chamomile Herbal whole chamomile flowers for a calming cup of tea      
Peppermint Herbal fresh and crisp, peppermint leaves from oregon      
Lemon Herbal a light and soothing alternative to chamomile      
Citron Green delicate citrus flavor      
Raspberry Herbal a mixture of rosehips, hibiscus, raspberry leaves      
Spiced Plum a hearty herbal infusion with the delightful essence of cinnamon and plums      
Five Flowers Cocktail four flowers juice, elderflower liqueur, champagne       11.50
J. Rogét Mimosa choice of orange, cranberry, four flowers, or mango       9
Fresh Bellini       9
Vero Sparkling or Natural Water     sm 3.25   lg 6.50
Martinelli’s Sparkling Apple Cider       4.75
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice       6.50
Sunberry Madison Blend Coffee       4
Sunberry Organic Espresso       4
Cappuccino       4.75
Harney & Sons Tea       4.25
Pitcher of Iced Tea       5.50
desserts
Lattice-topped Cherry Tart with vanilla ice cream and valhrona chocolate balsamic sauce       8.50
Chocolate soufflé Cake with whipped cream & a strawberry       8.50
Chocolate Truffle Cake layers of chocolate-orange cake, filled with ganache covered with a coffee-bittersweet chocolate glaze       8.50
Strawberry Shortcake with whipped cream & strawberries       8
Towering Meyer-lemon Meringue Tart of lemon curd and vanilla meringue       8.50
Warm Raspberry Bread Pudding with anglaise and raspberry coulis       8.50
Lemon Cheesecake with orange-apricot sauce and candied ginger       8.50
Classic Creme Brulee       8.50
Triple-chocolate Pudding       8
Sarabeth's Signature Cookie Plate palmier, chocolate-dipped orange sandwich cookie, chocolate chubbie, shortbread dove, and chocolate chip       8.50
With a Glass of Moscato D'asti       12
Flying Saucer Ice Cream Sandwich rainbow shortbread cookies sandwiched with tahitian vanilla ice cream and caramel sauce       9
Sarabeth's Ice Cream Sundae chocolate, vanilla, or strawberry ice cream with coconut, homemade marshmallows and chunky strawberry sauce       9
Assorted Fresh Fruit Platter with ciao bella sorbet       10.50
Sarabeth's Ice Creams & Sorbets ask your server for today's selection       8.50
digestifs
J. Roget Cocktail       9
Moscato D’asti       8.50
Bailey’s Hot Chocolate       9.50
Chocolate Martini       11
Irish Coffee       9
Laurent Parrier Brut Nv 1/2 Btl       30
Ports Bailey’s Irish Cream       9.50
Cointreau       8.50
Drambuie       8
Frangelico       8.50
Grand Marnier       9
Kahlua       8.50
Sambuca Romano       9.50
Taylor Fladgate First Estate       9
Smith, Woodhouse madalena 1995       9
Grahams 10 year tawny       9
Cockburns 20 year tawny       15
Grahams 1983 vintage port       22
Amaretto di Saronno       9.50
Sunberry Madison Blend Coffee       4
Sunberry Organic Espresso       4
Cappuccino       4.75
Hot Tea       4.25
ice cream $7.50 each
Vanilla with orange marmalade and chocolate chips      
Lemon with billy’s blues mixed berry preserves      
Chocolate with chocolate chubbie chunks      
Pistachio with fudge brownie chunks      
Espresso with cloud cookies      
Vanilla Bean      
Ginger      
cocktails
J. Rogét Mimosa       8.50
Four Flower Mimosa       9.50
Classic Martini vodka or gin, dry vermouth, olives       11
Four Flower Martini absolut, cointreau, four flowers juice       12
Apple Martini vodka, sour apple puckers, triple sec       11
Cosmopolitan absolut citron, cointreau, cranberry and a splash of lime       11
Chelsea Hotel gin, cointreau, lime       12
Margarita tequila, sour mix and lime       11
Margarita del Rey tequila, triple sec, grand marnier       11
Old-fashioned whiskey, crushed oranges, sugar       9

bakery

specialties
Truffle Slice       5.50
Souffle Slice       5
Creme Brulee       5
Mousse Slice       5.50
Crumb Pie       6
Pecan Tart       6.50
Bread Pudding       6.75
Chocolate Pudding       6
muffins
Banana       2.50
Bran       2.50
Corn       2.25
English       2.50
Pumpkin       2.50
Blueberry Corn       2.25
Scone or Mini Scone       2.25
Croissant       2.50
Pain Du Matin       2.50
cookies
Bear shortbread       1.35
Chocolate Chip       1.50
Chubbies       1.75
Clouds       1.75
Nut Crescents       .75
Doves       1.35
Linzer Hearts       1.85
Palmiers       1.50
Rugelach       1.25
Chocolate Sandwich with orange marmalade       1.75
Elephants with white chocolate       1.75
Chocolate Heart       1.75
cookie jars $14
Chocolate Chip Jar      
Chocolate Shortbread Jar      
Classic Shortbread Jar      
Oatmeal Raisin Jar      
cakes
Slice $2.75 / Loaf $8 / Small Cake $15 / Large Cake $25
Banana slice and loaf      
Budapest slice, loaf, small and large bundt      
Lemon slice, loaf, small and large bundt      
Poppy Seed slice, loaf      
Chocolate Cherry slice, loaf      
Chocolate Souffle slice, small or large cake      
ice cream
1 Scoop $2.50 / 2 Scoops $3.50 / Pint $6
Vanilla Bean      
Ginger      
Pistachio Ice Cream with brownie chunks      
Espresso Ice Cream with cloud cookies      
Chocolate with chubbie chunks      
Lemon with billy’s blue mixed berry      
Vanilla with orange marmalade and chocolate chips      
Sorbet varies      
jams
9Oz / 18oz
Orange Apricot Marmalade      
Strawberry Raspberry      
Strawberry Peach      
Peach Apricot      
Blood Orange Marmalade      
Apricot Pineapple      
Strawberry Rhubarb      
Chunky Apple      
Blueberry Cherry      
Pineapple Mango      
Mixed Berry      
Plum Cherry      
Cranberry Relish      
Mango Strawberry      
retail items
Hot Chocolate Tins       16
Flavored Iced Tea passion fruit       6.50
Organic Iced Tea       6.50
Tea Tins       8
Harney & Sons Loose Tea Small Tin       6
Granola Jar       7.50
Sunberry Madison Blend Coffee regular       9
Decaf       9
Advertising